Moderator: Andrew
Saint John wrote:artist4perry wrote: Now, are all loons in the same catagory?
No. Some are good people that are merely fans that, to some degree, have blinders on, some are stalkers that should be put to sleep (see half of "Perryville") and some are lobotomized wastes of space that should be set on fire and tossed into a wood chipper.
whirlwind wrote:After all the trouble with how the band has treated or mistreated their frontman for the past decade and a half, you should maybe make some concessions in your blame game.
Gideon wrote:whirlwind wrote:Care to elaborate?
Certainly.
I preface this with full acknowledgment (and hope) that you're espousing Lunacy in total jest.whirlwind wrote:I would bet that Perry loves his loons most of all. We are the fans that never stopped believing in him and want only him singing the dirty doz. We are Journey/Perry all the way and just as he has no interest in the band, other than his time spent with them, neither do we.
What's the harm? I think that there is pride in being a Perryloon. He has a huge following of totally loyal fans who will accept no if ands or buts where he is concerned. I agree Carol, he can walk on water.
That's a dangerous and unheathly line of thought, if you're being serious, that most people reserve only for their chosen gods and religions. If Christians are correct, Jesus Christ was a man born without vice or sin and so enjoyed a certain status above saints and prophets; regarded by his followers as a perfect creature. Yet if they're to be believed, he also died for our weakness. You basically extend Steve Perry the same status, despite the fact that he has done nothing other than help give us some great music over the years and being born with an incredible voice. Great accomplishments to be sure, but hardly the stuff of someone who is faultless, as you have suggested that he is.whirlwind wrote:Oh, I am certain that he loves all his fans but as I wrote in my first sentence. I would bet that he loves his loons most of all. I didn't state it as fact, I wrote that I would bet.
Sure, there are lots of Steve Perry fans but some of these fans diss him for the decisions he made, all in good faith, during his time with the band. He gave his all to the band while he was able and has been a class act about that band up to the present.
I still think that he loves his loons best.whirlwind wrote:In my opinion, you're either a loon, such as I or you are simply a Steve Perry fan. A loon will only identify Journey with Perry and have complete understanding of his decisions while with the band.
It seems that many want to be considered a loon but forget it. It's all or nothing. Complete loyalty! No "I love him but...."
The embolded sentences strike a resonant chord of moral absolutism, which creates a schism, draws lines, and conjures thoughts of President Bush's infamous "you're with us or you're with the terrorists" line or, if you're a Star Wars fan, the great line "only a Sith deals in absolutes." You (again, hopefully jokingly) acknowledge that there is no acknowledgment of Steve Perry's mistakes during his tenure with the band, citing vague rationale that must be accepted in order to be a member in this most elite Order of Loons, saying it's all or nothing.
That's not something to be proud of. It's actually, quite frankly, sick.
Saint John wrote:whirlwind wrote:After all the trouble with how the band has treated or mistreated their frontman for the past decade and a half, you should maybe make some concessions in your blame game.
Journey has treated their frontmen just fine. They waited for Perry till the cows came home. They endured long layoffs, fired members, aborted lineups, and a recorded album that he had no intention of ever touring behind. He fired himself. They pulled Augeri from fixing shitters and he's now sitting at home rolling around in piles of money. Man, they treated him like shit!![]()
His demise was as much his own fault as anyone. While I doubt he came up with the insane idea of singing into a micrphone that wasn't on, he did do it. Soto came in and made mad cash while helping finish a tour. Unfortunately, after daily leaks about sensitive band information, drunken entourages embarrassing/pestering the band, other bands and management, and a change in what the band thought was the right direction, they made a change.
While a drunk Neal Schon had to be about as much fun to work with as snapping a mouse trap on your genitals, the man came to work every day and just wanted to write, record and tour. There's a "concession" for you.
portland wrote:I need more clarification - Can you be a Steve Perry fan and not want a replacement for the lead singer of Journey and not be a loon? I mean I don't want to see AP or anyone else for that matter sing the Journey songs that I listen to Steve Perry sing and co-wrote...I don't mind him singing stuff that was not already done by Perry...but for me I think it all should have been left alone. So does that make me a loon?
