Moderator: Andrew
Slander wrote:There's a new band note on Survivormusic.com. I get my wish. It sounds like Robin will performing some MSG stuff too! Frickin awesome. Adding "Anytime" Or "Love Is Not A Game" would add punch. What do you guys think?
Red13JoePa wrote:Slander wrote:There's a new band note on Survivormusic.com. I get my wish. It sounds like Robin will performing some MSG stuff too! Frickin awesome. Adding "Anytime" Or "Love Is Not A Game" would add punch. What do you guys think?
No way. Uh uh.
Too many great Survivor songs that need to be played.
No need for McSideProjectSongs in the setlist.
Slander wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:Slander wrote:There's a new band note on Survivormusic.com. I get my wish. It sounds like Robin will performing some MSG stuff too! Frickin awesome. Adding "Anytime" Or "Love Is Not A Game" would add punch. What do you guys think?
No way. Uh uh.
Too many great Survivor songs that need to be played.
No need for McSideProjectSongs in the setlist.
Wow I can't disagree more. I think it adds to the fan base. It's that simple. It doesn't take away Survivor. MSG had quite a following. To disregard Robin's accomplishments is selfish.
Red13JoePa wrote:They're only playing 10-12 songs as it is.
Jamo's solo efforts are frequently put down here, but I had never even HEARD of McCauley until he took over in Survivor.
The following can't be that big.
Red13JoePa wrote:They're only playing 10-12 songs as it is.
Jamo's solo efforts are frequently put down here, but I had never even HEARD of McCauley until he took over in Survivor.
The following can't be that big.
Red13JoePa wrote:They're only playing 10-12 songs as it is.
Jamo's solo efforts are frequently put down here, but I had never even HEARD of McCauley until he took over in Survivor.
The following can't be that big.
Red13JoePa wrote:Nope.
Apparently I am remiss but I'd never even heard of him/MSG until Andrew's piece explained where he came from.
And I sure as HELL don't want to hear songs from MSG at a Survivor show any more than I want to hear Jamison roll out Rock Hard with Survivor.
Not with this band's cannon of great songs.
Red13JoePa wrote:LOL, it's not nonsense.
I do respect the MSG accomplishments, I just don't want to hear them at a Survivor show.
If I want to hear something non-Survivor with McCauley I'd just as soon they play Come On Feel The Noise. It'd make a hell of a lot more sense to me.![]()
I'd rather Van Halen play only Van halen and Survivor play only Survivor.
Eyeof wrote:wow...Van Halen played Heavy Metal...I never heard that...Heard I Can't Drive, One Way to Rock, Eagles Fly, Give to Live, but don't remember Heavy Metal...
I loved when Halen played the Hagar stuff, but let's be honest Hagar was a little more intwined in VH, plus his stuff rocks...
I don't care what Survivor plays, just don't play Reach with McAuley...
Red, I'm with you have to admit I know a lot of music, but other than Frankie going on about him when they did that record, I'd never heard of him...
Cum on Feel the Noise...awesome...they should play that...and Heavy Metal...which by the way...Peterik wrote....
Eyeof wrote: I don't care what Survivor plays, just don't play Reach with McAuley...
Red13JoePa wrote:Eyeof wrote: I don't care what Survivor plays, just don't play Reach with McAuley...
LOL!
Don't like the way that one McSounds McNow?
IngoK wrote:For me it´s very simple. When I go to watch a concert of Survivor I don´t want them playing songs of another Band. It´s Survivor and not Survivor + MSG. And it wasn´t Survivor + Jimi Jamison before it was just Survivor.
Slander wrote:IngoK wrote:For me it´s very simple. When I go to watch a concert of Survivor I don´t want them playing songs of another Band. It´s Survivor and not Survivor + MSG. And it wasn´t Survivor + Jimi Jamison before it was just Survivor.
The lack of open minds and willingness to try anything new astounds me. Good rock and roll is good rock and roll. I think the reaction here is just more of the same effort to discredit Robin. It really saddens me. Robin is a talent and needs to be recognized as such. Yes I want to see Survivor. I have been a fan of the band since Premontion. I do however recognize that Robin brings his own catalogue to the table. If he has a couple of songs that can add some spice to the set list I'm all for it.
IngoK wrote:Slander wrote:IngoK wrote:For me it´s very simple. When I go to watch a concert of Survivor I don´t want them playing songs of another Band. It´s Survivor and not Survivor + MSG. And it wasn´t Survivor + Jimi Jamison before it was just Survivor.
The lack of open minds and willingness to try anything new astounds me. Good rock and roll is good rock and roll. I think the reaction here is just more of the same effort to discredit Robin. It really saddens me. Robin is a talent and needs to be recognized as such. Yes I want to see Survivor. I have been a fan of the band since Premontion. I do however recognize that Robin brings his own catalogue to the table. If he has a couple of songs that can add some spice to the set list I'm all for it.
Blah, Blah, Blah! Come on Slander, it has nothing to do with Robin. I like him. But I don´t want a McAuleySurvivorGroup! I want Survivor! Doesn´t matter who the current singer is!
Journey/Survivor wrote:I first heard of Robin Mcauley back in the late 80's when "Anytime" was a hit song.
My friend and former neighbor is a big MSG fan. I had already heard "Anytime" but I remember him also playing the song for me at the time because he thought being a huge Survivor, Journey and Bad English fan I would really like the song, which I do.
That friend of mine is also the person who told me about the Robin Mcauley CD "Buisness As Usual" when it was first released in the 90's.
I heard that Survivor might include a song or two from the "Business As Usual" CD in their set list. At least in that case Frankie was the guitarist on those songs in the first place unlike the MSG stuff.
I don't have a problem with them playing "Anytime" except that it means thats one less Survivor song for them to play each night.
MSG was a very successful band, and a song like "Anytime" might go over well with the more casual Survivor fans?
Robin Mcauley actually is somewhat of a big name singer from his years in MSG.
Slander wrote:Journey/Survivor wrote:I first heard of Robin Mcauley back in the late 80's when "Anytime" was a hit song.
My friend and former neighbor is a big MSG fan. I had already heard "Anytime" but I remember him also playing the song for me at the time because he thought being a huge Survivor, Journey and Bad English fan I would really like the song, which I do.
That friend of mine is also the person who told me about the Robin Mcauley CD "Buisness As Usual" when it was first released in the 90's.
I heard that Survivor might include a song or two from the "Business As Usual" CD in their set list. At least in that case Frankie was the guitarist on those songs in the first place unlike the MSG stuff.
I don't have a problem with them playing "Anytime" except that it means thats one less Survivor song for them to play each night.
MSG was a very successful band, and a song like "Anytime" might go over well with the more casual Survivor fans?
Robin Mcauley actually is somewhat of a big name singer from his years in MSG.
J/S thank you so much for this. I am shocked by the negative feedback. MSG had a nice following. Anytime was top ten hit on Billboards mainstream rock chart back in 1990. It's a great song. So is Love Is Not A game. Frankie produced Robin's solo album. There's some good stuff on their if people are willing to give it a spin. I for one think the band is fortunate to have a person as capable as Robin to step in and take over for Jamo.
Return to Survivor / Jim Peterik / Toby Hitchcock / Pride Of Lions / Marc Scherer / Sir Jimi (RIP)
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest