by Red13JoePa » Fri Mar 02, 2007 12:58 am
saint John wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:McNeil wrote: I have the whole gig on DVD..Augeri is great here...its early days...and hes hardly putting a foot wrong, and certainly not miming at all!
Goes to show you , though, that when you have been kicked down...all your previous efforts get trashed... and goes to prove that people only hear what they want to hear!!
Indeedio.
Popular rhetoric now, in light of 'Gate, has Augeri caterwalling like a wounded lemur from the day he joined the band right up he straightened it out by going to taped assistance.
In reality he was pretty fuckin good for a long time.
He was good? When? Maybe he was "good" at covering the catalog for a bit, but that's it. Failed album after failed album (except Arrival....a VERY MINOR success), stagnation in the creative process, and ultimately the decision to mime rather than show an ounce of class/dignity and step down, SHOULD wipe out anything you did prior.
I fuckin SAID, San Juan (You're a pain in my ass, but I like you alot) that he was not probably the singing technician that the Gospel enjoying Gravvy Lover was. That doesn't mean that from a personal perspective I'm not allowed to prefer his voice on a Journey album over his predecessor. Pinning the album "failures (thought still both Arrival and Generations chearted on Billboard despite the fact that concert version of Gens prolly kept many from buying it retail and RIAA refusing to allow Jrny to do what Prince did and cound records bought with tickets towards certification)" SOLELY on Perry W/A Perm is a false strawman argument, b/c by the time they got Arrival out, stealing of music had became a MAJOR problem to be dealt with for artists and albums just did not fly off shelves the way they did in 1996.
Look, man. You don't like Augeri. We GET it. You didn't show up here until TapeGate broke and ESC4P3ToTape was online.
But I refuse to adhere to the credo that 'Gate should wipe out ANYTHING he ever did.
Last edited by
Red13JoePa on Fri Mar 02, 2007 1:22 am, edited 1 time in total.
"I love almost everybody."---Rocky Balboa 1990
"Let's reform this thing.Let's go out and get some guys who want to work and go do it"--Neal Schon February, 2001
"I looked at Neal, and I just saw a guy who really wants his band back"-JCain 2/01