Moderator: Andrew
Andrew wrote:What I find funny....and I must ask Frankie about this...is how the band had to RUSH to get the album finished, but previous to the rush, sat around doing bugger all for years!
Andrew wrote:I have no idea why Reach was what it was....complicated on all sides eh?
A lot of years wasted (by everyone) and that's just a shame.
Slander wrote:Andrew wrote:What I find funny....and I must ask Frankie about this...is how the band had to RUSH to get the album finished, but previous to the rush, sat around doing bugger all for years!
Andrew but my understanding was that both FMS and Half My Heart were slated for the Ultimate album in 2004. That's almost 2 years before the release of REACH. If I'm not mistaken Jeremy (who put the thing together) told us that. So why would the album have to be rushed with already 2 songs in the can?
Red13JoePa wrote:Slander wrote:Andrew wrote:What I find funny....and I must ask Frankie about this...is how the band had to RUSH to get the album finished, but previous to the rush, sat around doing bugger all for years!
Andrew but my understanding was that both FMS and Half My Heart were slated for the Ultimate album in 2004. That's almost 2 years before the release of REACH. If I'm not mistaken Jeremy (who put the thing together) told us that. So why would the album have to be rushed with already 2 songs in the can?
Maybe that's all they had new in the can.
Otherwise why wait 2 more years to release it in only part of the world with so many FMS sessions leftovers on it when Frankie said the whole thing would be brand new songs?
Slander wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:Slander wrote:Andrew wrote:What I find funny....and I must ask Frankie about this...is how the band had to RUSH to get the album finished, but previous to the rush, sat around doing bugger all for years!
Andrew but my understanding was that both FMS and Half My Heart were slated for the Ultimate album in 2004. That's almost 2 years before the release of REACH. If I'm not mistaken Jeremy (who put the thing together) told us that. So why would the album have to be rushed with already 2 songs in the can?
Maybe that's all they had new in the can.
Otherwise why wait 2 more years to release it in only part of the world with so many FMS sessions leftovers on it when Frankie said the whole thing would be brand new songs?
That could be the case. I would love to hear the story. I for one think FMS, Nevertheless, Seconds Away, and I don't were on REACH because FS truly believe they were great songs that needed to see the light of day. I think all are excellent tracks by the way.
Red13JoePa wrote:
Well, be that as it may, that's not what he SAID was going to happen. He said that pretty much other than Fire Makes Steel the whole album would be new like Reach and Gimme The World, Don't Give Up and Home.
Not the case in retrospect.
Anyway, what's tis about the FMS sessions leftovers needing to see the light of day?
I'm certain that on these very pages we can locates posts where you threw those songs being out there available since the mid-90s in peoples' faces who complained about the gap between Survivor releases and pointed to 2 official commericially released Jamison solo albums.
I know it happened to me. So which is it, do they need to see the light of day, finally in 2006 or did Survivor trump Peterik, Bickler and Jamison by having these songs released (in demo form) in the mid-90s on bootleg?
You've said both at different times now.
Slander wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:
Well, be that as it may, that's not what he SAID was going to happen. He said that pretty much other than Fire Makes Steel the whole album would be new like Reach and Gimme The World, Don't Give Up and Home.
Not the case in retrospect.
Anyway, what's tis about the FMS sessions leftovers needing to see the light of day?
I'm certain that on these very pages we can locates posts where you threw those songs being out there available since the mid-90s in peoples' faces who complained about the gap between Survivor releases and pointed to 2 official commericially released Jamison solo albums.
I know it happened to me. So which is it, do they need to see the light of day, finally in 2006 or did Survivor trump Peterik, Bickler and Jamison by having these songs released (in demo form) in the mid-90s on bootleg?
You've said both at different times now.
OMG Red let it go. I was theorizing that FS might have wanted those songs to be on an officiall record.
Red13JoePa wrote:Slander wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:
Well, be that as it may, that's not what he SAID was going to happen. He said that pretty much other than Fire Makes Steel the whole album would be new like Reach and Gimme The World, Don't Give Up and Home.
Not the case in retrospect.
Anyway, what's tis about the FMS sessions leftovers needing to see the light of day?
I'm certain that on these very pages we can locates posts where you threw those songs being out there available since the mid-90s in peoples' faces who complained about the gap between Survivor releases and pointed to 2 official commericially released Jamison solo albums.