New here - remember be nice if you can
whirlwind wrote:
I do think that it was the fact that the band had a change of instruments at their disposal whereas Perry had only his vocals and he stopped and started when he felt he had to.
whirlwind wrote: In my opinion, you're either a loon, such as I or you are simply a Steve Perry fan. A loon will only identify Journey with Perry and have complete understanding of his decisions while with the band.
It seems that many want to be considered a loon but forget it. It's all or nothing. Complete loyalty! No "I love him but...."
whirlwind wrote:artist4perry wrote:Saint John wrote:artist4perry wrote:SJ there are layers of loondom. I for one do not see Steve as perfect, but as human, I agree with the post above. He has done his share of mistakes.
But bands fight, that is pretty common. I was not there, and I am staying out of their mess. I just want to love the music, and I am not into playing monday night psychiatrist on the band. Never been one for fault finding missions.
Steve is a great singer, and I have respect for his art. But I have no desire to follow, anoy, stalk, or be with him on a daily basis. I would like to meet him on his terms someday. Maybe a meet and greet. But this is not a lifes goal, if I never meet him I would be fine. I have not withered away from not meeting him to date.![]()
![]()
![]()
If anyone does not like him this is their right. I am not your mom. I don't want to tell you who to like. I will voice an opposing oppinion if I so choose. Nothing personal to you, just an opposing oppinion.
O.K. with that?
Sounds logical to me, Ginger! For me, from 1981-1983 and to some degree even in 1986, he had the greatest voice I've ever heard. That said, his actions as a bandmate and his desire to bury a band that wasn't his rather than have it move on without him have soured my view of him as a person. None of the band members are mistake free, but I don't think any of them besides him actually wanted to put an end to Journey. *I* believe he did.
This is your oppinion and I am O.K with that. I don't agree, but I understand where you stand. Now, are all loons in the same catagory?
In my opinion, you're either a loon, such as I or you are simply a Steve Perry fan. A loon will only identify Journey with Perry and have complete understanding of his decisions while with the band.
It seems that many want to be considered a loon but forget it. It's all or nothing. Complete loyalty! No "I love him but...."
artist4perry wrote:SJ there are layers of loondom. I for one do not see Steve as perfect, but as human, I agree with the post above. He has done his share of mistakes.
But bands fight, that is pretty common. I was not there, and I am staying out of their mess. I just want to love the music, and I am not into playing monday night psychiatrist on the band. Never been one for fault finding missions.
Steve is a great singer, and I have respect for his art. But I have no desire to follow, anoy, stalk, or be with him on a daily basis. I would like to meet him on his terms someday. Maybe a meet and greet. But this is not a lifes goal, if I never meet him I would be fine. I have not withered away from not meeting him to date.![]()
![]()
![]()
If anyone does not like him this is their right. I am not your mom. I don't want to tell you who to like. I will voice an opposing oppinion if I so choose. Nothing personal to you, just an opposing oppinion.
O.K. with that?
Saint John wrote:whirlwind wrote:
I do think that it was the fact that the band had a change of instruments at their disposal whereas Perry had only his vocals and he stopped andThey tried to move on without him started when he felt he had to.
That's a great point and I agree with it. Just be honest with your bandmates and let them move on. Don't tour without them, break up lineups and record albums and say you're going to tour when you have no intention of doing so!
Peartree12249 wrote:artist4perry wrote:SJ there are layers of loondom. I for one do not see Steve as perfect, but as human, I agree with the post above. He has done his share of mistakes.
But bands fight, that is pretty common. I was not there, and I am staying out of their mess. I just want to love the music, and I am not into playing monday night psychiatrist on the band. Never been one for fault finding missions.
Steve is a great singer, and I have respect for his art. But I have no desire to follow, anoy, stalk, or be with him on a daily basis. I would like to meet him on his terms someday. Maybe a meet and greet. But this is not a lifes goal, if I never meet him I would be fine. I have not withered away from not meeting him to date.![]()
![]()
![]()
If anyone does not like him this is their right. I am not your mom. I don't want to tell you who to like. I will voice an opposing oppinion if I so choose. Nothing personal to you, just an opposing oppinion.
O.K. with that?
