MR

Posted: **Sat Jun 28, 2008 2:47 pm**

www.youtube.com/watch?v=HaaTEiWSM_A&feature=user

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wnIACW8kB7c&feature=user

contrary to what froy might have you believe, the place was almost sold out (capacity was around 8,000 - guesstimate) and the crowd was on its feet the whole time (that would include the drunk guy next to me who continuously screamed out ROBOTTO for 20 minutes @@)

all in all- a fun show. styx played for 70 minutes. usual set list w SMB & MITW thrown in, which made me very happy. i'd love to hear them do half penny 2 penny again, and queen of spades. hell- do the entire song of MITW. they do need to shake things up, but the addition of SMB was a pleasant surprise. i also really enjoyed boston (only stayed for an hour of their set though) they were not as "stiff" as i had anticipated. their new singer DOES need seasoning (lots!), but the rest of the band kicked ass. loved kimberly- she's awesome! great bass player. and all 3 guitar players rocked. there were lots of "guitarheros" and musicians in the audience. LOL boston is definitely a "guy band"

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 12:35 am**

stmonkeys wrote:www.youtube.com/watch?v=HaaTEiWSM_A&feature=user

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wnIACW8kB7c&feature=user

contrary to what froy might have you believe, the place was almost sold out (capacity was around 8,000 - guesstimate) and the crowd was on its feet the whole time (that would include the drunk guy next to me who continuously screamed out ROBOTTO for 20 minutes @@)

all in all- a fun show. styx played for 70 minutes. usual set list w SMB & MITW thrown in, which made me very happy. i'd love to hear them do half penny 2 penny again, and queen of spades. hell- do the entire song of MITW. they do need to shake things up, but the addition of SMB was a pleasant surprise. i also really enjoyed boston (only stayed for an hour of their set though) they were not as "stiff" as i had anticipated. their new singer DOES need seasoning (lots!), but the rest of the band kicked ass. loved kimberly- she's awesome! great bass player. and all 3 guitar players rocked. there were lots of "guitarheros" and musicians in the audience. LOL boston is definitely a "guy band"

Terrible version on SMB just pathetic
Shaw looks terrible
Not much to be proud of here

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 1:11 am**

stmonkeys wrote:www.youtube.com/watch?v=HaaTEiWSM_A&feature=user

WOW!! dang you were right on the stage!!! unbelievabel sound quality!!

this was GREAT!! man they just sound fantastic..

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 1:19 am**

froy wrote:Terrible version on SMB just pathetic
Shaw looks terrible
Not much to be proud of here

I disagree. You should be very proud. You didn't make any grammatical errors for a change. Your idiotic response was at least comprehendable.

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 1:58 am**

chowhall wrote:
froy wrote:Terrible version on SMB just pathetic
Shaw looks terrible
Not much to be proud of here

I disagree. You should be very proud. You didn't make any grammatical errors for a change. Your idiotic response was at least comprehendable.

I didn't make any errors but you did.
Gowan sings like he is in a freezer.
BRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR.
If you like this version of STYX more power to the 3 of you.
Its obvious by that video the jig is up and the news is out.
Sad days for Shaw and JY

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 2:29 am**

froy wrote:
chowhall wrote:
froy wrote:Terrible version on SMB just pathetic
Shaw looks terrible
Not much to be proud of here

I disagree. You should be very proud. You didn't make any grammatical errors for a change. Your idiotic response was at least comprehendable.

I didn't make any errors but you did.
Gowan sings like he is in a freezer.
BRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR.
If you like this version of STYX more power to the 3 of you.

Its obvious by that video the jig is up and the news is out.
Sad days for Shaw and JY

Froy you have been saying the same thing for TEN YEARS. and you are STILL WRONG!!!

btw....been waiting 2 years for that DDY CD to hit the states! HA HA HA HA

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 3:09 am**

froy wrote:
stmonkeys wrote:www.youtube.com/watch?v=HaaTEiWSM_A&feature=user

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wnIACW8kB7c&feature=user

contrary to what froy might have you believe, the place was almost sold out (capacity was around 8,000 - guesstimate) and the crowd was on its feet the whole time (that would include the drunk guy next to me who continuously screamed out ROBOTTO for 20 minutes @@)

all in all- a fun show. styx played for 70 minutes. usual set list w SMB & MITW thrown in, which made me very happy. i'd love to hear them do half penny 2 penny again, and queen of spades. hell- do the entire song of MITW. they do need to shake things up, but the addition of SMB was a pleasant surprise. i also really enjoyed boston (only stayed for an hour of their set though) they were not as "stiff" as i had anticipated. their new singer DOES need seasoning (lots!), but the rest of the band kicked ass. loved kimberly- she's awesome! great bass player. and all 3 guitar players rocked. there were lots of "guitarheros" and musicians in the audience. LOL boston is definitely a "guy band"

Terrible version on SMB just pathetic
Shaw looks terrible
Not much to be proud of here

You just can't stand the fact that this band plays this song with the energy it is meant to be played with. Your hero NEEDS the boys in Styx to sound like Styx! Nothing against the guys Dennis has playing with him, but they can't touch this version of Styx as players. Maybe if this song was played a cappella you may have a point but fortunately it is not.

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 3:18 am**

Tommy's voice sounds phenomenal. He still sings like a champ after all these years.

I really wish he and Dennis could patch things up and the two of them just do some music together the way Tommy and Jack have done. Tommy and Dennis had voices than melted together like butter.

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 3:25 am**

the wife would never stand for a fling with THAT mistress !!!

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 3:33 am**

stmonkeys wrote:www.youtube.com/watch?v=HaaTEiWSM_A&feature=user

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wnIACW8kB7c&feature=user

contrary to what froy might have you believe, the place was almost sold out (capacity was around 8,000 - guesstimate) and the crowd was on its feet the whole time (that would include the drunk guy next to me who continuously screamed out ROBOTTO for 20 minutes @@)

all in all- a fun show. styx played for 70 minutes. usual set list w SMB & MITW thrown in, which made me very happy. i'd love to hear them do half penny 2 penny again, and queen of spades. hell- do the entire song of MITW. they do need to shake things up, but the addition of SMB was a pleasant surprise. i also really enjoyed boston (only stayed for an hour of their set though) they were not as "stiff" as i had anticipated. their new singer DOES need seasoning (lots!), but the rest of the band kicked ass. loved kimberly- she's awesome! great bass player. and all 3 guitar players rocked. there were lots of "guitarheros" and musicians in the audience. LOL boston is definitely a "guy band"

Has the set been the same since they started with boston? If so I hope they keep smb and man in the wilderness in the set when they swing by wisconsin at the end of next month.

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 4:41 am**

Grotelul wrote:
You just can't stand the fact that this band plays this song with the energy it is meant to be played with. Your hero NEEDS the boys in Styx to sound like Styx! Nothing against the guys Dennis has playing with him, but they can't touch this version of Styx as players. Maybe if this song was played a cappella you may have a point but fortunately it is not.

I'm a fan of the current Styx - saw them with Burtnik once and three times with Phillips. But, don't knock Dennis's band... they ROCKED when I saw them. Their guitar playing was honestly a step above JY and TS's. And Dennis's voice is still 100% pristine - Tommy's is still in great shape, but he's lost a TINY TINY bit.

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 5:47 am**

[b]Froy you have been saying the same thing for TEN YEARS. and you are STILL WRONG!!!

The only thing wrong is this
How can you possibly defend that

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EgQ4gOCqQlw

Not 1 single person in the pavilion
Whats next JY singing hell hole?

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 5:49 am**

Terrible version on SMB just pathetic
Shaw looks terrible
Not much to be proud of here[/quote]

You just can't stand the fact that this band plays this song with the energy it is meant to be played with.

Energy?
Look at Shaw he's stiff
Gowan is a pathetic singer
What I can't stand is a terrible band butchering this great song.

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 11:02 am**

It's nice you were so close.

It's nice you had a great time.

It's not nice for this group to sing "Suite Madame Blue." Please. Just leave that one alone. It is not for the crappy of voice.

Bugsy

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 11:59 am**

Glad you went and had a good time. In the final analysis, that's what matters. Thanks for sharing.

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 12:10 pm**

bugsymalone wrote:It's not nice for this group to sing "Suite Madame Blue." Please. Just leave that one alone. It is not for the crappy of voice.

