
Moderator: Andrew
Carla777 wrote:ooh i forget...maybe you were "allucinating" that Tony is much better singer than Ian
Carla777 wrote:verslibre wrote:Carla777 wrote::evil: what's wrong here??..why no one here seem to like Ozzy in Black Sabbath??..I know,he don't sing well, but he used to give the songs a special atmosphere in the early BS sound..and Ian Gillan...maybe not the best choice for Sabbath but this man had an incredible voice, out of this world, much better than T. Martin voice any day (yeahh i said it!)..love ozzy work with Sabbath, his early solo records are outstanding, and Gillan is for me in my top singer from all times!
I never said I don't like Ozzy at all. It's just that he...pales in comparison to Dio!![]()
Sorry. Seriously, I love Sabbath Bloody Sabbath! It's awesome. Sabotage, Technical Ecstacy and Never Say Die! are great, too.
You think Ian Gillan has a better voice than Tony Martin? Hmmm...maybe now he does. Tony's voice doesn't sound like it used to. But in '86-'96 Tony beat the pants off Ian (not literally, hahahaha)!
Ozzy and Dio are great front men, but yes there is mayor difference in vocal quality, of course Dio is in another level as a singer....now the second one...dear i respect most of your opinions here...but you are SOO WRONG this time; look at 86' Ian sing a little early (if i'm correct 85, or 84)in Perfect Strangers album with Deep Purple..i mean common!! Knocking at your back door,Wasted Sunsets, and how forget Perfect Strangers ..perfect vocal register, he can any day kick Tony Martin ass, in every way, as a singer and as a frontman..excuse me but is Ian Gillan!!!he is unique, more respect damn it!!
![]()
![]()
SF-Dano wrote:Carla777 wrote:
Ozzy and Dio are great front men, but yes there is mayor difference in vocal quality, of course Dio is in another level as a singer....now the second one...dear i respect most of your opinions here...but you are SOO WRONG this time; look at 86' Ian sing a little early (if i'm correct 85, or 84)in Perfect Strangers album with Deep Purple..i mean common!! Knocking at your back door,Wasted Sunsets, and how forget Perfect Strangers ..perfect vocal register, he can any day kick Tony Martin ass, in every way, as a singer and as a frontman..excuse me but is Ian Gillan!!!he is unique, more respect damn it!!
![]()
![]()
Ian Gillian is a great vocalist, but I can see how some may be put off by his style - especeially from the early Deep Purple stuff. For me personally, Ian is a top 25 rock vocalist. In comparison Ozzy and Martin would be some where in the latter half of the top 100.
I saw DP and Gillian on the Perfect Strangers tour and was absolutely blown away. That still ranks as one of the top 10 concerts I have ever seen (and I have seen a lot). I wish Ian and Ritchie could put aside their differences and co-exist in Deep Purple. They belong together. Don't get me wrong, I love Steve Morse as a player but when I think Deep Purple, I think Ian and Ritchie.
Now put Steve Morse together with David Coverdale and we might have something real interesting there...........![]()
Carla777 wrote:SF-Dano wrote:Carla777 wrote:
Ozzy and Dio are great front men, but yes there is mayor difference in vocal quality, of course Dio is in another level as a singer....now the second one...dear i respect most of your opinions here...but you are SOO WRONG this time; look at 86' Ian sing a little early (if i'm correct 85, or 84)in Perfect Strangers album with Deep Purple..i mean common!! Knocking at your back door,Wasted Sunsets, and how forget Perfect Strangers ..perfect vocal register, he can any day kick Tony Martin ass, in every way, as a singer and as a frontman..excuse me but is Ian Gillan!!!he is unique, more respect damn it!!
![]()
![]()
Ian Gillian is a great vocalist, but I can see how some may be put off by his style - especeially from the early Deep Purple stuff. For me personally, Ian is a top 25 rock vocalist. In comparison Ozzy and Martin would be some where in the latter half of the top 100.
I saw DP and Gillian on the Perfect Strangers tour and was absolutely blown away. That still ranks as one of the top 10 concerts I have ever seen (and I have seen a lot). I wish Ian and Ritchie could put aside their differences and co-exist in Deep Purple. They belong together. Don't get me wrong, I love Steve Morse as a player but when I think Deep Purple, I think Ian and Ritchie.
Now put Steve Morse together with David Coverdale and we might have something real interesting there...........![]()
Finally!!..someone make sense here! Ian Gillan is in another level, superior to Tony and Ozzy... wow you are so lucky i had seen some of the DP vids in youtube from that tour,and Ian was on fire back then..and yeah we all wish that Blackmore wake up from his medieval dream and come back to rock with DP or Rainbow..now i do believe Steve Morse is a fantastic player, i saw him live and he really kick ass, not like ritchie (he is from another world), but still very good
SF-Dano wrote:Now put Steve Morse together with David Coverdale and we might have something real interesting there...........![]()
verslibre wrote:Carla777 wrote:ps. don't you like it the stoner rock?..
Like Queens Of The Stone Age? I like a couple songs. I think they're overrated. They have a pretty rabid fan base. Since they (and the band they broke off from, Kyuss) are from my neck of the woods, I'm not as impressed as others are. I never liked Kyuss.
Or are there other bands you're thinking of? Stoner rock is a somewhat nebulous genre to me.
