Gunbot wrote:Who are you people?
We're the people going 'round and 'round to different places... or possibly the people that you want to know...
Moderator: Andrew
Gunbot wrote:Who are you people?
Jeremey wrote:finalfight wrote:Jeremey wrote:Jeremey wrote:Deb wrote:Jeremey wrote:I thought it was a brilliant fuckin album. I waited and waited by the radio in my studio apartment as they were supposed to be debuting "You Better Wait," and I had read on AOL that some ham and egger had heard the song and it had an a capella beginning and was 100% Perry all the way. So when those first vocal harmonies came in I was floored. I waited and bought the CD and played it every second of every day. I looked at Perry as an elder who seemed weary by his worldly experience, and I felt if I just absorbed those melodies and messages I could somehow learn from osmosis what he meant in the whole cosmos of things.
Understand I had NEVER heard a new Journey or Perry CD when this record came out. I had LIVED on Journey's releases since Time 3, and it seemed as though finally the world was right. When I heard "Anyway," I was convinced that a new legacy was about to be reborn, and I remember listening to those SPIN messages from Jon Cain's studio as they wrote the new record, and how excited I was. When the single "When You Love A Woman" came out, I bought it at Walmart while on my way to a sales call and listened in the parking lot, and I actually had tears in my eyes during the song because I felt that things had actually fallen into place.
How young, naive, and misinformed I must have been at the time. Regardless. FTLOSM is a classic record that grooves too darkly and too deeply to be written off as a musical one-off, and I know that Perry tried in his way to make things right with Sony and the band, but he really just found himself jumping on that roller coaster one more time.....The Eagles made it look so clean and easy. When the real world settled down on his shoulders it was really a totally different story.
One of my faves too, have you ever performed that one?
Only at my house, with LarryNext Door laying down the geetar tracks. No such recording exists anymore.
Perry songs attemtpted by Frontiers:
Foolish Heart
Oh Sherrie
Strung Out
Then there was a song with an odd bridge from FTLSOM....Young Hearts Forever, covered while I was in the band Altura.
Oh and I did Missing You by myself, and I want Frontiers to cover "One More Time" from YBW+5 that I lost and have no copy of to learn from.
You also recorded some amazing vocals for a version of 'You Better Wait'...
FF. you are absolutele right. It was YOU BETTER WAIT
Since 78 wrote:madsplash wrote:Saint John wrote:It was a vocally solid, but boring, album. The music is what makes the album shit. The magic of Journey simply wasn't there and record sales and radio play showed that.
As opposed to what, the record sales and radio play of Arrival?
It's all relative.
Has nothing to do with sales or airplay, just good versus bad songs. I listen to FTLOSM maybe once a year and the songs I like, I have have on my play list. Arrival, I play all the time. Just a superior album.
Bingo.wednesday's child wrote:I think Dan wasn't talking about quality relative to sort-of concurrent releases by others,
but rather, relative to what Journey (with Perry) once put out --
Loneman1 wrote:Yup, I've always thought that album was pretty solid. I'm still not sure whether or not I like the changes made to the intro of "You Better Wait" from the original release versus the '06 remaster. The fade in is cool and all, but part of me still digs the original's power.
Jeremey wrote:Jeremey wrote:Deb wrote:Jeremey wrote:I thought it was a brilliant fuckin album. I waited and waited by the radio in my studio apartment as they were supposed to be debuting "You Better Wait," and I had read on AOL that some ham and egger had heard the song and it had an a capella beginning and was 100% Perry all the way. So when those first vocal harmonies came in I was floored. I waited and bought the CD and played it every second of every day. I looked at Perry as an elder who seemed weary by his worldly experience, and I felt if I just absorbed those melodies and messages I could somehow learn from osmosis what he meant in the whole cosmos of things.
Understand I had NEVER heard a new Journey or Perry CD when this record came out. I had LIVED on Journey's releases since Time 3, and it seemed as though finally the world was right. When I heard "Anyway," I was convinced that a new legacy was about to be reborn, and I remember listening to those SPIN messages from Jon Cain's studio as they wrote the new record, and how excited I was. When the single "When You Love A Woman" came out, I bought it at Walmart while on my way to a sales call and listened in the parking lot, and I actually had tears in my eyes during the song because I felt that things had actually fallen into place.
How young, naive, and misinformed I must have been at the time. Regardless. FTLOSM is a classic record that grooves too darkly and too deeply to be written off as a musical one-off, and I know that Perry tried in his way to make things right with Sony and the band, but he really just found himself jumping on that roller coaster one more time.....The Eagles made it look so clean and easy. When the real world settled down on his shoulders it was really a totally different story.
One of my faves too, have you ever performed that one?
Only at my house, with LarryNext Door laying down the geetar tracks. No such recording exists anymore.
Perry songs attemtpted by Frontiers:
Foolish Heart
Oh Sherrie
Strung Out
Then there was a song with an odd bridge from FTLSOM....Young Hearts Forever, covered while I was in the band Altura.
Oh and I did Missing You by myself, and I want Frontiers to cover "One More Time" from YBW+5 that I lost and have no copy of to learn from.
madsplash wrote:Saint John wrote:It was a vocally solid, but boring, album. The music is what makes the album shit. The magic of Journey simply wasn't there and record sales and radio play showed that.
As opposed to what, the record sales and radio play of Arrival?
It's all relative.
brywool wrote:Radio play and sales ranks do NOT indicate what's good. Otherwise "Oh Mickey" would be ranked right up there with Pink Floyd's "The Wall". I hate when people equate sales to quality. It's RARELY the case. Was "Babe" the best Styx song because it was number 1 and the others weren't? Nt by a freakin mile. It was actually one of their worst tunes.
brywool wrote: I prefer the sound of it to Street Talk but I think the writing on Street Talk was better, though I think "Foolish Heart" blows. Boring, loungy tune. Blech. Hated it from the moment I first heard it and couldn't believe that it was a Perry tune. That album could've used more songs like "Strung Out".
You're completely misconstruing what I've said in the past. It's no surprise that timeless efforts like Escape and Frontiers moved a shitload of copies...they're simply that good. It's also no wonder that FTLOSM didn't sell shit...it wasn't worth a fuck. And for the record, my "stats" argument was to dowse your flaming panties regarding everything Soto. Furthermore, it was to suppress your amazement that the guy has never had radio play or a hit...despite having monstrous exposure opportunities several times. That speaks for itself.Deb wrote:Shhhh, Saint John might here ya. You don't want him marching in here with his stats arguments.
Saint John wrote:You're completely misconstruing what I've said in the past. It's no surprise that timeless efforts like Escape and Frontiers moved a shitload of copies...they're simply that good. It's also no wonder that FTLOSM didn't sell shit...it wasn't worth a fuck. And for the record, my "stats" argument was to dowse your flaming panties regarding everything Soto. Furthermore, it was to suppress your amazement that the guy has never had radio play or a hit...despite having monstrous exposure opportunities several times. That speaks for itself.Deb wrote:Shhhh, Saint John might here ya. You don't want him marching in here with his stats arguments.
Saint John wrote:You're completely misconstruing what I've said in the past. It's no surprise that timeless efforts like Escape and Frontiers moved a shitload of copies...they're simply that good. It's also no wonder that FTLOSM didn't sell shit...it wasn't worth a fuck. And for the record, my "stats" argument was to dowse your flaming panties regarding everything Soto. Furthermore, it was to suppress your amazement that the guy has never had radio play or a hit...despite having monstrous exposure opportunities several times. That speaks for itself.Deb wrote:Shhhh, Saint John might here ya. You don't want him marching in here with his stats arguments.
Onestepper wrote:Saint John wrote:You're completely misconstruing what I've said in the past. It's no surprise that timeless efforts like Escape and Frontiers moved a shitload of copies...they're simply that good. It's also no wonder that FTLOSM didn't sell shit...it wasn't worth a fuck. And for the record, my "stats" argument was to dowse your flaming panties regarding everything Soto. Furthermore, it was to suppress your amazement that the guy has never had radio play or a hit...despite having monstrous exposure opportunities several times. That speaks for itself.Deb wrote:Shhhh, Saint John might here ya. You don't want him marching in here with his stats arguments.
And here we go.....
I saw JSS the other night by the way. He was great. Sorry, no pics.
Onestepper wrote:And here we go.....
I saw JSS the other night by the way. He was great. Sorry, no pics.
Deb wrote:Onestepper wrote:And here we go.....
I saw JSS the other night by the way. He was great. Sorry, no pics.
Great show isn't it. Good to see ya survived the inlaws.
Onestepper wrote:Deb wrote:Onestepper wrote:And here we go.....
I saw JSS the other night by the way. He was great. Sorry, no pics.
Great show isn't it. Good to see ya survived the inlaws.
Yep, it's the holiday season alright![]()
I've seen him now with J and TSO, so I'd like to see a solo show at some point.
Deb wrote:Saint John wrote:You're completely misconstruing what I've said in the past. It's no surprise that timeless efforts like Escape and Frontiers moved a shitload of copies...they're simply that good. It's also no wonder that FTLOSM didn't sell shit...it wasn't worth a fuck. And for the record, my "stats" argument was to dowse your flaming panties regarding everything Soto. Furthermore, it was to suppress your amazement that the guy has never had radio play or a hit...despite having monstrous exposure opportunities several times. That speaks for itself.Deb wrote:Shhhh, Saint John might here ya. You don't want him marching in here with his stats arguments.
Then answer me this then oh wise one. To take something from Bry's post, why did "Oh Mickey" sell millions? Was it simply that good?!
-1![]()
Not misconstruing anything, your argument has all kinds of holes in it.There are lots of VERY talented singers nowhere near as popular as they should be and there are alot of NO talent singers way more popular than they should be.
Gunbot wrote:What defines good? If I can do work around the house bebopping to Britney or Kajagoogoo Hasn't the music fulfilled its purpose. If your daughter is doing her homework with the headphones on and singing along to Nsync, then the music is doing what it's supposed to, be an entertainment or relaxation tool. Everybody uses Britney as an example of a talentless hack but people buy her music and they continue to listen to it even after a few weeks. The girl still has to go out there, exercise learn the dance routines, tour and perform. I'm pretty sure that stuff isn't as easy as it looks. if there is an audience for what she's selling then she should get what she can out of it and adapt when the trends change. Bon Jovi, U2 and some other acts didn't roll over when Grunge came in, the changed the way they did business and matched up a new sound to what was going on in the market. The acts that suffered are the ones that couldn't get out of the 80's and believed their stuff was so good that people would eventually see the light and come back to them. Well that didn't happen and that's why these acts are playing the local ribfest because they didn't have the skill or the motivation to adapt their product. I really don't feel for sorry for any of them, and I don't begrudge the new acts for selling what we may think is crap. Remember we weren't to enthralled with what our parents were listening to either and they felt the same about a lot of our music. Doesn't mean any of it was bad, just that we can't feel what the other generation feels.
Deb wrote:Gunbot wrote:What defines good? If I can do work around the house bebopping to Britney or Kajagoogoo Hasn't the music fulfilled its purpose. If your daughter is doing her homework with the headphones on and singing along to Nsync, then the music is doing what it's supposed to, be an entertainment or relaxation tool. Everybody uses Britney as an example of a talentless hack but people buy her music and they continue to listen to it even after a few weeks. The girl still has to go out there, exercise learn the dance routines, tour and perform. I'm pretty sure that stuff isn't as easy as it looks. if there is an audience for what she's selling then she should get what she can out of it and adapt when the trends change. Bon Jovi, U2 and some other acts didn't roll over when Grunge came in, the changed the way they did business and matched up a new sound to what was going on in the market. The acts that suffered are the ones that couldn't get out of the 80's and believed their stuff was so good that people would eventually see the light and come back to them. Well that didn't happen and that's why these acts are playing the local ribfest because they didn't have the skill or the motivation to adapt their product. I really don't feel for sorry for any of them, and I don't begrudge the new acts for selling what we may think is crap. Remember we weren't to enthralled with what our parents were listening to either and they felt the same about a lot of our music. Doesn't mean any of it was bad, just that we can't feel what the other generation feels.
Gbot, of course everybody's definition of good is different, but I was mainly talking talent, specifically vocal talent. Britney is mainly for show IMO, where as somebody like Christina Aguilera majorly has the pipes to back it up.
Deb wrote:Gunbot wrote:What defines good? If I can do work around the house bebopping to Britney or Kajagoogoo Hasn't the music fulfilled its purpose. If your daughter is doing her homework with the headphones on and singing along to Nsync, then the music is doing what it's supposed to, be an entertainment or relaxation tool. Everybody uses Britney as an example of a talentless hack but people buy her music and they continue to listen to it even after a few weeks. The girl still has to go out there, exercise learn the dance routines, tour and perform. I'm pretty sure that stuff isn't as easy as it looks. if there is an audience for what she's selling then she should get what she can out of it and adapt when the trends change. Bon Jovi, U2 and some other acts didn't roll over when Grunge came in, the changed the way they did business and matched up a new sound to what was going on in the market. The acts that suffered are the ones that couldn't get out of the 80's and believed their stuff was so good that people would eventually see the light and come back to them. Well that didn't happen and that's why these acts are playing the local ribfest because they didn't have the skill or the motivation to adapt their product. I really don't feel for sorry for any of them, and I don't begrudge the new acts for selling what we may think is crap. Remember we weren't to enthralled with what our parents were listening to either and they felt the same about a lot of our music. Doesn't mean any of it was bad, just that we can't feel what the other generation feels.
Gbot, of course everybody's definition of good is different, but I was mainly talking talent, specifically vocal talent. Britney is mainly for show IMO, where as somebody like Christina Aguilera majorly has the pipes to back it up.
Saint John wrote:You're completely misconstruing what I've said in the past. It's no surprise that timeless efforts like Escape and Frontiers moved a shitload of copies...they're simply that good. It's also no wonder that FTLOSM didn't sell shit...it wasn't worth a fuck. And for the record, my "stats" argument was to dowse your flaming panties regarding everything Soto. Furthermore, it was to suppress your amazement that the guy has never had radio play or a hit...despite having monstrous exposure opportunities several times. That speaks for itself.Deb wrote:Shhhh, Saint John might here ya. You don't want him marching in here with his stats arguments.
Deb wrote:Saint John wrote:You're completely misconstruing what I've said in the past. It's no surprise that timeless efforts like Escape and Frontiers moved a shitload of copies...they're simply that good. It's also no wonder that FTLOSM didn't sell shit...it wasn't worth a fuck. And for the record, my "stats" argument was to dowse your flaming panties regarding everything Soto. Furthermore, it was to suppress your amazement that the guy has never had radio play or a hit...despite having monstrous exposure opportunities several times. That speaks for itself.Deb wrote:Shhhh, Saint John might here ya. You don't want him marching in here with his stats arguments.
Then answer me this then oh wise one. To take something from Bry's post, why did "Oh Mickey" sell millions? Was it simply that good?!
-1![]()
Not misconstruing anything, your argument has all kinds of holes in it.There are lots of VERY talented singers nowhere near as popular as they should be and there are alot of NO talent singers way more popular than they should be.
Masses of people seemed to like it...me not being one of them. My point is that at some time after over 20 years, many genres and several monstrous exposure opportunities, and no hits or radio play, one must deduce that said artist is just an average professional singer. Which in itself is quite an accolade. The problem is that you wanna take Chris Chelios' stats and put him in the same breath as Wayne Gretzky and Mario Lemieux. I just come along every now and then to point out how ridiculous that is.Deb wrote:Then answer me this then oh wise one. To take something from Bry's post, why did "Oh Mickey" sell millions? Was it simply that good?!
escapefan wrote:Bottom line, we are all entitled to our opinion on the subject. I love it. SJ doesn't. So why argue about it. I know what I like, same as SJ knows what he likes.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 32 guests