I liked hearing them do it. And I don't think Gowan has a "crappy" voice. Just because he doesn't have a power vibrato going 24/7 or hold the "MOOOOOOOOOOOoooore" for 38.4 seconds doesn't mean it's crappy. Different strokes. You don't like his voice. We got it, really. You don't ever go see current Styx in concert. We got that too. So what the hell difference does it make to you whether they play it or not? YOU DON'T HAVE TO LISTEN TO IT.

To paraphrase yourself: Please. Just leave it alone.

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 12:11 pm**

I think that's at the Nokia Theater in Grand Prairie. It seats between 6300 & 6400. Very nice venue.

I think they sound great.

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 3:03 pm**

yes, it was the nokia theatre. VERY nice. we had 3rd row seats, and of course we went for the "against the barricade upgrade"

the show would have been even better without the drunk guy next to me. but there's ALWAYS at least one.

Glad MOST of you enjoyed the clips. As far as MITW is concerned, i believe it's a permanent addition to the set for this tour. i saw them in March, and they played it then too. Just the first verse and chorus, right before Crystal Ball, which is also a permanent fixture as far as i can tell.

sorry, but i really ENJOYED hearing SMB. they haven't played it in almost a decade, and i'm glad they decide to "dust it off." i have no prob with gowan singing it. he has the stage presence and charisma to carry it off. the crowd loved it- really!!! but don't take my word for it. listen to the clip. you hear the cheers.

this was shot w my little cannon a620. i'm still surprised at how good the sound is. thanks everybody. i'll post a link to the pics i took.

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 3:38 pm**

here's crystal ball:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nEEPbeRFlKo

my friend karen shot this one.

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 4:10 pm**

this should be a link to my photo album:

http://share.shutterfly.com/action/welc ... nkid=link4

Posted: **Sun Jun 29, 2008 10:55 pm**

So what the hell difference does it make to you whether they play it or not? YOU DON'T HAVE TO LISTEN TO IT.

No. I don't. But others do and may think that is the way it is supposed to sound.

Definitely different strokes.

There are a lot of great songs in the Styx repertoire that fans would love to hear. It does not have to include SMB. My opinion -- and I don't plan on "leaving it alone."

I have zero problem with the other stuff they do, especially Tommy's songs, as he really is sounding quite good lately.

Bugsy

Posted: **Mon Jun 30, 2008 12:09 am**

bugsymalone wrote:
So what the hell difference does it make to you whether they play it or not? YOU DON'T HAVE TO LISTEN TO IT.

No. I don't. But others do and may think that is the way it is supposed to sound.

Oh gosh...on behalf of the people who actually attend these shows, thanks for the concern. I'm sure we all owe you a great debt. ;-)

By "supposed to sound like," you mean, like the original recording? Cuz...It's supposed to sound like a live performance. Hopefully one that entertains the crowd, which, in case you're wondering, always does. If you want to micromanage a song note-for-note, sit home and listen to your albums. If you want to have a concert experience, then go and enjoy yourself like everyone else.

And come to think of it, Dennis doesn't sound very much like he did back when SMB was first recorded either. His voice is much richer and deeper than it was back then - doesn't even sound like the same person. I prefer the original (and the 1983 recording) as well, but Dennis hasn't been able to get that sound from it since, IMO. But I'm not gonna bitch about it. It is what it is. I'd rather hear it played than not played - by either group. I love the song, and so does the crowd, regardless of who's singing it.

Posted: **Mon Jun 30, 2008 12:19 am**

Zan wrote:
bugsymalone wrote:
So what the hell difference does it make to you whether they play it or not? YOU DON'T HAVE TO LISTEN TO IT.

No. I don't. But others do and may think that is the way it is supposed to sound.

You mean, like the original recording? Well, Dennis doesn't sound very much like he did back when SMB was first recorded either. His voice is much richer and deeper than it was back then - doesn't even sound like the same person. I prefer the original (and the 1983 recording) as well, but Dennis hasn't been able to get that sound from it since, IMO. But I'm not gonna bitch about it. It is what it is. I'd rather hear it played than not played - by either group. I love the song, and so does the crowd, regardless of who's singing it.

Thanks for the concern, though. I'm sure the anonymous concert goers everywhere owe you a great debt.

As for what's it's supposed to sound like: It's supposed to sound like a live performance. Hopefully one that entertains the crowd, period. If you want to micromanage a song note-for-note, sit home and listen to your albums. If you want to have a concert experience, then go and enjoy yourself like everyone else.