I have to agree with you A4P. I really don't think I'd want to meet Steve Perry does that mean I'm not a loon? Are they going to demand their membership card back? I don't know how Dan became the self-appointed arbiter of what a loon is, but for the record, like you, I am not a fanatic, stalker, Perry apologist, Neal hater, Journey w/o Perry hater, I do not worship Perry. He's just a guy with a fabulous God-given gift who made some amazing music with some other very talented and creative people and for a brief period in time they created magic. And I fervently hope he will again, but if he doesn't, life will go on.![]()
Jana wrote:Peartree12249 wrote:artist4perry wrote:SJ there are layers of loondom. I for one do not see Steve as perfect, but as human, I agree with the post above. He has done his share of mistakes.
But bands fight, that is pretty common. I was not there, and I am staying out of their mess. I just want to love the music, and I am not into playing monday night psychiatrist on the band. Never been one for fault finding missions.
Steve is a great singer, and I have respect for his art. But I have no desire to follow, anoy, stalk, or be with him on a daily basis. I would like to meet him on his terms someday. Maybe a meet and greet. But this is not a lifes goal, if I never meet him I would be fine. I have not withered away from not meeting him to date.![]()
![]()
![]()
If anyone does not like him this is their right. I am not your mom. I don't want to tell you who to like. I will voice an opposing oppinion if I so choose. Nothing personal to you, just an opposing oppinion.
O.K. with that?
I have to agree with you A4P. I really don't think I'd want to meet Steve Perry does that mean I'm not a loon? Are they going to demand their membership card back? I don't know how Dan became the self-appointed arbiter of what a loon is, but for the record, like you, I am not a fanatic, stalker, Perry apologist, Neal hater, Journey w/o Perry hater, I do not worship Perry. He's just a guy with a fabulous God-given gift who made some amazing music with some other very talented and creative people and for a brief period in time they created magic. And I fervently hope he will again, but if he doesn't, life will go on.![]()
You're not a Loon according to Whirlwind's definition.![]()
whirlwind wrote:Smitty would tell you the truth if you could get an interview.
Saint John wrote:whirlwind wrote:Smitty would tell you the truth if you could get an interview.
I've met Mr. Smith on two occasions and I'll just say that the mere mention of "Steve Perry" seemed to put him in a foul mood. The eye rolling was pretty tell-tale as well. Here's another odd occurrence. When Tito and I went to see Jim Peterik's World Stage this year we were standing in line to meet Jimi Jamison and Rik Emmett when David Pack came over. I'm not sure what we were talking about but someone mentioned Perry's name and Pack got up and immediately left, never to be seen again for the rest of the night. Coincidence? Perhaps, but I was recently told that they have some minor feud going on. Whether or not that's true I have no idea, but I've talked to quite a few famous musicians over the last decade or two and, aside from his voice, the compliments have been few and far between when people talk about Perry.
whirlwind wrote: In my opinion, you're either a loon, such as I or you are simply a Steve Perry fan. A loon will only identify Journey with Perry and have complete understanding of his decisions while with the band.
It seems that many want to be considered a loon but forget it. It's all or nothing. Complete loyalty! No "I love him but...."
Deb wrote:whirlwind wrote: In my opinion, you're either a loon, such as I or you are simply a Steve Perry fan. A loon will only identify Journey with Perry and have complete understanding of his decisions while with the band.
It seems that many want to be considered a loon but forget it. It's all or nothing. Complete loyalty! No "I love him but...."
Um no, I'm thinking those are the ones that probably scare him a bit.![]()
So what category does a Martinized Sotomized Loon (or is it "Spoon" now?
) fit into?!
Deb wrote:whirlwind wrote: In my opinion, you're either a loon, such as I or you are simply a Steve Perry fan. A loon will only identify Journey with Perry and have complete understanding of his decisions while with the band.
It seems that many want to be considered a loon but forget it. It's all or nothing. Complete loyalty! No "I love him but...."
Um no, I'm thinking those are the ones that probably scare him a bit.![]()
So what category does a Martinized Sotomized Loon (or is it "Spoon" now?
) fit into?!
Rhiannon wrote:Deb wrote:Sotomized
You should come up with a better word for that. Misreads as "sodomized" very easily!
Rhiannon wrote:Deb wrote:Sotomized
You should come up with a better word for that. Misreads as "sodomized" very easily!
