Is there a boot of the Bill Graham tribute ?

[yulog]

mine worked fine thanks Sallie

[Clasicrockldy]

You're very welcome, yulog !

[Liquid_Drummer]

Damn ask and you shall receive. ! You guys rule !!!

[maverick218]

Here it is. Faithfully & Lights.

http://download.yousendit.com/ADDE3AF504919C61

Am I correct in that was the last time that Neal, Jonathan, and Steve played together live? Thanks for the links btw.

[*Laura]

Here it is. Faithfully & Lights.

http://download.yousendit.com/ADDE3AF504919C61

Am I correct in that was the last time that Neal, Jonathan, and Steve played together live? Thanks for the links btw.

Yes,last time on the stage.

[KCfla]

Wonderful!
Thank you!!!!!

[Clasicrockldy]

Damn ask and you shall receive. ! You guys rule !!!

You're welcome everyone !

[zino]

Couldn't get the "web Help" to come up after I clicked on it no video
can anybody help?

[junky]

Couldn't get the "web Help" to come up after I clicked on it no video
can anybody help?

here's the link for the plugin you need:

http://www.divxmovies.com/codec/

[junky]

Ok, here is the link for the Bill Graham tribute. The video will have both "Lights" and "Faithfully" .

http://download.yousendit.com/DBAFB2FE2421E2CD


Enjoy !

Thanks, you always come through. I had the audio, but not the video.

[zino]

Ok, here is the link for the Bill Graham tribute. The video will have both "Lights" and "Faithfully" .

http://download.yousendit.com/DBAFB2FE2421E2CD


Enjoy !

Thanks, you always come through. I had the audio, but not the video.

Thanks a bunch

[Clasicrockldy]

Couldn't get the "web Help" to come up after I clicked on it no video
can anybody help?

here's the link for the plugin you need:



Thanks jrnyjunky ! That is the same plug in that I used so I could see the video !

[larryfromnextdoor]

Couldn't get the "web Help" to come up after I clicked on it no video
can anybody help?

here's the link for the plugin you need:

http://www.divxmovies.com/codec/

thanks JJ i couldnt that that codec link to save my neck!!! you saved me frustration!

[larryfromnextdoor]

thanks tons sallee and shania (laura) HA,,, sallee this one might be worth a new tattoo on me!! , well on you,, but , checks in the mail.......

[Clasicrockldy]

Ok, here is the link for the Bill Graham tribute. The video will have both "Lights" and "Faithfully" .

http://download.yousendit.com/DBAFB2FE2421E2CD


Enjoy !

Thanks, you always come through. I had the audio, but not the video.

You're welcome jrnyjunky !

[Enigma869]

Did anyone else notice that Perry seemingly forgot the second verse to Faitfully??? Instead of singing "Through space and time, always another show" in the second verse, he sang "Sending all my love along the wire" for a second time. Was this intentional? In any event, I still think Perry sounded great, even though that was in its rawest form! Perry was magic. I've always been amazed at the people who tell me the frontman is only one small part of the band. If that's the case, I would say the existing incarnation of Journey is as much Bad English as it is Journey, as there are three members from each band!

John from Boston

[Monker]

I find it absolutely amazing that people listen to this and think the band and Perry sound good. Compare this to Lights/Stay Awhile from 1982, and the Bill Graham tribute sounds like crap, Perry sounds like crap...and, yeah, he did forget the words to "Faithfully".

The band sounds OK at best...this is Journey at their lowest point prior to TBF...and it shows to anybody who has an unbiased ear.

[larryfromnextdoor]

I find it absolutely amazing that people listen to this and think the band and Perry sound good. Compare this to Lights/Stay Awhile from 1982, and the Bill Graham tribute sounds like crap, Perry sounds like crap...and, yeah, he did forget the words to "Faithfully".

The band sounds OK at best...this is Journey at their lowest point prior to TBF...and it shows to anybody who has an unbiased ear.

hey monker, i really would like to know, -- what u like, where u stand on the band,, your thoughts all wrapped up in 3 or 4 sentences,, the posts go back and forth so much , im lost to where you really are..i cant figure out if you love them , hate them ,, what year u hate/love them.,.believe tapegate,.........this clip was the last time we will see them so i really dug it,,,.......... your thoughts.................sincerly
ps- go to the booze thread , vote larry

[A Fire Inside]

Monker has always opposed yet approved of the band, it seems to me.

[Clasicrockldy]

Monker has always opposed yet approved of the band, it seems to me.

Fire,
Do you mean Monker does flip flops about the band?

[A Fire Inside]

How has he flip-flopped? He thinks they're past their peak as a band now and he thinks the Graham tribute was a terrible performance. Where is the relation?

[Clasicrockldy]

Fire, sorry, I misinterpreted what you said. My bad.

[Enigma869]

I find it absolutely amazing that people listen to this and think the band and Perry sound good. Compare this to Lights/Stay Awhile from 1982, and the Bill Graham tribute sounds like crap, Perry sounds like crap...and, yeah, he did forget the words to "Faithfully".

The band sounds OK at best...this is Journey at their lowest point prior to TBF...and it shows to anybody who has an unbiased ear.

I guess it's all open to interpretation. I'm a huge Perry fan, so anything he sings is going to sound better to me than someone else singing HIS music! I'm not someone who ever disliked Steve Augeri or his voice. I think Jeff also has a great voice. That said, Perry is Perry! Also, I think longtime Journey fans simply find something magical about Perry, Schon, and Cain being on any stage together...even if it is in its rawest form! Forgetting the words to their signature song is the only thing I found even remotely disturbing about this performance.