Carla777 wrote::evil: what's wrong here??..why no one here seem to like Ozzy in Black Sabbath??..I know,he don't sing well, but he used to give the songs a special atmosphere in the early BS sound..and Ian Gillan...maybe not the best choice for Sabbath but this man had an incredible voice, out of this world, much better than T. Martin voice any day (yeahh i said it!)..love ozzy work with Sabbath, his early solo records are outstanding, and Gillan is for me in my top singer from all times!
wastingbeerz wrote:Queens Of The Stone Age are indeed highly overrated, and it really sucks that they're usually the face of "stoner" rock/metal when even the band they came from, Kyuss, are lightyears beyond them. Josh Homme really pisses me off for trying to simplify and popify Kyuss's sound.
wastingbeerz wrote:My favorite stoner rock bands...
Sheavy
Cathedral (usually considered more doom than stoner)
Fu Manchu
Spiritual Beggars
Sixty Watt Shaman
Monster Magnet
Electric Wizard
Mushroom River Band
Orange Goblin
Nebula
verslibre wrote:wastingbeerz wrote:Queens Of The Stone Age are indeed highly overrated, and it really sucks that they're usually the face of "stoner" rock/metal when even the band they came from, Kyuss, are lightyears beyond them. Josh Homme really pisses me off for trying to simplify and popify Kyuss's sound.
But that's the funny thing...overrated as they are, QotSA is the better of the two. I never got what people like about John Garcia's voice. Honestly, as far as hard rock goes, I thought they were average at best. Their so-called "mystique" has done much more for them than their music ever did, breaking up before ever getting "big," playing unannounced and/or "secret" gigs, being produced by Chris Goss of Masters Of Reality (another band whose cult status I REALLY don't get), recording at Rancho de la Luna studio way up in the high desert, etc. To top it all off, Kyuss never really made any money, and I think that also adds to their status as "artists."
Now just don't get me started on Eagles of Death Metal!wastingbeerz wrote:My favorite stoner rock bands...
Sheavy
Not familiar with them.Cathedral (usually considered more doom than stoner)
This is the third band I've heard of with that name, the other two being prog rock and metal bands. I think that word should be banned from the Band Name Lexicon.Fu Manchu
Another band known more for Brant Bjork drumming for them for what, one whole album?Spiritual Beggars
These guys are pretty good.Sixty Watt Shaman
Heard of 'em, not familiar with their music.Monster Magnet
Ugh.Electric Wizard
Not bad.Mushroom River Band
Not familiar with them.Orange Goblin
Nebula
I need to hear more to form an opinion.
So do you listen to Bigelf? I like them loads better than any band you mentioned here.
verslibre wrote:Carla777 wrote:ooh i forget...maybe you were "allucinating" that Tony is much better singer than Ian
Don't get me wrong, I like Ian. Here's how I rank him on my list of favorite singers!
1. Ronnie James Dio
2. John Lawton
3. Sammy Hagar
4. Ray Alder
5. Geddy Lee
6. Glenn Danzig
7. Geoff Tate
8. Ian Anderson
10. Ann Wilson
11. Mike Patton
_
_
_
99. Cyndi Lauper
100. Ian Gillan![]()
![]()
![]()
Carla777 wrote:verslibre wrote:Carla777 wrote:ooh i forget...maybe you were "allucinating" that Tony is much better singer than Ian
Don't get me wrong, I like Ian. Here's how I rank him on my list of favorite singers!
1. Ronnie James Dio
2. John Lawton
3. Sammy Hagar
4. Ray Alder
5. Geddy Lee
6. Glenn Danzig
7. Geoff Tate
8. Ian Anderson
10. Ann Wilson
11. Mike Patton
_
_
_
99. Cyndi Lauper
100. Ian Gillan![]()
![]()
![]()
mmm
hey nice, you put Ray Adler in the list, should be more recognition for him, love his voice, more imperfect that Tate, but still full with emotions![]()
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FoAyJiUYvc
wastingbeerz wrote:Carla777 wrote:verslibre wrote:Carla777 wrote:ooh i forget...maybe you were "allucinating" that Tony is much better singer than Ian
Don't get me wrong, I like Ian. Here's how I rank him on my list of favorite singers!
1. Ronnie James Dio
2. John Lawton
3. Sammy Hagar
4. Ray Alder
5. Geddy Lee
6. Glenn Danzig
7. Geoff Tate
8. Ian Anderson
10. Ann Wilson
11. Mike Patton
_
_
_
99. Cyndi Lauper
100. Ian Gillan![]()
![]()
![]()
mmm
hey nice, you put Ray Adler in the list, should be more recognition for him, love his voice, more imperfect that Tate, but still full with emotions![]()
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FoAyJiUYvc
Ray Alder rules... most people only know him from his stuff with Fates Warning... but his stuff with Engine and Redemption is equally good.
Carla777 wrote:wastingbeerz wrote:Carla777 wrote:verslibre wrote:Carla777 wrote:ooh i forget...maybe you were "allucinating" that Tony is much better singer than Ian
Don't get me wrong, I like Ian. Here's how I rank him on my list of favorite singers!
1. Ronnie James Dio
2. John Lawton
3. Sammy Hagar
4. Ray Alder
5. Geddy Lee
6. Glenn Danzig
7. Geoff Tate
8. Ian Anderson
10. Ann Wilson
11. Mike Patton
_
_
_
99. Cyndi Lauper
100. Ian Gillan![]()
![]()
![]()
mmm
hey nice, you put Ray Adler in the list, should be more recognition for him, love his voice, more imperfect that Tate, but still full with emotions![]()
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FoAyJiUYvc
Ray Alder rules... most people only know him from his stuff with Fates Warning... but his stuff with Engine and Redemption is equally good.
I love Ray Alder in Redemption!..but still love uch more FW..btw did you ever saw FW live? do you live close to this guys are from right?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 23 guests