Rhiannon wrote:Deb wrote:Sotomized
You should come up with a better word for that. Misreads as "sodomized" very easily!
Deb wrote:Rhiannon wrote:Deb wrote:Sotomized
You should come up with a better word for that. Misreads as "sodomized" very easily!
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Gawd you people! Here, grab my hand and let me pull you up out of that there gutter.
![]()
Jubilee wrote:Saint John wrote:whirlwind wrote:Smitty would tell you the truth if you could get an interview.
I've met Mr. Smith on two occasions and I'll just say that the mere mention of "Steve Perry" seemed to put him in a foul mood. The eye rolling was pretty tell-tale as well. Here's another odd occurrence. When Tito and I went to see Jim Peterik's World Stage this year we were standing in line to meet Jimi Jamison and Rik Emmett when David Pack came over. I'm not sure what we were talking about but someone mentioned Perry's name and Pack got up and immediately left, never to be seen again for the rest of the night. Coincidence? Perhaps, but I was recently told that they have some minor feud going on. Whether or not that's true I have no idea, but I've talked to quite a few famous musicians over the last decade or two and, aside from his voice, the compliments have been few and far between when people talk about Perry.
Seriously SJ, what, exactly, is your point? Perry's an a-hole? Duly noted. So, now what?
artist4perry wrote:Deb wrote:Rhiannon wrote:Deb wrote:Sotomized
You should come up with a better word for that. Misreads as "sodomized" very easily!
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Gawd you people! Here, grab my hand and let me pull you up out of that there gutter.
![]()
Sorry Deb, I have had a hard day with some difficult students and I had my glasses off..............I went........huh???????? And could not resist.............
Truth be told your a loon too. No one has the right to judge others on if they are loons are not. A fan is a loon. If you love pics of him, love his voice, collect memorabilia of his, I think that is a pretty good sign. And who knows what is loondom? We all vary like personalities do..............
You are so funny girl......I laughed out loud on that one! Thank you it has been an awful day. The boy who lost his mom came in today, and he looked so lost. It has been a hard couple of weeks and you guys humor and kindness has made it so much easier to go in each day and do what is needed to be done.
Deb I think the world of ya!
Deb wrote:whirlwind wrote: In my opinion, you're either a loon, such as I or you are simply a Steve Perry fan. A loon will only identify Journey with Perry and have complete understanding of his decisions while with the band.
It seems that many want to be considered a loon but forget it. It's all or nothing. Complete loyalty! No "I love him but...."
Um no, I'm thinking those are the ones that probably scare him a bit.![]()
So what category does a Martinized Sotomized Loon (or is it "Spoon" now?
) fit into?!
Liquid_Drummer wrote:I have met Steve Smith on two occasions. Made NO mention of Journey or Steve Perry in any way. He was still arrogant and obviously self important. He apologized for his attitude through Bernard, the owner of drummerworld.com. Here is the PM I received from Bernard.
Hi Mark,
I read your comments about the behaviour of Steve Smith and i'm really concerned. As you know, i'm a good friend of him personally and we meet really often for dinner with the Hudson Guys.
for sure, your wrote everything totally correct and ok - but anyway, i remove this part of the thread.
But be sure: I showed it to Steve and he promised me to change his attitude and says that if he put a damper that he is very sorry. (really!!!!!)
Is this deal ok for you?
thanks for understanding.
Bernhard,
Any way, he wasnt a dick to me personally. It was the staff of the local music store that was taking care of the drum clinic and PAYING HIM for it which was all done per Steve's specs with NO MISTAKES. He shows up and Ryan (the drum department manager) says,
"Steve, a real pleasure tonice to meet you, Im Ryan..... And before he could get his last name out Steve cuts him off by saying GOT MY CHECK rather rudely. Ryan says with wide eyes, umm yes, right here and hands it to him. Steve takes the check, turns around and walks off.. This is one example of 3 situations that made me loose all respect for him..
Still love his drumming and dont care that he is a dick. Glad he didnt pull that shit with me. I would have called him out fast. I dont are who the fuck you are. IF you are rude to me you get rude x2 back. Well, unless you have a gun or a major size advantge that is.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 31 guests