John from Boston

[ddregs]

I repeat myself once again: tuning down make songs lose emotion, power, original intentions. Songs are like pieces of art.
Perry sounds great even when he's not trained, but this time is not up to Journey standards.
Cheers

[geminix]

The only thing I found disturbing about it was the fact that Steve was up there almost begging the crowd to sing along and they simply weren't doing it. Other than that, I thought they were great. Thanks for posting the vids!

[ddregs]

Excerpt from Herbie Herbert interview on another great rock site, classicrockrevisited.com
(http://www.classicrockrevisited.com/Int ... bert06.htm)
“Do you remember when Bill Graham died and the band came back together and performed in Golden Gate Park?” Jon and Neal were there and when Perry showed up he said “Herbie, what songs are we going to play?” I said, “I don’t know, maybe ‘Lights’ or ‘Don’t Stop Believin.’” I rattled off three or four choices and he says, “You get the lyrics together because I certainly don’t remember the words. You write them down and tell Jon and Neal to take them down two steps.” That means if you’re in the key of ‘E’ you have to go down to ‘A.’

Taking a song down two whole steps is a monumental thing. It really demonstrated how good Jon and Neal are as musicians, that they were able to pull it off without any practice or rehearsal. With over half a million people in the park, surely people tape-recorded that performance and you can hear that it’s two whole steps down. Even then Perry could not hold his pitch and sing in tune; his voice was really rough. If he could, he would be Journey. He went out and did that solo tour to do Journey but he couldn’t. He kept postponing shows and ultimately he had to cancel the thing. He doesn’t have the health and he can’t sing anymore. He lost his talent. Think Karma. "

This speaks volumes....

[zino]

Was finally able too view this.. Perry sounded OK a few things though as mentioned before the crowd just didn't seem into it at all, Perr was begging them too sing. Could Neal stood further away from Perry you could almost see the tension between them. I wonder why since this was a tribute to Billy why no Ross, or Rollie or Smith. They could of delt with each other for two songs. But anyway thanks for the link it was finally good too see after all those years.

[Chakra]

Excerpt from Herbie Herbert interview on another great rock site, classicrockrevisited.com
(http://www.classicrockrevisited.com/Int ... bert06.htm)
“Do you remember when Bill Graham died and the band came back together and performed in Golden Gate Park?” Jon and Neal were there and when Perry showed up he said “Herbie, what songs are we going to play?” I said, “I don’t know, maybe ‘Lights’ or ‘Don’t Stop Believin.’” I rattled off three or four choices and he says, “You get the lyrics together because I certainly don’t remember the words. You write them down and tell Jon and Neal to take them down two steps.” That means if you’re in the key of ‘E’ you have to go down to ‘A.’

Taking a song down two whole steps is a monumental thing. It really demonstrated how good Jon and Neal are as musicians, that they were able to pull it off without any practice or rehearsal. With over half a million people in the park, surely people tape-recorded that performance and you can hear that it’s two whole steps down. Even then Perry could not hold his pitch and sing in tune; his voice was really rough. If he could, he would be Journey. He went out and did that solo tour to do Journey but he couldn’t. He kept postponing shows and ultimately he had to cancel the thing. He doesn’t have the health and he can’t sing anymore. He lost his talent. Think Karma. "

This speaks volumes....

About what? Words from Herbie should be taken with a gallon shaker of salt. He has never had a postive thing to say about any of the guys, except Rollie.
His ego proceeds him. He just comes off like a bitter man. All this speculation about Perry's voice is JUST that. The rumors and innuendo never stop. He gave the fans numerous first rate performances. Leave the guy in peace. If he decides to perform again, then judge from real facts, not someone else's slanted agenda.

[Matthew]

.... He doesn’t have the health and he can’t sing anymore. He lost his talent. Think Karma. "

This speaks volumes....

About what? Words from Herbie should be taken with a gallon shaker of salt. He has never had a postive thing to say about any of the guys, except Rollie.
His ego proceeds him. He just comes off like a bitter man. All this speculation about Perry's voice is JUST that. The rumors and innuendo never stop. He gave the fans numerous first rate performances. Leave the guy in peace. If he decides to perform again, then judge from real facts, not someone else's slanted agenda.

Well said...

[Deb]

Excerpt from Herbie Herbert interview on another great rock site, classicrockrevisited.com
(http://www.classicrockrevisited.com/Int ... bert06.htm)
“Do you remember when Bill Graham died and the band came back together and performed in Golden Gate Park?” Jon and Neal were there and when Perry showed up he said “Herbie, what songs are we going to play?” I said, “I don’t know, maybe ‘Lights’ or ‘Don’t Stop Believin.’” I rattled off three or four choices and he says, “You get the lyrics together because I certainly don’t remember the words. You write them down and tell Jon and Neal to take them down two steps.” That means if you’re in the key of ‘E’ you have to go down to ‘A.’

Taking a song down two whole steps is a monumental thing. It really demonstrated how good Jon and Neal are as musicians, that they were able to pull it off without any practice or rehearsal. With over half a million people in the park, surely people tape-recorded that performance and you can hear that it’s two whole steps down. Even then Perry could not hold his pitch and sing in tune; his voice was really rough. If he could, he would be Journey. He went out and did that solo tour to do Journey but he couldn’t. He kept postponing shows and ultimately he had to cancel the thing. He doesn’t have the health and he can’t sing anymore. He lost his talent. Think Karma. "

This speaks volumes....

About what? Words from Herbie should be taken with a gallon shaker of salt. He has never had a postive thing to say about any of the guys, except Rollie.
His ego proceeds him. He just comes off like a bitter man. All this speculation about Perry's voice is JUST that. The rumors and innuendo never stop. He gave the fans numerous first rate performances. Leave the guy in peace. If he decides to perform again, then judge from real facts, not someone else's slanted agenda.

Exactly, I'm more leaning to go with what Joe Benson said, somebody who has actually heard him sing in the last year or so.