After watching that video, I am bummed for a number of reasons. First off, the harmonies are not there...at all. Second, Brad sounded sloppy as hell on that solo. The rest of my complaints might be not taken too well by the NR faithful--and believe me, I am one of you.....
Reb Beach should be singing damnit. He is an amazing singer and would probably be an immense help to the harmonies. And last, and possibly most controversial, Reb is not a rhythm guitarist. He is one of the best studio guitarists around..which is why he has appeared on innumerable projects. The guy is a virtuoso, and I hate seeing him as a guy playing only power chords. I love Jeff and Brad, but Reb could probably outplay them any day of the week and twice on Sunday. That is almost undeniable if you have ever seen him live or on video or heard him on record. Jeff, at the height of his playing, was sloppy...even on his own instructional vids. He became known for his tapping ability. Brad plays with great legato but, if it weren't for the whammy bar, he would not be considered a top guitarist. Even now, I don't know that, individually, Brad and Jeff were ever viewed by the rock community as elite players....they are probably more akin to niche players---great in tandem, excellent at gimmickery, but only better than average when compared to their counterparts. And this is coming from a died in the wool "Jeff Watson is the greatest guitar player ever" fan. Seeing this video finally made me realize that having Reb on stage is a mistake...not because of him, but because of them. God, its awfully hard to say that.
For those that question Reb----this is from his OLD instructional video:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zGjEaganMLk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5viKEp4n ... ed&search=
Reb live with Dokken (doing what Jeff and Brad both do...and doing it almost flawlessly):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fl1pGyZagJo
and here is Jeff from 1982. I'm sure that his playing improved over time as he matured. If I could find video of his instructional vid, I would show you.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OjnaC1tWCUA
Don't get me wrong, I am not trying to take away from Jeff or Brad in any way. As a team, they are incredible and so complimentary. But as separate entities.......eh. The video posted of the recent show only adds to my frustration and sadness. Lade---I know you weren't whining....its hard to lose a friend. I feel the same way.