Agreed as to this being your opinion. My opinion is ... already stated on this particular song.

Yep. Those anonymous concert goes DO owe me that great debt! :wink:

Especially if the band starts performing some of the really fantastic JY or Tommy songs from the catalog instead of this DeYoung signature piece.

[[ OPINION OF THIS POSTER ONLY!

]]

Bugsy

Posted: **Mon Jun 30, 2008 1:20 am**

bugsymalone wrote:My opinion is ... already stated on this particular song.

Yep. Those anonymous concert goes DO owe me that great debt! Especially if the band starts performing some of the really fantastic JY or Tommy songs from the catalog instead of this DeYoung signature piece.

And...as already stated, the opinion of someone who will never see the band without Dennis means exactly...what to the band in the way of working out their setlists? lol

Call me illogical, but it would seem to me that if any fan were to have an impact on helping them decide what to play, it would be one who actually bothers to go to the shows.

Posted: **Mon Jun 30, 2008 2:07 am**

"Zan""bugsymalone So what the hell difference does it make to you whether they play it or not? YOU DON'T HAVE TO LISTEN TO IT.

No. I don't. But others do and may think that is the way it is supposed to sound.

Oh gosh...on behalf of the people who actually attend these shows, thanks for the concern. I'm sure we all owe you a great debt.

By "supposed to sound like," you mean, like the original recording?

No she means that a goof who sounds like a chip monk should not be singing it.

Cuz...It's supposed to sound like a live performance.

Your right but when Gowan sings it sounds like a guy who needs a bowel movement.

Hopefully one that entertains the crowd, which, in case you're wondering, always does.

The video shows nobody in the crowd so I guess your wrong again
The entire pavilion empty,
I guess they have had enough of Gowans entertainment.

If you want to micromanage a song note-for-note, sit home and listen to your albums. If you want to have a concert experience, then go and enjoy yourself like everyone else.

By the looks of that video everyone else stayed home.

And come to think of it, Dennis doesn't sound very much like he did back when SMB was first recorded either. His voice is much richer and deeper than it was back then - doesn't even sound like the same person.

He sounds better than the original
You know it you just want to defend a band that draws 6 people at there shows.

Posted: **Mon Jun 30, 2008 2:13 am**

Zan

Call me illogical, but it would seem to me that if any fan were to have an impact on helping them decide what to play, it would be one who actually bothers to go to the shows.

And as we see in that video there is nobody going to there shows.
They are now in spinal tap country
Congrats to Styx from multi platinum to multi stupid thanks to Shaw and Young.

Posted: **Mon Jun 30, 2008 3:27 am**

Zan wrote:
bugsymalone wrote:My opinion is ... already stated on this particular song.

Yep. Those anonymous concert goes DO owe me that great debt! Especially if the band starts performing some of the really fantastic JY or Tommy songs from the catalog instead of this DeYoung signature piece.

And...as already stated, the opinion of someone who will never see the band without Dennis means exactly...what to the band in the way of working out their setlists? lol

Call me illogical, but it would seem to me that if any fan were to have an impact on helping them decide what to play, it would be one who actually bothers to go to the shows.

Dicey proposition for this band. Split fan base. Not going to please everyone. Glad I'm not in their position. No matter who the band/artist is, they will always face pro and con comments. And fans will usually argue and disagree about the comments. You each have validity.

Peace

Posted: **Mon Jun 30, 2008 4:28 am**

No she means that a goof who sounds like a chip monk should not be singing it.

A chip monk? Is that anything like the potato friar?

.

Posted: **Mon Jun 30, 2008 4:31 am**

Tanirocker wrote:A chip monk? Is that anything like the potato friar?

Snork.

Or a chocolate priest!

Pass the nachos.

Posted: **Mon Jun 30, 2008 4:35 am**

Zan wrote:
Tanirocker wrote:A chip monk? Is that anything like the potato friar?

Snork.

Or a chocolate priest!

Pass the nachos.

I heart my sarcasm sister Zan.

MR

Styx live in texas

Styx live in texas

Re: Styx live in texas

Re: Styx live in texas

Re: Styx live in texas

Re: Styx live in texas

Re: Styx live in texas

Re: Styx live in texas

Re: Styx live in texas

Re: Styx live in texas

Re: Styx live in texas

Re: Styx live in texas