Moderator: Andrew
Free wrote:Does anyone care?
Rockn'deano wrote:Free wrote:Does anyone care?
nope.
Rockn'deano wrote:Dude, I actually like the hits....
But Christ, they have enough hits to keep it fresh. How bout axing Escape, Ask the lonely for Send Her M Love and say After the Fall.
And for God's sake, cut power to Valory's mic.
Free wrote:
That's what I thought. I've seen them twice since 98. How many times can you see the same old songs sung live and stay sane?
Lula wrote:Free wrote:
That's what I thought. I've seen them twice since 98. How many times can you see the same old songs sung live and stay sane?
Rockn'deano wrote:Lasy comment from me here.
I heard the Spectrum boot today from 86.
Perry was phenominal. Absolutely incredible. Ad libbing, extra chords, etc..
Look, can't we be honest here? Let's drop the niceties, and bullshit for just once. BT'ers, pull up a chair.
Augeri simply does not have it anylonger. Great guy, awesome guy, just done...Schon, Cain; Superb..none better. Deen; excellent; but a lead singer in this band simply doesn't have the life expectancy of more than 7 yrs..
I defy anyone to PROVE to me that Augeri can bring it at this level. it simply cannot happen.
Irving, Herbie, Barouck, BT'ers, MR'rs, whatever. Don't ya think there is a reason I am taking this stance? Dee Dee Dee.
Free wrote:Does anyone care?
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Here's the problem:
Everyone hears the Vegas DVD, Arrival, Red 13 and Generations and then think this Augeri guy is brilliant and sounds very much like S.Perry.
But it's a fake perception. An illusion.
Augeri doesn't really sound like that.
All of the aforementioned official recordings have been tinkered in post-production to give him the power, strength and smoothness to his voice that he lacks on stage. Some songs he is good on (Lights, WITS) but for far too many of them he is just plain unqualified.
Go listen to his live tracks on the Tyketto album.
THAT is a fair representation of Augeri.
I'm a fan of Augeri, I'm just not really a fan of Steve Augeri in Journey.
At the very least, the band should write songs tailor-made for his pipes. But all of the songs (Higher Place, Place in Your Heart) are really suited for a high pitched tenor and that isn't Augeri's forte.
It's as if Jon and Neal write songs pretending Steve Perry never left.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:
At the very least, the band should write songs tailor-made for his pipes. But all of the songs (Higher Place, Place in Your Heart) are really suited for a high pitched tenor and that isn't Augeri's forte.
It's as if Jon and Neal write songs pretending Steve Perry never left.
Shania wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:
At the very least, the band should write songs tailor-made for his pipes. But all of the songs (Higher Place, Place in Your Heart) are really suited for a high pitched tenor and that isn't Augeri's forte.
It's as if Jon and Neal write songs pretending Steve Perry never left.
I agree.For instance on Arrival he sings ok,but sometimes I got the impression that someone`s pointing a gun to his head in order to make him hit the high notes.I guess Augeri had no choice but go along with the "filling Perry`s shoes" thing. I think that`s what killed his voice for the most part.Plus he is 8 years older,right?
Hm...I wonder if vocal exhaustion is something that happens to all the Journey lead singers?"All" meaning both Steves.
jrnyjunky wrote:Neal almost seems obsessed with touring, with little regard to the stress it puts on a vocalist.
jrnyjunky wrote:This may be totally wrong but with Generations, I got the feeling that Neal and maybe even Jon had little interest in being in the studio.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:jrnyjunky wrote:This may be totally wrong but with Generations, I got the feeling that Neal and maybe even Jon had little interest in being in the studio.
Let me qualify this statement if I may....
I don't think Neal and Jon are against being in a recording studio in general. I just don't think Neal is all that excited to be dawdling about in a studio with the current incarnation of Journey. I mean, what for?
Nobody outside of the niche village here at MR.com really gives a hoot about this band's musical output.
NealIsGod wrote:What could he be doing that would be more successful,...
The_Noble_Cause wrote:At the very least, the band should write songs tailor-made for his pipes. But all of the songs (Higher Place, Place in Your Heart) are really suited for a high pitched tenor and that isn't Augeri's forte.
It's as if Jon and Neal write songs pretending Steve Perry never left.
NealIsGod wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:NealIsGod wrote:What could he be doing that would be more successful,...
But Journey's albums aren't succesful.
More so than his solo CDs, aren't they?
heardonthestreet wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:It's as if Jon and Neal write songs pretending Steve Perry never left.
.......................................
Or maybe that they hope that Perry will return?
The_Noble_Cause wrote:jrnyjunky wrote:This may be totally wrong but with Generations, I got the feeling that Neal and maybe even Jon had little interest in being in the studio.
Let me qualify this statement if I may....
I don't think Neal and Jon are against being in a recording studio in general. I just don't think Neal is all that excited to be dawdling about in a studio with the current incarnation of Journey. I mean, what for?
NealIsGod wrote:Well, in this stage of Neal's career, I think he does what he enjoys and money is secondary. He seems to love touring with the guys in the band, and I am sure they kick around a lot of ideas while on the road. So future albums will probably happen as long as the tours do. I'll bet they distribute their next one the same way they did Gens.
jrnyjetster wrote::roll: Oh for cripe sakes all this pissin' moanin' and whining around here lately...Why doesn't Journey just call it fuckin' quits??
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 29 guests