I know it happened to me. So which is it, do they need to see the light of day, finally in 2006 or did Survivor trump Peterik, Bickler and Jamison by having these songs released (in demo form) in the mid-90s on bootleg?
You've said both at different times now.
OMG Red let it go. I was theorizing that FS might have wanted those songs to be on an officiall record.
Oh, is that right?
Because back then, when I complained (still do) about the US STILL not having an "official record" since 1988, you were indignant and pointed to the FMS demos citing those as evidence that they've gotten as much as Jamison out.
Red13JoePa wrote:It's moot.
Comparing bootlegs that were bootlegs b/c they couldn't get released (or the "band" couldn't get off their ASS to finish them) to OFFICIALLY RELEASED albums is BULLshit.
And why in hell COULDN'T they get the shit finished and get a label, anyway when JP and JJ could?
7 Wishes wrote:I think it's Diagnosis: Laziness on Frankie's part.
7 Wishes wrote:Thanks, bro. Feelin' a little better.
I would go see McSurvivor in a heartbeat...but WHERE THE FUCK ARE THEY AND WHAT ARE THEY DOING?
Joe Vana wrote:They do wayyyy more shows than people know....
Red13JoePa wrote:Joe Vana wrote:They do wayyyy more shows than people know....
That's terrific compensatory knowledge for insiders like you Joe Vana.
For the majority of the fans it's seems like a band that does more shows than people know is a bar band.
Red13JoePa wrote:Joe Vana wrote:They do wayyyy more shows than people know....
That's terrific compensatory knowledge for insiders like you Joe Vana.
For the majority of the fans it's seems like a band that does "more shows than people know" is a bar band.
Red13JoePa wrote:I'd love to give you a break.
If secret, unbilled casino gigs keep McSurvivor rolling in the dough per Joe Vana, that's great for them.
But us regular poor folk who are unfit financially to fasten the sandles on the feet of secret-casino gig rich Frankie and complain that they book about 6 shows a year in cornfields that we can't afford on our pauper's salaries to get to need a mainstream, advertised, booked show to see the band at.
Supposedly us blue-collar types who've been challenged on this site to compare W2s with the Joe Vanas and Frankie Sullivans of the world are REAL Survivor fans.
Joe Vana wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:Joe Vana wrote:They do wayyyy more shows than people know....
That's terrific compensatory knowledge for insiders like you Joe Vana.
For the majority of the fans it's seems like a band that does "more shows than people know" is a bar band.
I wish they were promoted more....Hell, if I didn't hear about the shows from Frank I would not know about em either....I would say they do about 40 to 50 per year.....and we hear about 4 or 5 of them hahahahah......really though, they keep pretty busy....
JV
Andrew wrote:Joe Vana wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:Joe Vana wrote:They do wayyyy more shows than people know....
That's terrific compensatory knowledge for insiders like you Joe Vana.
For the majority of the fans it's seems like a band that does "more shows than people know" is a bar band.
I wish they were promoted more....Hell, if I didn't hear about the shows from Frank I would not know about em either....I would say they do about 40 to 50 per year.....and we hear about 4 or 5 of them hahahahah......really though, they keep pretty busy....
JV
Gee...I know a website that would promote this band's shows for free...if only they were sent the info!!!!!!!
Slander wrote:I'm sure JoePa if you really wanted to see them you could find a way. Where do you live? Altoona? Happy Valley? I will contact band management and tell them they must play Penn State's homecoming next year. Maybe they could play Paterno's 175 year old b-day.
Red13JoePa wrote:Slander wrote:I'm sure JoePa if you really wanted to see them you could find a way. Where do you live? Altoona? Happy Valley? I will contact band management and tell them they must play Penn State's homecoming next year. Maybe they could play Paterno's 175 year old b-day.
I'm in Philly, but Altoona's about their speed these days.
Got to augment those secret casino gigs Joe Vana spoke of that keep them in a different tax bracket than all of us lowlife, poor fans with some real shows every now and then.
Red13JoePa wrote:Phew.
Must be money to be made there, hand over fist, right?
Why ELSE whould they subject themself to being in the same area as less well off finacial people as those who presumably live in ....
where is it?
Hico?
You and Joe Vana concur that McSurvivor's checkbooks should remain in the black enough from that trip to make that advertised trip to worth it?
Slander wrote:keep in mind Robin has his own gigs as well.
Return to Survivor / Jim Peterik / Toby Hitchcock / Pride Of Lions / Marc Scherer / Sir Jimi (RIP)
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests