Moderator: Andrew
Joe Vana wrote:Ehwmatt wrote:Epic news! I really hope we hear something new. JP rejoining would be a HUGE bonus.
Don't wish for too many things all at once
Andrew wrote:JP is not involved.
Andrew wrote:JP is not involved.
Andrew wrote:Journey/Survivor wrote:Andrew wrote:JP is not involved.
He needs to be, and make this a proper reunion!
Sad to hear that he's not involved.
I won't give up on Jim....will keep bugging him...
Andrew wrote:JP is not involved.
def wrote:I wonder, why I do not get upset about this news. I hoped that something would happen in the SURVIVOR camp, but maybe I hoped a little more, that something outside the remaining SURVIVOR camp would happen. The idea of Jamison returning to the ridiculous leftovers of what was once a great band probably seemed so absurd, after he left the band twice and got sued by other members. REACH has been the weakest effort in their discography and there are no hints, that it will get better songwriting-wise without JP. Of course it is only speculation, but I guess the only reason is, that this is part of an overall settlement of the legal matters. It's hard to belive, that there is a reasonable basis for a cooperation of artists, after you took the time and read the MR-interview with JJ (http://www.melodicrock.com/interviews/j ... son07.html) again.
So, I am not enthusiastic at all. Pobably they just try to do those nostalgia tours and make some bucks. Musically I would indeed have preferred something like a Bickler-Jamison-Peterik project.
Well, maybe the coming SURVIVOR Mark whatsoever surprise me with some good new songs...who knows?
jaxmanjoe wrote:From the sounds of it, they are going to be touring and probably not focusing on new music...here we go again. I wonder what's going to happen to all the music that's been written so far. Are they destined to demo purgatory?
Abitaman wrote:Andrew wrote:JP is not involved.
Sad to hear that.
What Frankie needs is someone who can write. I personally think that is part of the problem with no new music. Hopefully JP can come in produce and help right.
Joe Vana wrote:Writing I am sure...hopefully some backgrounds....it is up to FS!!
Great news for the fans of this band.....they are really back!!
Ehwmatt wrote:Even if nothing new comes out of it, it's always encouraging to see bands get back together at this stage of the game. Gives you hope for some of the other long-wanted reunions.
S2M wrote:Ehwmatt wrote:Even if nothing new comes out of it, it's always encouraging to see bands get back together at this stage of the game. Gives you hope for some of the other long-wanted reunions.
Not a huge fan of the band...like a few songs, and definitely haven't been in the midst of all the ins and outs of band members, drama, and the flame wars over singers....etc....
but this, to me, sounds like nothing more than that aging baseball player that wants to retire with the first team he played for, and signs a one-day contract.....
Yoda wrote:S2M wrote:Ehwmatt wrote:Even if nothing new comes out of it, it's always encouraging to see bands get back together at this stage of the game. Gives you hope for some of the other long-wanted reunions.
Not a huge fan of the band...like a few songs, and definitely haven't been in the midst of all the ins and outs of band members, drama, and the flame wars over singers....etc....
but this, to me, sounds like nothing more than that aging baseball player that wants to retire with the first team he played for, and signs a one-day contract.....
Except this isn't Jamison's first band!
S2M wrote:Yoda wrote:S2M wrote:Ehwmatt wrote:Even if nothing new comes out of it, it's always encouraging to see bands get back together at this stage of the game. Gives you hope for some of the other long-wanted reunions.
Not a huge fan of the band...like a few songs, and definitely haven't been in the midst of all the ins and outs of band members, drama, and the flame wars over singers....etc....
but this, to me, sounds like nothing more than that aging baseball player that wants to retire with the first team he played for, and signs a one-day contract.....
Except this isn't Jamison's first band!
Doesn't matter...it put him on the map. Which is the point. You think Pedro is going in the hall as a Dodger, or Expo?
Idiosyncrasy wrote:Sad to say it, but I think you might be on to something with the 'fulfilling a legal obligation' suggestion. I don't think I've heard Jamo say a single good word about Frankie since leaving the band, and very recently there was the dispute over royalties, the legal case, etc. Sounds like Jamo could be being forced into it legally or financially or both. Such a shame if that is the case, as it doesn't bode well for a re-invigorated band. I was still hoping for another Jamison/Peterik album - Crossroad Moments was excellent (IMO) and much more worthy than the name Survivor than Reach. I really hope this is by mutual agreement because they want to work together, and not because Jamison is being forced into it. It would be nice if he's able to keep his solo career going alongside Survivor too (including working with JP).
Slander wrote:Idiosyncrasy wrote:Sad to say it, but I think you might be on to something with the 'fulfilling a legal obligation' suggestion. I don't think I've heard Jamo say a single good word about Frankie since leaving the band, and very recently there was the dispute over royalties, the legal case, etc. Sounds like Jamo could be being forced into it legally or financially or both. Such a shame if that is the case, as it doesn't bode well for a re-invigorated band. I was still hoping for another Jamison/Peterik album - Crossroad Moments was excellent (IMO) and much more worthy than the name Survivor than Reach. I really hope this is by mutual agreement because they want to work together, and not because Jamison is being forced into it. It would be nice if he's able to keep his solo career going alongside Survivor too (including working with JP).
While I disagree with you on Crossroads Moments sounding like Survivor album, it is a solid effort. I do agree with you about this so called reunion. This sounds like both parties are less than enthusiastic. If you watch the JJ intereview on Youtube, it's not like he's ecstatic about the reunion, it's almost an afterthought. Andrew reports that FS said the following about the reunion "a solid move" and "a step in the right direction" to get Jimi back in the fold to hit the road and in Frankie's words "go out and play the hits"- Once again, not exactly warm and fuzzy! This smells of a business decision. I really hope I am wrong. I really do. I'm looking forward to Andrew's interview as well as press releases from both FS and JJ to shine further light on the move.
Return to Survivor / Jim Peterik / Toby Hitchcock / Pride Of Lions / Marc Scherer / Sir Jimi (RIP)
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest