Matthew wrote:Perry's vocals on ROR are undeniably awesome. In fact, it's possibly the greatest vocal performance ever...by any artist.
I'm sure many Journey fans did go "WTF". And what's wrong with that? The band took a risk...the sound of the band had evolved...they didn't want to churn out the same old album. Let's hope Journey try to emulate some of that adventurous spirit now that JSS is in the band...a spirit that has been almost entirely absent for twenty years.
By the way...that sax solo on "Positive Touch" is a timeless classic.
I agree that Perry did a phenomenal job on Eyes of a Woman, Happy to Give, I'll Be All Right Without You and Why Can't This Night Go on Forever, but Girl Can't Help It and Positive Touch and definitely not my favorites. Suzanne is just okay. It Could Have Been You is not a bad tune either.
Happy to Give is probably one of my Perry favorites, with Eyes of a Woman coming in a close second. These are just incredible songs.
The interesting thing about ROR (and for the record, I have an actual ROR album framed on my wall), it's an eclectic mix of music and yes, I think it leaves the average Journey fan scratching their head because they're not sure what to make of it. It kind of reminds me of the one song Baby I'm a Leavin' You on TBF. When I first heard it, I thought "What is THAT?" It just didn't seem to fit the overall tone of the CD.
But opinions, such as they are, are up for grabs anyway.
