Indyjoe wrote:I don't think this is comparable to my recommending a little book to Fyre at all. I sure hope he didn't see it that way!
NO!!! I did not.
I may get around to checking it out. It's pretty cheap at Amazon.com however have you read the book reviews there? I'm not too impressed. Amazon's review doesn't stir me, either.
The people who like it generally state that it's a "good introduction to apologetics and for those seeking questions". Honestly, this doesn't grab me.
Claiming that Jesus truly existed requires more than circular reasoning - many reviews explain that Josh uses quotes from the Bible to prove the truth of what he's saying about it. Here's what I thought was a fiar review:
"Disappointing, Unconvincing, February 15, 2006
By Truth-Seeker (Daytona Beach, FL USA) - See all my reviews
McDowell fails to mention (I can only assume that it's intentional) that the gospels can only serve as hearsay accounts. The traditionally accepted authorship of the gospels is not historically sound by any means. All four gospels were anonymously written. Even if we do accept the traditional authorship of the earliest written gospel (Mark), on which other gospels obviously relied heavily for their information, we still do not have a first-hand account--only the account of a disciple of Peter.
McDowell also omits the embarrassing fact that despite Jesus' alleged fame, there is not one single writing from the actual lifetime of Jesus that mentions him. No writer that was alive during the lifetime of Jesus ever mentions him. In fact, the earliest writings that mention him are the biblical epistles of Paul, who never met an earthly Jesus. It's easy to make a case more convincing than McDowell's that perhaps Jesus, and even the city of Nazareth, never even existed.
Philo Judaeus (20 B.C.E. - 50 C.E) never mentions Jesus.
Seneca (4? B.C.E. - 65 C.E.) never mentions Jesus.
Pliny the Elder (23? - 79 C.E.) never mentions Jesus.
Nobody does.
This just scratches the surface, but please don't take my word for it. I urge any reader interested in a critical examination of Christianity to read this book (there are over 10,000,000 copies in print--one of your friends probably has a copy), but actually research its claims. It contains some of the best Christian apologetics arguments that exist. It shouldn't be easily refuted, right? I think you'll find otherwise.
I give the book two stars: one for its brevity, and another for helping me find some truth (although not contained in its pages)."