Moderator: Andrew
In another TV appearance, a re-recorded bridge of "Mr. Roboto" was used to demonstrate the sound system for a Volkswagen Golf. "We re_recorded the track for the Volkswagen commercial," said JY. "We have to okay these things, so they can't do it without the writers' permission. The record company owned the original master, and they ultimately wanted more money than the people were willing to pay, but Dennis decided, being the writer of Roboto, asked me about what I thought about re_recording it, and I said why not, let's give it a shot. So we did. And the sale of our Greatest Hits albums doubled the week after that thing first hit."
Ash wrote:http://elusivemind.net/video/Golf-mister-roboto.mov
SuiteMadameBlue wrote:Here's a few more:
This is from one of the VW sites:
Ad: "Crazy Guy" Click here to download WAV format.
The New Golf Click here to download MP3 format.
Song: Mr. Roboto
Band: Dennis DeYoung and James Young of Styx
From Sadie:
http://www.racerrecords.com/Styx/goldmine.htmlIn another TV appearance, a re-recorded bridge of "Mr. Roboto" was used to demonstrate the sound system for a Volkswagen Golf. "We re_recorded the track for the Volkswagen commercial," said JY. "We have to okay these things, so they can't do it without the writers' permission. The record company owned the original master, and they ultimately wanted more money than the people were willing to pay, but Dennis decided, being the writer of Roboto, asked me about what I thought about re_recording it, and I said why not, let's give it a shot. So we did. And the sale of our Greatest Hits albums doubled the week after that thing first hit."
[/quote]Right, so we still don't know who got paid what, and why it was only Dennis and JY. Once again, we're doing nothing but speculating. That's all I was trying to say.
Peace,
Sadie
At the end of the day, it's Dennis' song. And I think that irks some in the band more than others... because I'm **SURE** DDY still continues to make quite a bit of residual income off that song alone.
Irony is.... the re-recorded version sound better than the original
styxfanNH wrote:And Froy continues to spout the paymant amount for the commercial but has yet to provide any substantive source of his information.
And you will never get my source as its inside info
If you dont believe it fine
Think about it for a second the commercial was used many times on thousands of stations over the US are you saying 500 grand is to high to low ? I think its sounds just rightPlease point us to an article, an interview, something that proves to at least 50% validity that Dennis chose to ask JY to re-record the song then paid him nothing or shared nothing of the money received for his services.
There was an article with JY that was posted where he said that if your in a band for years you should split all the money down the middle
He's the lowest songwriter in the band in fact Shaws rights Dennis owns so he's got nothing to sell either, It 's common sense to see that Dennis made the money on the VW commercial even JY wont answer questions about it so there is something going on with it .If it is true as you say, shame on Dennis. But personally, I don't think Dennis is like that.
Shame on Dennis for what asking JY to help him out as a friend only to be asked to be paid for it. Dawn Marie would have sounded better and would have done it for nothingAnd why did Dennis choose to remove Tommy and Chuck from the re-recording of the song?
Irony is.... the re-recorded version sound better than the original
DarrenUK wrote:THE PROBLEMS PLAIN TO SEE
WAS TOO MUCH OF A ROYALTY
MACHINES TO SAVE OUR LIVES
MACHINES VOLKSWAGON KIND
THE TIME HAS COME AT LAST
TO THROW AWAY THE MASK
SO EVERYONE CAN SEE
JY DIDNT GET A FEE
IME KILROY
KILROY
KILROY
froy wrote:Dennis got 500 grand JY got nothing except double sales of the greatest hits which made him some nice cash.
It was Dennis's voice we heard , it was his song he wrote it
He has the right to make money off of it
When you heard THE WHO in commercials do you know who gets the money Townsend he wrote the tunes nobody else gets the money
Same with Sienfeld he's rich all the others are not
Only recently did they make a deal with the DVDS ,[/color]
SuiteMadameBlue wrote:Okay, here's a little scoop: Dennis DID NOT get paid $500,000 or close to it for re-recording Mr. Roboto for the VW commerical. Froy, I hate to say this, but you were misinformed from your source. All parties involved, including JY were paid an amount of money for the re-recording which was fair to each of them.
The finances are their business (all the parties involved).
The bottom line, Dennis and JY re-recorded "Mr. Roboto" for the VW commerical. They AND OTHERS that were involved were paid an undisclosed amount of money.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests