Andrew wrote:Saint John wrote:I'm pretty sure that Shirley did both the new album and the re-records.
That is my understanding also.
Hmm... different opinions... I had to go back and do some digging to see what I could find, and here's what I have -- first, this from a previous post from me in early April...
Rip Rokken wrote:annie89509 wrote:We'll have to listen to the whole song(s) to see if the band actually made any changes to the original riffs/vocals.
The blurb I heard, and it may have been from Caveman's diary, was that they'd been busy trying to make the songs sound as close to the originals as possible, so I've been expecting updated production, but not many (if any at all) changes to the riffs or instrument tones. I guess we'll see.
On closer recollection, I don't think this was from Caveman's diary, but was a blurb from another well-known musician who was working in a studio down the hall from Journey while they worked on these. He made the mention of them trying to get them as close to the originals as possible. Wish I could find it again... so maybe they worked on them in Cain's basement for a while, but I never had the impression the official re-records were done there. These sound much, much better than
Red13 or
Generations production-wise.
Next, here are all the Journey references I could find in Kevin Shirley's diary... he doesn't specifically mention working on the rerecords, but alludes to them a time or two:
___________________________________
WednesdayNovember14th2007Malibu, CA
Had to check my watch... Gosh, is it still 1980? * Finished a wonderful, succesful, stupidly creative stint in the Bay Area and then drove back home last night, feeling chuffed as only those rare, monster sessions leave you. Sometimes you just know when there's history in the making.
January1st2008Malibu, CA
I have been recording many new amazing Journey tracks in San Francisco, and am now mixing in Las Vegas, and still have a very busy schedule ahead.
FridayJanuary18th2008Malibu, CA
Also, been working on the Journey project, but there's little to say about it, that doesn't get someone somewhere upset, so I rather say nothing. It won't be finished for awhile yet, although my part is nearly done and it is really great, and right now I really can't wait to get home to my wife and kids.
February10th2008Malibu, CA
Journey have been preparing for an upcoming tour and I have been talking to band and management about all manner of things - from fees to mastering to songs, mixes, running orders.....
March3rd2008Malibu, CA
Off to New York City tomorrow - mastering Journey and a few meetings - then off to Vegas Friday to see Journey play Planet Hollywood Saturday night. Should be quite a show.............
March12th2008Malibu, CA
Flew into New York Tuesday night (March 4th) for a mastering session with mastering legend George Marino, who did a fabulous job with the new Journey album. It sounds fabulous - rich and lush and hi-fi - everything (and more) than you'd expect from Journey. I am seriously proud of this and really look forward to people hearing it. Journey do have some of the more psychotic and rabid internet fans, and it's not always fun dealing with them - but they know what they like, and I am expecting them to be very happily surprised! This guy has a set of pipes..... and the whole band is playing fantastically!
I've recorded Journey live at Planet Hollywood in Vegas on Saturday night, as part of their super-dooper package that's coming out. The show was great, and I will mix it next week, in stereo and surround, for the DVD that's part of their special Walmart package. It's called Revelation, and yes, I really do think it is fantastic! Journey fans have always been the toughest internet people - actually, back in the day I stopped all Journey chat because they get pretty heated and vitriolic - and it's already started again...... after one U.S. date and only 3 new songs played, there is every kind of criticism being hurled around, from the music relying too much on "the Legacy sound" (I thought you wanted that), to the music being too "rocky" (I thought you wanted that too), to the negative Perry comparisons (well, he ain't coming back) and JSS (I have never heard him), to the release being on Walmart (who along with Starbucks, are the biggest music retailers in the U.S. now), to my positive comments made during the recording - what do you want people? What exactly is it you would like? Actually, don't answer please - why not wait 'til you've heard it.......... enough of that madness already...... OY!
March22nd2008Malibu, CA
Busy, busy, busy.... it's been quite a couple of weeks. Holed up mixing some live Journey stuff in preparation for their jumbo June 3rd release. REVELATION. Anyone interested knows by now, that it's a collection of 2 CD's and 1 DVD, but what has me the most excited about it, is the new album with eleven original tracks. Ballads, rockers, progressive pieces - even a gorgeous instrumental to close - and I think the fans, both old and new, will love hearing what I think is the best album from Journey since Escape. (I know press releases have hinted at these things before, but I wouldn't say it if i didn't believe it). Schon and Cain's playing and writing is tuned into some higher source on this one.... well, you'll see soon enough.
FridayMarch28th2008Malibu, CA
Finishing the Journey DVD audio mixes - I hope those of you interested have surround sound, 'cos that's really the way to hear it - I mean there is a stereo track, of course, but surround is where it lives as a concert!
April20th2008Malibu, CA
Last week, I finished up stereo mixes of Maiden from all over the world; also updated Joe's live album by putting in a little more crowd (I had preffered it cleaner, but it sounds great this way as well), and worked on the live Journey DVD for it's June 3 release.
April26th2008Malibu, CA
Had to stick my head in and lend a hand with the edit of the Journey live DVD, as they were having an issue or two...
One thing I've not mentioned on the board before -- right before Vegas, I think Kevin himself was posting here as a new user. We PM'ed back and forth a few times when I originally thought he was Jonathan Cain, and he did mention being a "Bay Area Producer", but denied being a band member. His posts had specifically to do with talking up the re-records, going into a lot of detail about how amazing they would sound with certain aspects of modern production, and once I asked him if he was Kevin Shirley, he cut off our communications.