Who really gives a shit about the movies head to head. Jen VS Brad. Pretty queer, Jennifer Aniston is only mentioned in the same breath as Brad Pitt because she fucked him, end of story. Her movies can't hold a candlelight to anything Brad Pitt did.
The two movies are so much different in capability it's sickening. Brad Pitt was involved with an incredible story, with a un-breakable plot, and pretty much carried it with no major co-stars.
Anniston had that ugly, not funny dude with the broken nose, Owen Wilson as a co-star, and the certain genre she opposes as her roles are more for what audiences are looking for as in family, etc.
There is no way, no how, that Marley and Me has a better story than Benjamin Button. Benjamin Button is genius, and is a role only a few could pull off. The Characters were believable and the acting was superb.
Pitt kicks Anniston's ASS.
..and he probably did something else with it too

lucky bastard.