So, who has the best solo career?

by **ProgRocker53** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 4:40 am

Neal, Perry, or The Frig? Does Smitty's Vital Information count? Ah, I'll throw him in here too. And JSS.

by **LucyFurr** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 4:42 am

Hands down Steve Perry. I miss that man! (No dis intended Jeff!)

by **Granny** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 4:49 am

Thats a tough one...so I didn't vote....for some reason I cannot compare SP to JSS...I know all of SP solo stuff but I just getting into all of JSS stuff which BTW, is excellent...Boot Lady sent me most of JSS previous CD, and WOW, they are awesome...I think their voices are totally different but truly love them both...

SO, I pick JSS and SP!

by AR » Tue Mar 13, 2007 4:49 am

Perry sold the most records, but he really only has 2 releases. Not exactly a solo "career". Lazy fuck.

by **Matthew** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 4:59 am

AR wrote:Perry sold the most records, but he really only has 2 releases. Not exactly a solo "career". Lazy fuck.

Quality...not quantity...

"Street Talk" alone means that Perry wins hands down.

by AR » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:04 am

Matthew wrote:
AR wrote:Perry sold the most records, but he really only has 2 releases. Not exactly a solo "career". Lazy fuck.

Quality...not quantity...

"Street Talk" alone means that Perry wins hands down.

I love Street Talk.

FTLOSM sucks donkey balls though.

Soto has tons of great material. Critically, his output blows Perry out of the water as a "solo".

by **Melissa** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:09 am

Voted for Jeff, since he's done so much & it's all great imo. One of my fav singers, way before joining Journey.

SP is my fav of all time though.

by **Matthew** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:09 am

AR wrote:
Matthew wrote:
AR wrote:Perry sold the most records, but he really only has 2 releases. Not exactly a solo "career". Lazy fuck.

Quality...not quantity...

"Street Talk" alone means that Perry wins hands down.

I love Street Talk.

FTLOSM sucks donkey balls though.

Soto has tons of great material. Critically, his output blows Perry out of the water as a "solo".

No, Perry never did fulfill his potential as a solo artist - but let's get real: JSS was never in the same league.

by **Rockindeano** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:18 am

This is a very good question.

I could make the case for 5 of the guys.

1) Perry. Commercial success. Platinum Records. Hit songs.

2) Schon. Awesome material, side prjects, and oh yeah, a Grammy nomination.

3) Friga. Tons of piano issues and now dude has a top 7 AC hit.

4) Soto. Might have done more than all those combined, and did it without the Journey name to sell himself. Impressive body of work.

5) Rolie. He might have more quality than them all.

by **Marc S** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:18 am

FTLOSM...superb methinks. Surprised you'd disregard it like that AR, even if its just for the opener with those lush vocals. Big production as well, more late 80s than built for speed 90s, but still sounds good.

by **belar** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:22 am

Perry only had two solo albums and maybe a total of 3 songs off of those two albums which were of a similar quality to his output with Journey. Jeff has had, what, four strictly "solo" albums which, from what I've heard of them, are better than Perry's two, but Jeff also has forty billion other projects he's worked on, with Talisman, Takara, Human Clay, Humanimal, Axel Rudi Pell, Kuni, Skrapp Mettle, etc., etc., etc. and everything that I've heard has fallen in the range of solid to fantastic. I'd put anything by Talisman up against Perry's solo material any day of the week and twice on Sunday, and I have always loved Journey with Perry. I just don't think the songwriting was there for Perry without Neal and Jon, and even though the voice was still there, the songs, for the most part, were weak. Neal has some nice solo stuff, too, but my vote goes to JSS.

by **Matthew** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:23 am

Marc S wrote:FTLOSM...superb methinks. Surprised you'd disregard it like that Matthew, even if its just for the opener with those lush vocals. Big production as well, more late 80s than built for speed 90s, but still sounds good.

Oh, I agree Marc. It's a big, lush record with some great tracks. But for me it didn't quite hit the heights of "Street Talk". Also - "Melody" off Against the Wall is one of my favourite Perry performances.

Overall, though - in terms of quality and quantity - I don't think Perry's solo career reflected his spectacular talent.

But the same can be said for Schon and Cain. Sorry but I cannot listen to Smooth Jazz and it baffles me why these two extraordinary muasicians have wasted so much time being so utterly bland.

by **ohsherrie** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:25 am

I had to go with Perry since he's the one who's most widely known and has charted higher than any of the others, even Journey. Of course the song he charted highest with just happened to be Oh Sherrie. :wink:

by **Marc S** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:28 am

Mind you, Frig, Schon and Randy Jackson rocked like a mutha when they did Freight Train Heart with Aussie Jimmy Barnes, thats got some superb co-written stuff on, kind of hard Journeyesque. 1987 I think?

by **Matthew** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:30 am

belar wrote:everything that I've heard has fallen in the range of solid to fantastic.

I've only ever heard "solid"....except maybe "Believe In Me". But even that wilts in comparison to - say - "Foolish Heart".

by **Matthew** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:32 am

Marc S wrote:Mind you, Frig, Schon and Randy Jackson rocked like a mutha when they did Freight Train Heart with Aussie Jimmy Barnes, thats got some superb co-written stuff on, kind of hard Journeyesque. 1987 I think?

I still haven't heard that song! Can anyone face posting it?

by **Rockindeano** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:33 am

ohsherrie wrote:I had to go with Perry since he's the one who's most widely known and has charted higher than any of the others, even Journey. Of course the song he charted highest with just happened to be Oh Sherrie.

O really?

Perry NEVER charted higher than Journey be it CD's or songs.

Song- Open Arms was #2
Album-Escape #1

by **Red13JoePa** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:34 am

Best Schon. Not my usual Perry rip, either b/c if he could've kept putting out quality stuff like his first 2 records he'd up there. Schon has multiple good solo works.

Must successful, Perry EASILY.

by **Rockindeano** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:34 am

Matthew wrote:
belar wrote:everything that I've heard has fallen in the range of solid to fantastic.

I've only ever heard "solid"....except maybe "Believe In Me". But even that wilts in comparison to - say - "Foolish Heart".

Dude, you're fuckin gay.

by AR » Tue Mar 13, 2007 5:38 am

Marc S wrote:FTLOSM...superb methinks. Surprised you'd disregard it like that AR, even if its just for the opener with those lush vocals. Big production as well, more late 80s than built for speed 90s, but still sounds good.

I SWEAR, that I have tried to spin that record and just can't get into it. Same with Trial By Fire.

I think Street Talk is a fucking masterpiece though. "Captured By The Moment", "Running Alone", "Strung Out" - I'm all about that shit. :!:

by **Deb** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 9:05 am

Had to vote Perry, simply 'strungout' out on The Voice. :lol:

Enjoying the hell out of Jeff's solo work though, so he's thisclose! And I haven't heard enough of Gregg's, Smitty's or Jon's solo work to even say.

by **Behshad** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 9:16 am

RockinDeano wrote:This is a very good question.

I could make the case for 5 of the guys.

1) Perry. Commercial success. Platinum Records. Hit songs.

2) Schon. Awesome material, side prjects, and oh yeah, a Grammy nomination.

3) Friga. Tons of piano issues and now dude has a top 7 AC hit.

4) Soto. Might have done more than all those combined, and did it without the Journey name to sell himself. Impressive body of work.

5) Rolie. He might have more quality than them all.

Couldnt have said it better myself.
(By the way, I dont think Matthew is gay, I think he is just deaf , cut him some slack please

)

by **ohsherrie** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 9:23 am

RockinDeano wrote:
ohsherrie wrote:I had to go with Perry since he's the one who's most widely known and has charted higher than any of the others, even Journey. Of course the song he charted highest with just happened to be Oh Sherrie.

O really?

Perry NEVER charted higher than Journey be it CD's or songs.

Song- Open Arms was #2
Album-Escape #1

Maybe I was wrong. I would still vote for Perry though.

by **Matthew** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 9:24 am

RockinDeano wrote:
Matthew wrote:
belar wrote:everything that I've heard has fallen in the range of solid to fantastic.

I've only ever heard "solid"....except maybe "Believe In Me". But even that wilts in comparison to - say - "Foolish Heart".

Dude, you're fuckin gay.

Yes, that was a bit gay, wasn't it? Maybe I should have chosen "Captured By the Moment" or "Strung Out" instead.

by **Matthew** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 9:41 am

Behshad wrote:
RockinDeano wrote:This is a very good question.

I could make the case for 5 of the guys.

1) Perry. Commercial success. Platinum Records. Hit songs.

2) Schon. Awesome material, side prjects, and oh yeah, a Grammy nomination.

3) Friga. Tons of piano issues and now dude has a top 7 AC hit.

4) Soto. Might have done more than all those combined, and did it without the Journey name to sell himself. Impressive body of work.

5) Rolie. He might have more quality than them all.

Couldnt have said it better myself.
(By the way, I dont think Matthew is gay, I think he is just deaf , cut him some slack please )

Thank you Behshad. I was starting to feel insecure about my masculinity for a moment there.

Can I ask...have you heard "Elegance On The Catwalk" by Jonathan Cain? If so, do you think that you have to be both gay and deaf to appreciate it?

by **Enigma869** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 9:52 am

I'm not sure this one is even close. Out of the people on that list, Perry is the only one who most of America even knows had a "solo career". As I've said in the past, whether you like Perry or not (and I know many here don't), it doesn't change the fact that Perry is the only member of Journey who had mainstream, commercial success without the name Journey attached to it!

John from Boston

by **Matthew** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 9:54 am

RockinDeano wrote:
ohsherrie wrote:I had to go with Perry since he's the one who's most widely known and has charted higher than any of the others, even Journey. Of course the song he charted highest with just happened to be Oh Sherrie.

O really?

Perry NEVER charted higher than Journey be it CD's or songs.

Song- Open Arms was #2
Album-Escape #1

No - but he came very, very close. "Oh Sherrie" was #3.
Street Talk was #4.

by AR » Tue Mar 13, 2007 9:54 am

Enigma869 wrote:I'm not sure this one is even close. Out of the people on that list, Perry is the only one who most of America even knows had a "solo career". As I've said in the past, whether you like Perry or not (and I know many here don't), it doesn't change the fact that Perry is the only member of Journey who had mainstream, commercial success without the name Journey attached to it!

John from Boston

John my response on this is quantity AND quality. Perry had one AWESOME solo album and one shitty one.

Soto recorded much more, and I like his material better. He wins hands down IMO.

by **SteveForever** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 9:56 am

Enigma869 wrote:I'm not sure this one is even close. Out of the people on that list, Perry is the only one who most of America even knows had a "solo career". As I've said in the past, whether you like Perry or not (and I know many here don't), it doesn't change the fact that Perry is the only member of Journey who had mainstream, commercial success without the name Journey attached to it!

John from Boston

Plus if you look at how many fan websites are devoted to him it says it all. If ony we could see their bank accounts...

by **Matthew** » Tue Mar 13, 2007 9:56 am

Enigma869 wrote: Perry is the only member of Journey who had mainstream, commercial success without the name Journey attached to it!

It's an undeniable fact. (And Bad English doesn't count as a solo project.)

MR

So, who has the best solo career?

Whose solo career do you like the best?

So, who has the best solo career?

Who is online