Moderator: Andrew
SF-Dano wrote:Sounds to me like after the Santana thing, it may be time for someone to replace Cain and I can see that getting really ugly.
SF-Dano wrote:Sounds to me like after the Santana thing, it may be time for someone to replace Cain and I can see that getting really ugly.
perryfan61 wrote:quote"Journey/Survivor"]SF-Dano wrote:Sounds to me like after the Santana thing, it may be time for someone to replace Cain and I can see that getting really ugly.
Yeah. I'm a huge fan of Jonathan Cain. But if he's holding Journey back from recording a new album, then he needs to be replaced. Journey is probably going to come to an end in a couple of years from now, and they can't be wasting those years because Cain is holding them back.
Neal will have to find a good songwriter, as Jonathan is the only one they have.
Journey/Survivor wrote:SF-Dano wrote:Sounds to me like after the Santana thing, it may be time for someone to replace Cain and I can see that getting really ugly.
Yeah. I'm a huge fan of Jonathan Cain. But if he's holding Journey back from recording a new album, then he needs to be replaced. Journey is probably going to come to an end in a couple of years from now, and they can't be wasting those years because Cain is holding them back.
FamilyMan wrote:After the disappointment of Eclipse, it's no surprise the studio is the last place these band members want to be.
FamilyMan wrote:You are all on crack. There is no way Jonathan Cain is going to be replaced. After the disappointment of Eclipse, it's no surprise the studio is the last place these band members want to be. And it won't be a deciding factor in whether or not the band stays in tact. It's all about the road now. And has been for some time.
SF-Dano wrote:Not that it is going to happen, but if replacing Friga becomes a reality, of course the position should first be offered to Rolie. If that doesn't pan out, I think Alan Fitzgerald would possibly work. Long time Bay Area musician (Night Ranger, Gamma, Montrose, Hagar..) who has ran in the same circles as the Journey guys for a long time. Another old school name that the guys are probably familiar with is Tim Gorman.
Or maybe, Journey just is finally over.
Majestic wrote:SF-Dano wrote:Not that it is going to happen, but if replacing Friga becomes a reality, of course the position should first be offered to Rolie. If that doesn't pan out, I think Alan Fitzgerald would possibly work. Long time Bay Area musician (Night Ranger, Gamma, Montrose, Hagar..) who has ran in the same circles as the Journey guys for a long time. Another old school name that the guys are probably familiar with is Tim Gorman.
Or maybe, Journey just is finally over.
I thought that too, but then I was thinking that Rolie probably can't play Journey music from Cain era. I don't think he is that skilled as a pianist. Could be wrong though.
Journey/Survivor wrote:FamilyMan wrote:You are all on crack. There is no way Jonathan Cain is going to be replaced. After the disappointment of Eclipse, it's no surprise the studio is the last place these band members want to be. And it won't be a deciding factor in whether or not the band stays in tact. It's all about the road now. And has been for some time.
It appears to only be Cain that is opposed to recording a new album.
Unfortunately, Cain seems to share Frankie Sullivan's (Survivor's guitarist) opinion that you only record a new album if you can make shit-loads of money from album sales, and that you should only tour, because that's where the money is now.
ebake02 wrote:Journey/Survivor wrote:FamilyMan wrote:You are all on crack. There is no way Jonathan Cain is going to be replaced. After the disappointment of Eclipse, it's no surprise the studio is the last place these band members want to be. And it won't be a deciding factor in whether or not the band stays in tact. It's all about the road now. And has been for some time.
It appears to only be Cain that is opposed to recording a new album.
Unfortunately, Cain seems to share Frankie Sullivan's (Survivor's guitarist) opinion that you only record a new album if you can make shit-loads of money from album sales, and that you should only tour, because that's where the money is now.
But he is spot on, album sales are in the toilet. How else could you explain the fact that classic rock acts who haven't had a hit album in decades are still selling 10,000+ a show.
Journey/Survivor wrote:I'm not denying that. I'm just saying that it sucks that Sullivan or Cain or any other great musician is only focused on money. Especially seeing as Sullivan and Cain have made millions and millions of dollars already.
ebake02 wrote:Journey/Survivor wrote:I'm not denying that. I'm just saying that it sucks that Sullivan or Cain or any other great musician is only focused on money. Especially seeing as Sullivan and Cain have made millions and millions of dollars already.
Cain has never been a fan of Eclipse so I'm thinking that this is a tantrum on his part. He's digging in his heals until Schon caves and agrees to a new record his way.
ebake02 wrote:Journey/Survivor wrote:I'm not denying that. I'm just saying that it sucks that Sullivan or Cain or any other great musician is only focused on money. Especially seeing as Sullivan and Cain have made millions and millions of dollars already.
Cain has never been a fan of Eclipse so I'm thinking that this is a tantrum on his part. He's digging in his heals until Schon caves and agrees to a new record his way.
Journey/Survivor wrote:ebake02 wrote:Journey/Survivor wrote:I'm not denying that. I'm just saying that it sucks that Sullivan or Cain or any other great musician is only focused on money. Especially seeing as Sullivan and Cain have made millions and millions of dollars already.
Cain has never been a fan of Eclipse so I'm thinking that this is a tantrum on his part. He's digging in his heals until Schon caves and agrees to a new record his way.
I think that that is definitely part of it, too.
Jeremey wrote:Is it really appropriate to bag on a songwriter (Cain) if they feel like they legitimately don't have anything interesting to say musically?
I get the feeling that Cain simply believes if he doesn't have anything worthwhile to add to the existing legacy, there are better ways to spend his time at this stage in his career. As opposed to Schon, who has given the impression that he's at a creative zenith in his songwriting – arguably mistaking quantity for quality at this point.
It doesn't necessarily have to do with "money" – Cain has always been a champion of the "legacy," as much as Perry, whereas Neal Schon has been vocal in the past about Journey being a constantly evolving musical energy. The problem is "evolving" implies "improving," and Cain may be at a point where he just doesn't feel that he has anything to contribute to improve upon the past.
Plus he's obviously been through some pretty immense changes in his personal life over the past 3 years, through his divorce and new love interest and now new wife and future. It could be that he just needs some time to digest all this artistically before he sits down to write about it. These are the kinds of things that can spark timeless material but only if it's approached in due time.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 58 guests