Chevypv wrote:I think without an indepth discussion with JSS about his vocal techiques and the intent of his use of the word "strain" we really shouldn't be so harsh, that post basically says, "I know more about taking care of my voice than you, a proffessional singer for 20 years does."
Excuse me Chevypv- but I'm 43 and I've been a club singer since I was 17. That's 2 nights a week singing 4 1/2 hour shows both nights for 26 years. I know about vocal blowout and what to do about avoiding it. Jss probably does too. I didn't say I knew more than him. I said I'm concerned about what I'm hearing as a fellow vocalist. I've heard all the boots out there because this whole thing is REALLY interesting to me (again as a vocalist more than a Journey fan). I mean no disrespect to him, but anybody who's listened to the recordings can hear the strain.
Chevypv wrote:And JSS is always as on pitch as SP ever was from what I have heard, listen to some SP RoR tour boots, now those are rough...
The notes are rough. Never are they flat. They do actually crack a few times too. I've heard them. And if you look back, Perry KNEW he was losing his voice "I really was toast"- Steve Perry, from Behind the Music. That's why he quit the ROR tour mid stream and his own solo tour midstream.
Chevypv wrote:
JSS is leaps and bounds above what those performances were in terms of vocal consistancy...
That's your opinion. Are you a singer?
Chevypv wrote:and its quite obvious in the boots of the soundcheck that JSS isn't pushing his voice due to the fact that he hasn't warmed up, all they are doing is checking levels for a few minutes, they aren't performing, if we had recordings of you in your shower would it sound excellent? no, probably not, boots are what they are for a reason, they really werent inteded to be released and taken out of context...
I'll give you that. In fact I said that in my reply that "I figured he warmed up as many singers do prior to sound checks and all of them should"- Actually it does sound like he's pushing his voice to me. But you're right,they weren't intended for release and so I should let it go. HOWEVER, everything else that I've heard from the Journey tours points to serious vocal problems just waiting to happen.
But what do I know?
Chevypv wrote:good lord, JSS has been singing since I was born, and he still sounds as good now as he did then, so whats the big deal...
The big deal is that the Journey tour could toast his voice. Maybe not concerning to you, but it is to me.