Moderator: Andrew
Escape79 wrote:Not recovered enough to sing the Journey catalogue. Period.
TRUST ME...I'm being nice.
FyreWyngz wrote:Escape79 wrote:Not recovered enough to sing the Journey catalogue. Period.
TRUST ME...I'm being nice.
But all of the chatter in the interviews is about a NEW chapter in the legacy - moving forward with NEW music and getting an album out ASAP - promoting the crap out of it, etc.
Seems like they're ready to move on from the old JOURNEY catalog into some new material. While I applaud this and have been BEGGING for years that they do so - it seems to me that if SA were still on board that not being recovered enough to sing the catalog would be a moot point.
FyreWyngz wrote: Steve Augeri is CURRENTLY recording his debut solo album, IN THE MOMENT, due out the summer of 2007. He’s also putting the finishing touches on the much-anticipated follow-up to the AOR classic TALL STORIES album, launching early next year.
I read this as saying that SA is currently capable of working in the studio. Is he singing? Doesn't say. Is he capable of singing? Doesn't say. Maybe all of the tracks were laid down prior to his condition flaring up. Will he tour next Summer? Who knows. Has he recovered? It appears so but it can't be known for sure.
They way it's spelled out it leads one to believe that he's recovered and ready to fly solo and/or hit the road with Tall Stories in about 7 months.
So if he's recovered then what's the problem?[/b]
JourneyRox wrote:FyreWyngz wrote: Steve Augeri is CURRENTLY recording his debut solo album, IN THE MOMENT, due out the summer of 2007. He’s also putting the finishing touches on the much-anticipated follow-up to the AOR classic TALL STORIES album, launching early next year.
I read this as saying that SA is currently capable of working in the studio. Is he singing? Doesn't say. Is he capable of singing? Doesn't say. Maybe all of the tracks were laid down prior to his condition flaring up. Will he tour next Summer? Who knows. Has he recovered? It appears so but it can't be known for sure.
They way it's spelled out it leads one to believe that he's recovered and ready to fly solo and/or hit the road with Tall Stories in about 7 months.
So if he's recovered then what's the problem?[/b]
Fyre, ur right. U are NOT the sharpest knife. I am, so let me help u w/this
It doesn't say anywhere SA is going to tour. There is NOT one mention of that. It says he is recording an album & finessing TS2.
1. TS2 was recorded a LONG time ago (over a decade).
2. Altho it says that he is recording his debut album, it doesn't say he's actually singing it now. Recording is kind of a generic term. For all we know, these could be tracks he layed down when he was still healthy, before Generations, for example. There were some other songs he had written for Gens that did not make it on the album, for example. Maybe he will use some of those.
3. It took him a very very long time to finish some of the tracks on Gens. For example, FITH took over a couple of months.
4. Have u ever been in a recording studio to record anything? I have, so let me try to give u an analogy. It's kinda like how they shoot a movie in a way. U know how they have the clipboard & do takes & the director watches them to see how they look, then if he/she doesn't like them, they do them over? Well it is a lot like that. As u lay down bits & pieces, if u don't like the way they sound, u go ahead & redo them. Then, they all get mixed together to sound like one smooth track.
5. Let's go back to a boot that we have of one of Augeri's last performances on June 24 2006 in Jones Beach (do u have that one?), u can listen to his singing voice there.
Here's Stone In Love: http://download.yousendit.com/D80E514B7BE9AE61
He was still able to sing a few notes w/in one octave. As Jon Cain explained in his interview, SA has a vocal paralysis. This means that one of his vocal cords which was once flexible is no longer flexible & has trouble expanding & closing. He may have gotten this condition from his years of using a steroid inhaler for his asthma. Anyway, he can still sing some of the notes, but when his vocal cords are supposed to move for different notes w/in that octave or to allow him to reach into another octave, at least one of the cords is not doing so. In a studio situation, where he could practice this over & over, he will probably be able to get to at least some of those notes over time, & those he can't get to can be massaged w/special software.
6. Let's read about the condition Jon Cain, his friend, says he has:
http://www.intelihealth.com/IH/ihtIH/WS ... 10976.html
"In some cases, the voice returns on its own within a year. If not, the condition is likely to be permanent."
SA has had this condition for more than a yr now. That means it is likely to be permanent. Therefore, he is not, as u speculate "recovered". However, that doesn't mean that he can't do some limited studio work if it's only paralysis on one side of his cords.
Got it now? I tried to keep it simple. If u don't understand any of it, just holler.
FyreWyngz wrote:...So if he's recovered then what's the problem?[/b]
fred_journeyman wrote:FyreWyngz wrote:...So if he's recovered then what's the problem?[/b]
Probably doesn't have the voice anymore for Perry tunes. Simple as that. I'm glad for him though that he's moving on with his own projects.
silverblue wrote:JourneyRox, you cracked me up with that first line...and, ditto on what Carol said.
JourneyRox wrote:silverblue wrote:JourneyRox, you cracked me up with that first line...and, ditto on what Carol said.
Another person last nite said Jeff sings high notes in falsetto, but his tonality is so deep it sounds normal to us. I just about rolled on the floor laughing at that one. Falsetto is false voice, like the Bee Gees. That sounds normal? Damn. I must have weird freaking ears then. If we heard one of the Gibb bros sing in head or chest voice, it would have sounded way different (not sure if they ever did as I haven't studied their music).
JourneyRox wrote:silverblue wrote:
I'm seriously tired of all these people pontificating on things they know nothing about. I read last nite where someone claimed he/she was a musician & Jeff sings "off key". I can't believe a musician would say that.
Red13JoePa wrote:JourneyRox wrote:silverblue wrote:
I'm seriously tired of all these people pontificating on things they know nothing about. I read last nite where someone claimed he/she was a musician & Jeff sings "off key". I can't believe a musician would say that.
Yea, that's bullshit.
Unless they criticize Augeri then it's valid.![]()
silverblue wrote:JourneyRox, you cracked me up with that first line...and, ditto on what Carol said.
JourneyRox wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I'm talking about the whole place in general not you specifically.
Oh, by the way...
Beat it.
Go beat off! Maybe u would do that well
JourneyRox wrote:brywool wrote:I have talked with a mutual friend who would know and apparently, Steve's voice has fully recovered.
That's good news for him.
Well I'll believe it when he performs LIVE on tour.
Lula wrote:silverblue wrote:JourneyRox, you cracked me up with that first line...and, ditto on what Carol said.
You got that right Tammy. I'll third what you said JRox.
Red13JoePa wrote:JourneyRox wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I'm talking about the whole place in general not you specifically.
Oh, by the way...
Beat it.
Go beat off! Maybe u would do that well
OK, Mr Refined.
![]()
You stay classy now.
JourneyRox wrote:FyreWyngz wrote: Steve Augeri is CURRENTLY recording his debut solo album, IN THE MOMENT, due out the summer of 2007. He’s also putting the finishing touches on the much-anticipated follow-up to the AOR classic TALL STORIES album, launching early next year.
I read this as saying that SA is currently capable of working in the studio. Is he singing? Doesn't say. Is he capable of singing? Doesn't say. Maybe all of the tracks were laid down prior to his condition flaring up. Will he tour next Summer? Who knows. Has he recovered? It appears so but it can't be known for sure.
They way it's spelled out it leads one to believe that he's recovered and ready to fly solo and/or hit the road with Tall Stories in about 7 months.
So if he's recovered then what's the problem?[/b]
Fyre, ur right. U are NOT the sharpest knife. I am, so let me help u w/this
It doesn't say anywhere SA is going to tour. There is NOT one mention of that. It says he is recording an album & finessing TS2.
1. TS2 was recorded a LONG time ago (over a decade).
2. Altho it says that he is recording his debut album, it doesn't say he's actually singing it now. Recording is kind of a generic term. For all we know, these could be tracks he layed down when he was still healthy, before Generations, for example. There were some other songs he had written for Gens that did not make it on the album, for example. Maybe he will use some of those.
