RedWingFan wrote:So the entire book is discredited, not by what's in it, but by what's not in it?

That, and from observing the whiny old bitch make baseless predictions (like the Wright one) on O'Reilly for years now.
There's big money to be made playing the refs, and Goldberg has made a cottage industry out of it.
RedWingFan wrote:Not surprised coming from someone who's so quick to believe Kerry's "botched joke" excuse, which followed 30 some odd years of calling troops horrible names, ie: "reminescent of Ghengis Kahn".
Then turns around and tries to nail Limbaugh on "phony soldiers" after going over documented fake soldiers who claimed to be in Iraq, and decades of donating and raising funds that totals in the millions for our troops (which includes liberal troops)
The common unifier in the above block paragraph is ZERO context. You're intellectually dishonest.
Kerry made that "stuck in Iraq" remark on the heels of an anti-Bush joke in a speech that was loaded with them.
He wasn't testifying before Congress on 'Nam, why would he suddenly turn dour and attack the troops while campaigning for a colleague?
Short of making projections on his subconscious mind, you can't, and have yet to provide an answer.
As for Limbaugh, contrary to what you said, the "documented fake soldiers" weren't mentioned by either of the two callers Rush was speaking to. Nor had the fake soldier story of Jesse Macbeth even been mentioned that broadcast day. The topic at hand was soldiers who talk to the press in general. So again, unless your privy to the inner-goings on of Rushbo's mind, you can't possibly know what he meant.
Most revealing of all, even before the "phony soldiers" remark, when the first caller revealed himself to be an anti-Iraq Republican who served, Rush immediately cracked
"yea, and I used to walk on the moon."
Listen to the audio for yourself
http://mediamatters.org/items/200709270010