Moderator: Andrew
Toph wrote:Give me a freakin break. Skulls, Knives going through angels, Charon on his boat....None of these are on brand. You would have never seen Styx from 1975 - 1998 align themselves with that kind of crap. Why these guys want to be a heavy metal band is beyond me. Its an embarrassment. Stop trying to be something you aren't. The manager Briscoe will do anything for a buck - including selling out what this band is/was. Yet another reason why fans of DDY think this incarnation of the band is a joke and is doing everything to bastardize what was built for 20 years.
I give Journey and Foreigner credit. Even though they have new lead singers, they at least are staying true to the brand and what these bands stood for. Styx is trying to be something that many of its core fans would never recognize. The class is gone from this band.
masque wrote:two things;
1) Charon is for sure "on brand" with a freaking band named Styx. yes as the years went by and their tampon rock become super popular then things associated with that kind of branding took a back seat, with the exception of their backwards satanic messages of course.
2) maybe they are morphing a bit, god forbid, possibly even changing a little bit….you sort of crack me up on this subject…….for the last couple of years you have bitched about them claiming to be rockers but in your eyes they really weren't acting like rockers with their look and music and now that they are actually moving in the direction they said they wanted to be and actually doing what they claimed then you bitch about that……..i would hate to be married to you
gr8dane wrote:Toph wrote:Give me a freakin break. Skulls, Knives going through angels, Charon on his boat....None of these are on brand. You would have never seen Styx from 1975 - 1998 align themselves with that kind of crap. Why these guys want to be a heavy metal band is beyond me. Its an embarrassment. Stop trying to be something you aren't. The manager Briscoe will do anything for a buck - including selling out what this band is/was. Yet another reason why fans of DDY think this incarnation of the band is a joke and is doing everything to bastardize what was built for 20 years.
I give Journey and Foreigner credit. Even though they have new lead singers, they at least are staying true to the brand and what these bands stood for. Styx is trying to be something that many of its core fans would never recognize. The class is gone from this band.
Fascinating.
Fans of DDY.
And why exactly should Styx care about what DDY fans like you think ?
Toph wrote:I give Journey and Foreigner credit. Even though they have new lead singers, they at least are staying true to the brand and what these bands stood for. Styx is trying to be something that many of its core fans would never recognize. The class is gone from this band.
Toph wrote:gr8dane wrote:Toph wrote:Give me a freakin break. Skulls, Knives going through angels, Charon on his boat....None of these are on brand. You would have never seen Styx from 1975 - 1998 align themselves with that kind of crap. Why these guys want to be a heavy metal band is beyond me. Its an embarrassment. Stop trying to be something you aren't. The manager Briscoe will do anything for a buck - including selling out what this band is/was. Yet another reason why fans of DDY think this incarnation of the band is a joke and is doing everything to bastardize what was built for 20 years.
I give Journey and Foreigner credit. Even though they have new lead singers, they at least are staying true to the brand and what these bands stood for. Styx is trying to be something that many of its core fans would never recognize. The class is gone from this band.
Fascinating.
Fans of DDY.
And why exactly should Styx care about what DDY fans like you think ?
They should care that they have bastardized the brand and that Styx now stands for nothing.
scarab wrote:do they sell the lazy susan for keyboards?
Toph wrote:masque wrote:two things;
1) Charon is for sure "on brand" with a freaking band named Styx. yes as the years went by and their tampon rock become super popular then things associated with that kind of branding took a back seat, with the exception of their backwards satanic messages of course.
2) maybe they are morphing a bit, god forbid, possibly even changing a little bit….you sort of crack me up on this subject…….for the last couple of years you have bitched about them claiming to be rockers but in your eyes they really weren't acting like rockers with their look and music and now that they are actually moving in the direction they said they wanted to be and actually doing what they claimed then you bitch about that……..i would hate to be married to you
I'm sure you embrace this change masque. Because you are the "new" fan that they are trying to attract. I'm sure you appreciate cheesy pseudo satanic rock and heavy metal, probably have a number of tattoos, and probably are on some type of government assistance. A nice night out on the town probably involves going to the Olive Garden. You vacation at Myrtle Beach, SC, Daytona, or the Atlantic City. I get it. This appeals to you.
But the fact of the matter is that they have no clue as to what their brand is or should be. Again, when you lose your key visionary that tends to happen. You put out crap music, sell coffee, Oh Mamma jewelry, and you then you want to persuade the world that you are some combination of Iron Maiden, Black Sabbath, and Ronnie James Dio. You appear on "That Metal Show" and look completely out of place. You want to erase from memory the fact that you were a complete top 40 band for most of your career and of your 8 highest charting hits, 5, arguably 6 were ballads. Of course with this new "metal focus" you add to your repertoire with such head bangers as Just Be and Difference in the World. The fact of the matter is this band and its management has no appreciation of its past, no appreciation of its brand, and tries to create a mish mash of elements that makes no strategic sense whatsoever.
scarab wrote:do they sell the lazy susan for keyboards?
masque wrote:i suppose that since i am a musician and have written songs myself that i understand as an artist that people and their tastes change. that's why as a rush fan i can enjoy their entire catalog….because as they changed i was ready for them to do something different. i didn't want moving pictures over and over.
