Dream super group

by **Majestic** » Thu Apr 28, 2011 3:16 pm

Schon, Scholtz, Shaw, Blades, Castranovo. The group could be called "Schhh" or "Scho Scho Sha."

Can you imagine what killer music this band would make? Also, think about the covers they could do: Journey, Boston, Night Ranger, Styx.

Neal, next time you're not busy...

by **S2M** » Thu Apr 28, 2011 3:19 pm

Majestic wrote:Schon, Scholtz, Shaw, Blades, Castranovo. The group could be called "Schhh" or "Scho Scho Sha."

Can you imagine what killer music this band would make? Also, think about the covers they could do: Journey, Boston, Night Ranger, Styx.

Neal, next time you're not busy...

Supergroups aren't what they are cracked up to be.....too many egos to actually survive. Think of them like that backetball team that has 2 or 3 guys that want to take ALL the shots.....there's limited space to flourish.

Website · by **steveo777** » Thu Apr 28, 2011 3:25 pm

Majestic wrote:Schon, Scholtz, Shaw, Blades, Castranovo. The group could be called "Schhh" or "Scho Scho Sha."

Can you imagine what killer music this band would make? Also, think about the covers they could do: Journey, Boston, Night Ranger, Styx.

Neal, next time you're not busy...

Not much different than what they make now. If Journey wanted to switch over to metal they could do it with their present lineup.
I'm sure 3 would have no problem with it.

by **RocknRoll** » Thu Apr 28, 2011 3:28 pm

steveo777 wrote:
Majestic wrote:Schon, Scholtz, Shaw, Blades, Castranovo. The group could be called "Schhh" or "Scho Scho Sha."

Can you imagine what killer music this band would make? Also, think about the covers they could do: Journey, Boston, Night Ranger, Styx.

Neal, next time you're not busy...

Not much different than what they make now. If Journey wanted to switch over to metal they could do it with their present lineup.
I'm sure 3 would have no problem with it.

METAL????

Website · by **steveo777** » Thu Apr 28, 2011 3:33 pm

RocknRoll wrote:
steveo777 wrote:
Majestic wrote:Schon, Scholtz, Shaw, Blades, Castranovo. The group could be called "Schhh" or "Scho Scho Sha."

Can you imagine what killer music this band would make? Also, think about the covers they could do: Journey, Boston, Night Ranger, Styx.

Neal, next time you're not busy...

Not much different than what they make now. If Journey wanted to switch over to metal they could do it with their present lineup.
I'm sure 3 would have no problem with it.

METAL????

Hahaha
No, not really. Harder rock? Yes
Figured that was no more absurd than some of the other shit that gets said around here. :wink:

by **PianoMan1986** » Thu Apr 28, 2011 4:17 pm

Majestic wrote:Schon, Scholtz, Shaw, Blades, Castranovo. The group could be called "Schhh" or "Scho Scho Sha."

Can you imagine what killer music this band would make? Also, think about the covers they could do: Journey, Boston, Night Ranger, Styx.

Neal, next time you're not busy...

I'm curious as to how you put Scholz into the mix? Nothing against him, just thought an interesting element to have. Anytime I try to put together a dream lineup supergroup I end up getting conflicted with my own choices :lol:

by **Majestic** » Thu Apr 28, 2011 6:00 pm

PianoMan1986 wrote:
Majestic wrote:Schon, Scholtz, Shaw, Blades, Castranovo. The group could be called "Schhh" or "Scho Scho Sha."

Can you imagine what killer music this band would make? Also, think about the covers they could do: Journey, Boston, Night Ranger, Styx.

Neal, next time you're not busy...

I'm curious as to how you put Scholz into the mix? Nothing against him, just thought an interesting element to have. Anytime I try to put together a dream lineup supergroup I end up getting conflicted with my own choices

I was at the Gym listening to Boston, and realized how great Schon and Sholtz would compliment each other. Both very melodic, but Sholtz a bit stronger on rhythm, and Schon a bit stronger on lead. What a combo they would be.

by **WykkedSensation** » Thu Apr 28, 2011 7:05 pm

Majestic wrote:
PianoMan1986 wrote:
Majestic wrote:Schon, Scholtz, Shaw, Blades, Castranovo. The group could be called "Schhh" or "Scho Scho Sha."

Can you imagine what killer music this band would make? Also, think about the covers they could do: Journey, Boston, Night Ranger, Styx.

Neal, next time you're not busy...

I'm curious as to how you put Scholz into the mix? Nothing against him, just thought an interesting element to have. Anytime I try to put together a dream lineup supergroup I end up getting conflicted with my own choices

I was at the Gym listening to Boston, and realized how great Schon and Sholtz would compliment each other. Both very melodic, but Sholtz a bit stronger on rhythm, and Schon a bit stronger on lead. What a combo they would be.

Only problem there though would be that you would only get 1 release every 8 to 10 years with Scholz onboard. Scholz is also well known to be one complete asshole so it really wouldn't bode too well playing alongside another asshole :lol:

by **JourneyHard** » Fri Apr 29, 2011 6:12 am

Here is my Super Group Idea!

Steve Perry Lead Singer
Gary Richrath Lead Guitar
Dennis DeYoung Keyboards, Vocals
Steve Smith Drums

Add somebody to play Bass and you got a winner!

by **Ehwmatt** » Fri Apr 29, 2011 6:19 am

JourneyHard wrote:Here is my Super Group Idea!

Steve Perry Lead Singer
Gary Richrath Lead Guitar
Dennis DeYoung Keyboards, Vocals
Steve Smith Drums

Add somebody to play Bass and you got a winner!

Richrath? That guy is more likely to drink his way out of a brown paper bag than play his way out of one :lol:

by **SF-Dano** » Fri Apr 29, 2011 7:36 am

OK - just for laughs and going for some crazy groupings here:

1.
Neal Schon
Mattias Jabbs
Jeff Keith
John Wetton
Ian Paice

2.
Kirk Hammet
Michael Schenker
Steve Harris
Geoff Tate
Nick Menza

3.
Steve Morse
Rik Emmet
Geddy Lee
James LaBrie
Steve Smith

4.
Dave Mustain
Alex Skolnick
Billy Sheehan
Bruce Dickinson
Vinnie Paul

by **Deb** » Fri Apr 29, 2011 8:04 am

SF-Dano wrote:OK - just for laughs and going for some crazy groupings here:

1.
Neal Schon
Mattias Jabbs
Jeff Keith
John Wetton
Ian Paice

2.
Kirk Hammet
Michael Schenker
Steve Harris
Geoff Tate
Nick Menza

3.
Steve Morse
Rik Emmet
Geddy Lee
James LaBrie
Steve Smith

4.
Dave Mustain
Alex Skolnick
Billy Sheehan
Bruce Dickinson
Vinnie Paul

Hmm some pretty interesting combos there.

(4) Pretty darn heavy indeed.
(3) Three Canucks in that one. As long as Rik is singing somewhere in there too, and NOT Geddy. :lol:

(1) Have never heard of Mattias?

Jeff sounds alot like EM, so I think it would sound somewhat similar to this w/Schon........ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3wUHmAcGZuQ

by **SF-Dano** » Fri Apr 29, 2011 8:31 am

Deb wrote:
SF-Dano wrote:OK - just for laughs and going for some crazy groupings here:

1.
Neal Schon
Mattias Jabbs
Jeff Keith
John Wetton
Ian Paice

2.
Kirk Hammet
Michael Schenker
Steve Harris
Geoff Tate
Nick Menza

3.
Steve Morse
Rik Emmet
Geddy Lee
James LaBrie
Steve Smith

4.
Dave Mustain
Alex Skolnick
Billy Sheehan
Bruce Dickinson
Vinnie Paul

Hmm some pretty interesting combos there.

(4) Pretty darn heavy indeed.
(3) Three Canucks in that one. As long as Rik is singing somewhere in there too, and NOT Geddy.
(1) Have never heard of Mattias? Jeff sounds alot like EM, so I think it would sound somewhat similar to this w/Schon........ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3wUHmAcGZuQ

You may not be to far off as far as Group 1 goes - I had forgotten about that tune.. I do hear similarities between Eric and Jeff's voices, especially in their younger days. Typo - should have been Matthias Jabbs. Lead guitarist for the Scorpions since the early 80s.

by **Archetype** » Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:16 am

Vocals: Roy Khan
Lead Guitar: Glen Drover
Rhythm Guitar: Nick Catanese
Drums: Tom Sharpe
Bass Guitar/Backing Vocals: Ricky Philips

by **S2M** » Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:26 am

Archetype wrote:Vocals: Roy Khan
Lead Guitar: Glen Drover
Rhythm Guitar: Nick Catanese
Drums: Tom Sharpe
Bass Guitar/Backing Vocals: Ricky Philips

No wonder you love the new Journey.......WHO?

by **Archetype** » Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:29 am

S2M wrote:
Archetype wrote:Vocals: Roy Khan
Lead Guitar: Glen Drover
Rhythm Guitar: Nick Catanese
Drums: Tom Sharpe
Bass Guitar/Backing Vocals: Ricky Philips

No wonder you love the new Journey.......WHO?

I'll just take for granted that perhaps your busy routine has deprived you of being exposed to some absolutely terrific talent.

by **S2M** » Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:37 am

Archetype wrote:
S2M wrote:
Archetype wrote:Vocals: Roy Khan
Lead Guitar: Glen Drover
Rhythm Guitar: Nick Catanese
Drums: Tom Sharpe
Bass Guitar/Backing Vocals: Ricky Philips

No wonder you love the new Journey.......WHO?

I'll just take for granted that perhaps your busy routine has deprived you of being exposed to some absolutely terrific talent.

Dude, I listen to more music than you could fathom. think again. Over 750 gigs of music.

by **Archetype** » Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:41 am

S2M wrote:
Archetype wrote:
S2M wrote:
Archetype wrote:Vocals: Roy Khan
Lead Guitar: Glen Drover
Rhythm Guitar: Nick Catanese
Drums: Tom Sharpe
Bass Guitar/Backing Vocals: Ricky Philips

No wonder you love the new Journey.......WHO?

I'll just take for granted that perhaps your busy routine has deprived you of being exposed to some absolutely terrific talent.

Dude, I listen to more music than you could fathom. think again. Over 750 gigs of music.

You you haven't heard of any of these guys? I am suspicious

Ill start you off with some Glen Drover and Tom Sharpe (Tom plays all instruments and is the sole composer)

by **S2M** » Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:59 am

I've seen the name Ricky Phillips.....but that's it.

by **Deb** » Sat Apr 30, 2011 2:39 am

SF-Dano wrote:
Deb wrote:
SF-Dano wrote:OK - just for laughs and going for some crazy groupings here:

1.
Neal Schon
Mattias Jabbs
Jeff Keith
John Wetton
Ian Paice

Hmm some pretty interesting combos there.

(4) Pretty darn heavy indeed.
(3) Three Canucks in that one. As long as Rik is singing somewhere in there too, and NOT Geddy.
(1) Have never heard of Mattias? Jeff sounds alot like EM, so I think it would sound somewhat similar to this w/Schon........ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3wUHmAcGZuQ

You may not be to far off as far as Group 1 goes - I had forgotten about that tune.. I do hear similarities between Eric and Jeff's voices, especially in their younger days. Typo - should have been Matthias Jabbs. Lead guitarist for the Scorpions since the early 80s.

IMO Eric has boatloads more soul, but really liked both their vocals back in the day, very similar tone/timbre. Love the Mechanical Resonance album. Just wish Jeff's voice had held up as well as E's. From the youtubes I've seen he's sounding pretty screechy nowadays, but then again those are youtubes. Saying that, I'd still like to see Tesla LIVE sometime.

by **Archetype** » Sat Apr 30, 2011 10:26 am

Lead Vocals- Jeff Scott Soto
Guitar- John Petrucci
Keyboards- Oliver Palotai
Drums/Vocals- Deen Castronovo
Bass Guitar- Robert Trujillo

by **Archetype** » Wed Jun 22, 2011 7:31 am

Vocals: Russell Allen
Bass: Rob "Blasko" Nicholson
Drums: Jonas Ekdahl
Guitar: Michael Ammot
Guitar: Gus G

by **hoagiepete** » Wed Jun 22, 2011 7:49 am

Schon
Shaw
Blades
Sucherman
Keyboard To Be Named Later

by **JRNYMAN** » Wed Jun 22, 2011 9:16 am

S2M wrote:I've seen the name Ricky Phillips.....but that's it.

Ditto!

by **conversationpc** » Wed Jun 22, 2011 9:21 am

Archetype wrote:You you haven't heard of any of these guys? I am suspicious

Ill start you off with some Glen Drover and Tom Sharpe (Tom plays all instruments and is the sole composer)

Drover had the 2nd guitarist slot in Megadeth prior to Chris Broderick.

by **Tito** » Wed Jun 22, 2011 9:35 am

Majestic wrote:Schon, Scholtz, Shaw, Blades, Castranovo. The group could be called "Schhh" or "Scho Scho Sha."

Can you imagine what killer music this band would make? Also, think about the covers they could do: Journey, Boston, Night Ranger, Styx.

Neal, next time you're not busy...

Even though I don't care and quite frankly I don't know if it's fact about Neal's 5 alimony payments. But that would be the least of his worries after a Scholtz lawsuit. That prick sues everything and everybody. Not to mention the album would take minimum 8 years to record.

by **JRNYMAN** » Wed Jun 22, 2011 9:38 am

Ehwmatt wrote:
JourneyHard wrote:Here is my Super Group Idea!

Steve Perry Lead Singer
Gary Richrath Lead Guitar
Dennis DeYoung Keyboards, Vocals
Steve Smith Drums

Add somebody to play Bass and you got a winner!

Richrath? That guy is more likely to drink his way out of a brown paper bag than play his way out of one

Didn't he die a while back or am I thinking of someone else. I coulda swore Richrath died. Hmm.....

by **Tito** » Wed Jun 22, 2011 9:39 am

JourneyHard wrote:Add somebody to play Bass and you got a winner!

Marcel Jacob!

MR

Dream super group

Dream super group

Re: Dream super group

Re: Dream super group

Re: Dream super group

Re: Dream super group

Re: Dream super group

Re: Dream super group

Re: Dream super group

Re: Dream super group

Who is online