Which band would Arnel sound better as a vocalist in?

by **G.I.Jim** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 4:23 pm

Just a thought, but which band do you think Arnel would be a better replacement vocalist for...Journey or Survivor? When I first heard him sing with "The Zoo", I thought MAN, he'd sound awesome as a replacement for Survivor! I've heard all of the survivor clips with their new singer, but honestly I don't think he sounds at ALL like Jimi Jamison.

I think Arnel will do a great job with Journey, I just kinda wish he was Survivor's new singer. As they sound now, I wouldn't go to see them if it were free! I think their new singer has a good voice, just not a Survivor voice!

Here's a clip of Arnel's Survivor tunes...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S_s92u1OKRA

Or

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fgVQQnI ... re=related

Here's Arnel on the Journey tunes...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=88nfiZ-y ... re=related

Or

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6HjcCzgC ... re=related

by **Arnelian** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 4:30 pm

SURVIVOR OR TOTO

by **Andrew** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 4:32 pm

Toto???????? :roll:

by **G.I.Jim** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 4:36 pm

Arnelian wrote:SURVIVOR OR TOTO

Wasn't an option dude! Toto's got enough kick-ass singers! they don't need anyone else right now. :lol:

by **bradwjensen** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 4:39 pm

I like his Aerosmith song too.

by **G.I.Jim** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 4:44 pm

bradwjensen wrote:I like his Aerosmith song too.

I do to, but WTF??? This is between Journey and Survivor! Not Toto, Aerosmith, or any of the other hundred songs they did! :lol:

You're killing me here!

by **journey123** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 4:57 pm

G.I.Jim wrote:
bradwjensen wrote:I like his Aerosmith song too.

I do to, but WTF??? This is between Journey and Survivor! Not Toto, Aerosmith, or any of the other hundred songs they did! You're killing me here!

This is such a difficult choice but I have chosen Journey. I must admit I'm a little bias because he's in Journey now. But either way he pulled it off on those videos.

by **G.I.Jim** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 5:00 pm

journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
bradwjensen wrote:I like his Aerosmith song too.

I do to, but WTF??? This is between Journey and Survivor! Not Toto, Aerosmith, or any of the other hundred songs they did! You're killing me here!

This is such a difficult choice but I have chosen Journey. I must admit I'm a little bias because he's in Journey now. But either way he pulled it off on those videos.

I think he'll sound great in Journey also. Maybe he'll give it his own sound. In a way, maybe it's better that he's in Journey, because now maybe we'll get a Journey album with Survivorish vocals. And YES, I just made that name up! :lol:

by **journey123** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 5:08 pm

G.I.Jim wrote:
journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
bradwjensen wrote:I like his Aerosmith song too.

I do to, but WTF??? This is between Journey and Survivor! Not Toto, Aerosmith, or any of the other hundred songs they did! You're killing me here!

This is such a difficult choice but I have chosen Journey. I must admit I'm a little bias because he's in Journey now. But either way he pulled it off on those videos.

I think he'll sound great in Journey also. Maybe he'll give it his own sound. In a way, maybe it's better that he's in Journey, because now maybe we'll get a Journey album with Survivorish vocals. And YES, I just made that name up!

What about a Surviving Journey for the album's title? It doesn't sound good though.

by **G.I.Jim** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 5:09 pm

journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
bradwjensen wrote:I like his Aerosmith song too.

I do to, but WTF??? This is between Journey and Survivor! Not Toto, Aerosmith, or any of the other hundred songs they did! You're killing me here!

This is such a difficult choice but I have chosen Journey. I must admit I'm a little bias because he's in Journey now. But either way he pulled it off on those videos.

I think he'll sound great in Journey also. Maybe he'll give it his own sound. In a way, maybe it's better that he's in Journey, because now maybe we'll get a Journey album with Survivorish vocals. And YES, I just made that name up!

Surviving Journey

How about Jourvivor, or Surney? :lol:

by **journey123** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 5:11 pm

G.I.Jim wrote:
journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
bradwjensen wrote:I like his Aerosmith song too.

I do to, but WTF??? This is between Journey and Survivor! Not Toto, Aerosmith, or any of the other hundred songs they did! You're killing me here!

This is such a difficult choice but I have chosen Journey. I must admit I'm a little bias because he's in Journey now. But either way he pulled it off on those videos.

I think he'll sound great in Journey also. Maybe he'll give it his own sound. In a way, maybe it's better that he's in Journey, because now maybe we'll get a Journey album with Survivorish vocals. And YES, I just made that name up!

What about a Surviving Journey for the album's title? It doesn't sound good though.

How about Jourvivor, or Surney?

He did a good Bon Jovi as well. For that it could be BonJour Monsieur

by **G.I.Jim** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 5:15 pm

journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
bradwjensen wrote:I like his Aerosmith song too.

I do to, but WTF??? This is between Journey and Survivor! Not Toto, Aerosmith, or any of the other hundred songs they did! You're killing me here!

This is such a difficult choice but I have chosen Journey. I must admit I'm a little bias because he's in Journey now. But either way he pulled it off on those videos.

I think he'll sound great in Journey also. Maybe he'll give it his own sound. In a way, maybe it's better that he's in Journey, because now maybe we'll get a Journey album with Survivorish vocals. And YES, I just made that name up!

What about a Surviving Journey for the album's title? It doesn't sound good though.

How about Jourvivor, or Surney?

He did a good Bon Jovi as well. For that it could be BonJour Monsieur

THAT one went right over my head! Anyway, are you a Survivor fan? I was really amazed when I heard him sing "The search is over", and even more so on "Ever since the world began"! He's definitely got the voice down. I think he sounds much better on the Survivor stuff, but that's just my opinion.

by **journey123** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 5:26 pm

G.I.Jim wrote:
journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
journey123 wrote:
G.I.Jim wrote:
bradwjensen wrote:I like his Aerosmith song too.

I do to, but WTF??? This is between Journey and Survivor! Not Toto, Aerosmith, or any of the other hundred songs they did! You're killing me here!

This is such a difficult choice but I have chosen Journey. I must admit I'm a little bias because he's in Journey now. But either way he pulled it off on those videos.

I think he'll sound great in Journey also. Maybe he'll give it his own sound. In a way, maybe it's better that he's in Journey, because now maybe we'll get a Journey album with Survivorish vocals. And YES, I just made that name up!

What about a Surviving Journey for the album's title? It doesn't sound good though.

How about Jourvivor, or Surney?

He did a good Bon Jovi as well. For that it could be BonJour Monsieur

THAT one went right over my head! Anyway, are you a Survivor fan? I was really amazed when I heard him sing "The search is over", and even more so on "Ever since the world began"! He's definitely got the voice down. I think he sounds much better on the Survivor stuff, but that's just my opinion.

This is, by far, the longest series of "qoutes" ever.

I enjoy quite a varied style of music so long as the content is good and not just shouting.

Every one here might hate me now but I do enjoy theatre/musical as well. Miss Saigon, Les Miserable (both had been played by Lea Salonga, a Filpino) not to mention her singing voice of Jasmine in Aladin (Disney)

and of course Phantom of the Opera.

by **G.I.Jim** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 5:31 pm

That's a little over my head as well! Just never got into that stuff! As long as you like Journey...we're okay! :lol:

by **journey123** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 5:33 pm

G.I.Jim wrote::lol: That's a little over my head as well! Just never got into that stuff! As long as you like Journey...we're okay!

I do like Survivor as well.

by **The Sushi Hunter** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 6:58 pm

Tough call, I guess he's good at both. Though only two bands to choose from, not a great deal of options here. Too bad Europe wasn't one of the options because if it was, that's where I would put my money down.

by **styxman** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 8:45 pm

Having no real credentials, by that I mean Arnel would have struggled to embed his name in the Melodic world, continuing with his former band and as the clock is always ticking, Journey had to be the best vehicle to hitch a ride. If not Journey, then yes I agree Toto could have been an option but not Survivor, as the exposure isn't as great. Regardless of how in pans out with Journey, Arnel will be on the Rock Map and if it all goes pear shaped then at least he'll be know to a wider audience.

I personally would have liked to see him fronting The Bay City Rollers

by **styxman** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 8:50 pm

What I forgot to mention is - Toto now, have more of a European/Asian following than that of the US and it also looks like Journey are now adopting a view that overseas is a serious market, by Journey including Arnel in the lineup, it's a win, win situation for them. They fuck up in the States, there's still a very lucrative market over the pond and in Asia :wink:

by **Vladan** » Sun Dec 30, 2007 11:16 pm

Arnelian wrote:SURVIVOR OR TOTO

Survivor yes, TOTO... ummm no. That's like stepping back in time back to 1983, and taking Freddie Mercury away from Queen and asking for a replacement, the simple question... WHY?.

by **journeywoman** » Mon Dec 31, 2007 12:11 am

Andrew wrote:Toto????????

no no no.They do not need help Drew.I like Toto.

by **G.I.Jim** » Mon Dec 31, 2007 1:24 am

journeywoman wrote:
Andrew wrote:Toto????????
no no no.They do not need help Drew.I like Toto.

I'm with you. Why fix it if it isn't broken! :wink:

by **youkeepmewaiting** » Mon Dec 31, 2007 1:32 am

I voted for Journey, as thats who he will be with and who i want to see him with.

by **G.I.Jim** » Mon Dec 31, 2007 1:35 am

youkeepmewaiting wrote:I voted for Journey, as thats who he will be with and who i want to see him with.

If I had a choice, he'd be with Survivor. He sounds amazing singing their stuff. I'd like to see them put out another kick-ass cd, but I don't see that ever happening now. :cry:

I am excited about the new Journey cd also though! 50% of the votes so far say they could care less either way! Man...harsh crowd! :lol:

by **larryfromnextdoor** » Mon Dec 31, 2007 1:54 am

styxman wrote:I personally would have liked to see him fronting The Bay City Rollers

just like a Welsh to be raggin on a nice Scottish band...........................................
..........................

by **youkeepmewaiting** » Mon Dec 31, 2007 1:57 am

G.I.Jim wrote:
youkeepmewaiting wrote:I voted for Journey, as thats who he will be with and who i want to see him with.

If I had a choice, he'd be with Survivor. He sounds amazing singing their stuff. I'd like to see them put out another kick-ass cd, but I don't see that ever happening now. :

Yeah i wasnt a fan of Reach, Peterick is to Sullivan like Cain is to Schon.

by **strangegrey** » Mon Dec 31, 2007 2:03 am

I'm not sure that Steve Lukather would allow Arnel to bring his music stand...so that scratches out Toto.

As for survivor, Frankie Sullivan likes to make sure his singers have enough financial assets so that he can sue them later on in life. :roll:

by **Arkansas** » Mon Dec 31, 2007 2:43 am

Btw, not 'could care less', but 'couldn't care less'.

I mean, he's probably a good singer and will do fine, but if Journey found 'Joe Schmuckatelli from Madison WI', I wouldn't feel any different. More and more I feel that this band has become a tribute to themselves. It's kind of a strange feeling, but it's like the Hall of Presidents at Disneyland - they're just robots going through the motions.

later~

by **Perrydise** » Mon Dec 31, 2007 2:52 am

I think he could do alot for the Partridge Family. :lol:

by **G.I.Jim** » Mon Dec 31, 2007 2:57 am

Arkansas wrote:Btw, not 'could care less', but 'couldn't care less'.

I mean, he's probably a good singer and will do fine, but if Journey found 'Joe Schmuckatelli from Madison WI', I wouldn't feel any different. More and more I feel that this band has become a tribute to themselves. It's kind of a strange feeling, but it's like the Hall of Presidents at Disneyland - they're just robots going through the motions.

later~

SHUT-UP!

I never claimed to be an english major! I think you're wrong, but we're all entitled to our own opinions. I think we're going to be surprised by the next album...in a good way! Guess we'll know soon.

by **Wally_Hatchet** » Mon Dec 31, 2007 3:00 am

I think he sounds almost exactly like Jimi Jamison - would be a perfect fit for Survivor.

MR

Which band would Arnel sound better as a vocalist in?

Should he sing with Journey or Survivor?

Which band would Arnel sound better as a vocalist in?

Toto?

Re: Toto?

Who is online