3. It took him a very very long time to finish some of the tracks on Gens. For example, FITH took over a couple of months.
4. Have u ever been in a recording studio to record anything? I have, so let me try to give u an analogy. It's kinda like how they shoot a movie in a way. U know how they have the clipboard & do takes & the director watches them to see how they look, then if he/she doesn't like them, they do them over? Well it is a lot like that. As u lay down bits & pieces, if u don't like the way they sound, u go ahead & redo them. Then, they all get mixed together to sound like one smooth track.
5. Let's go back to a boot that we have of one of Augeri's last performances on June 24 2006 in Jones Beach (do u have that one?), u can listen to his singing voice there.
Here's Stone In Love: http://download.yousendit.com/D80E514B7BE9AE61
He was still able to sing a few notes w/in one octave. As Jon Cain explained in his interview, SA has a vocal paralysis. This means that one of his vocal cords which was once flexible is no longer flexible & has trouble expanding & closing. He may have gotten this condition from his years of using a steroid inhaler for his asthma. Anyway, he can still sing some of the notes, but when his vocal cords are supposed to move for different notes w/in that octave or to allow him to reach into another octave, at least one of the cords is not doing so. In a studio situation, where he could practice this over & over, he will probably be able to get to at least some of those notes over time, & those he can't get to can be massaged w/special software.
6. Let's read about the condition Jon Cain, his friend, says he has:
http://www.intelihealth.com/IH/ihtIH/WS ... 10976.html
"In some cases, the voice returns on its own within a year. If not, the condition is likely to be permanent."
SA has had this condition for more than a yr now. That means it is likely to be permanent. Therefore, he is not, as u speculate "recovered". However, that doesn't mean that he can't do some limited studio work if it's only paralysis on one side of his cords.
Got it now? I tried to keep it simple. If u don't understand any of it, just holler.
FyreWyngz wrote:JourneyRox wrote:FyreWyngz wrote:
Regarding #3: Why did it take so long to finish FITH? Are you saying that his voice was shot? Where is this reported? It's not unusual at all for a lot of time to be taken to finish things. Cain labored over the lyrics for Be Good To Yourself for 5 months! Should we report then that he's somehow lyrically challenged and in need of recovery at the Emily Dickinson Center for Poets?
FyreWyngz wrote: Ok. I may be a little sharper now. But you echoed some things that I alluded to. I recognize that the statement left out major details. You've also made some broad assumptions where there are no details.
FyreWyngz wrote: Regarding #3: Why did it take so long to finish FITH? Are you saying that his voice was shot? Where is this reported? It's not unusual at all for a lot of time to be taken to finish things. Cain labored over the lyrics for Be Good To Yourself for 5 months! Should we report then that he's somehow lyrically challenged and in need of recovery at the Emily Dickinson Center for Poets?
FyreWyngz wrote: As for your other obnoxious and elitist ramblings I'll agree with your superiority complex driven howlings
FyreWyngz wrote: however regarding my speculation: the statement was that SA would be monitored for recovery. The JSS announcement presents the info in such a way that leads to speculation as they haven't confirmed nor denied SA's recovery. If he was truly out for health issues then it stands to reason that it be confirmed and NOT wish him well on his future endeavors behind the mic.
Ultimately, it's clear to me that they wanted him out for whatever reasons and using his health was a convenient and smokescreen of an excuse.
Red13JoePa wrote: It's not reported anywhere, Fyre.
It's speculation masquerading matter-of-factly as truth. Happens around here from time to time.
I happen to have heard this as well and find it to have merit, but that is because of the REAL source from where it came, not this guy.
The answer to the cain question is that it's perfectly fine for JC to labor over lyrics but the AugeriIsTheRootOfAllEvil crowd's double standard makes it just another inditement of his fraudulence to have to take a month to lay vox down for a track.
JourneyRox wrote:
Since we're speculating, let me present another scenario that would be equally as feasible as urs. Just think about it, ok? U don't have to agree w/it, just ponder it. SA & his lawyer(s) did not want Journey to confirm or deny his recovery or lack therof.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 29 guests