Boomchild wrote:masque wrote:i suppose that since i am a musician and have written songs myself that i understand as an artist that people and their tastes change. that's why as a rush fan i can enjoy their entire catalog….because as they changed i was ready for them to do something different. i didn't want moving pictures over and over.
You know it's funny DDY made a similar comment when talking about the change in sound when it came to Cornerstone. He wanted to do something different then what they had been doing for the last several albums. The point is that some will like it and some will not. From my point of view the current Styx can do what they want. It doesn't mean that some will chuckle and poke fun at some of it though.
masque wrote:i agree 100%....and it also means that some people will not really care one way or another (which is mostly my view) and some will freaking love it....it's all good in my book and nothing to argue about.....i mean NONE of these bands are relevant anymore in any real way.......it's pretty much all nostalgia for all of them and that's cool.....im real glad that many of them are still out there playing.....but what they sell, record or anything they market, will have little to no change on the pop radar.......it only matters to the few hundred or possibly thousand people that still give a rat's ass.
Boomchild wrote:masque wrote:i agree 100%....and it also means that some people will not really care one way or another (which is mostly my view) and some will freaking love it....it's all good in my book and nothing to argue about.....i mean NONE of these bands are relevant anymore in any real way.......it's pretty much all nostalgia for all of them and that's cool.....im real glad that many of them are still out there playing.....but what they sell, record or anything they market, will have little to no change on the pop radar.......it only matters to the few hundred or possibly thousand people that still give a rat's ass.
The points you've made here are valid ones. We should be able to discuss our views without getting into arguments or turn the discussion into a personal attack on someone you don't share the same opinion. To me that is just someone stroking their own ego or insecurity. Your totally right that regardless of what DDY or the current Styx does is not going to impact where they are at this place in time. But, I have to say some of it is comical in both camps. The sad point is that you had a group of extremely talented individuals that came together and did some amazing things but, in the long run couldn't keep it together. It wasn't caused by one individual or event. If you believe that your just fooling yourself.
Boomchild wrote:Normally I would not bother to visit their site but this post peeked my interest. To me the shirts in question don't seem to fit the band image. Post the wooden nickel era I never felt the band focused on the the mythical nature of the bands name. At least from a dark side or pagan image. Listening to them I would never picture images like those on these shirts. Just seems like they are trying to put forth some kind of bad ass image. Nice try but a few decades too late. Now if they really wanted to make an image change perhaps some new music would be a more believable. These are shirts that you would expect to see bands like GNR and Sabbath do. Styx sure isn't like them at all.
Monker wrote:Boomchild wrote:Normally I would not bother to visit their site but this post peeked my interest. To me the shirts in question don't seem to fit the band image. Post the wooden nickel era I never felt the band focused on the the mythical nature of the bands name. At least from a dark side or pagan image. Listening to them I would never picture images like those on these shirts. Just seems like they are trying to put forth some kind of bad ass image. Nice try but a few decades too late. Now if they really wanted to make an image change perhaps some new music would be a more believable. These are shirts that you would expect to see bands like GNR and Sabbath do. Styx sure isn't like them at all.
What? No pagan imagery in this band? It's in their lyrics, especially on the PT and GI albums...that's just loopy for you to say.
Toph wrote:Monker wrote:Boomchild wrote:Normally I would not bother to visit their site but this post peeked my interest. To me the shirts in question don't seem to fit the band image. Post the wooden nickel era I never felt the band focused on the the mythical nature of the bands name. At least from a dark side or pagan image. Listening to them I would never picture images like those on these shirts. Just seems like they are trying to put forth some kind of bad ass image. Nice try but a few decades too late. Now if they really wanted to make an image change perhaps some new music would be a more believable. These are shirts that you would expect to see bands like GNR and Sabbath do. Styx sure isn't like them at all.
What? No pagan imagery in this band? It's in their lyrics, especially on the PT and GI albums...that's just loopy for you to say.
Idiotic statement. Why do you want them to be a satanic outfit? Yeah Show Me The Way is stating their undying love for the pagan Gods.
Toph wrote:Monker wrote:What? No pagan imagery in this band? It's in their lyrics, especially on the PT and GI albums...that's just loopy for you to say.
Idiotic statement. Why do you want them to be a satanic outfit? Yeah Show Me The Way is stating their undying love for the pagan Gods.
yogi wrote:Robot on the front of a Black Tee. Arrow thru the robots head with blood everywhere.
This matches the thought process of the current band.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests