The_Noble_Cause wrote:Gideon wrote:
Honestly, man, I don't think that's what happened.
I think there's a prerecorded keyboard overlay for the intro to TWWUTB, like there is with the live intro to Ask the Lonely. If you watch any recording of Jon playing the intro to ATL, he's on the Fazio baby grand piano and there are prerecorded synths that overlay his piano keys.
Journey's had a bad habit of prerecorded synths for years: Only the Young's rhythm guitar riff, Wildest Dreams chorus, Never Walk Away's chorus, Suzanne, I'll Be Alright Without You, Send Her My Love, etc.
So why even quickly run up to his rig? Why bother? The intro only involves 2 keys tops and it looks like he's playing them to me.
During OTY, (before there was Travis or Jason), he just openly played rhythm guitar as the pre-recorded synth played in the background. If he didn't have to pantomime then, why start now?
I think for the same reason they run up to their mics even though most of the background vox are prerecorded; it's part of the presentation.
I brought up OTY as merely an example of a prerecorded synth loop overlay that drives me nuts. A more analogous example to what happened with TWWUTB would be the intro to Send Her My Love or Ask the Lonely. If you watch them play SHML or ATL live, a prerecorded synth loops plays over Jon's piano for the intro.