Greg wrote:
I know you're very passionate about this band and its accomplishments in the last few years, but it's pretty much common knowledge that Revelation sold because of A) price of what was offered
Agreed. It was great package that was promoted like crazy.
Greg wrote:and B) the greatest hits CD.
Then explain why it outsold Journey's GH Live? The hits on GH Live are far more authentic renditions, yet it didn't sell all that well.
Greg wrote:The cool thing about that is, the casual fan is probably not going to know that the GH cd doesn't have Steve Perry singing on it. They may not even pay attention to the fact that the those songs have been re-recorded.
This is simply not true and is just the excuse du jour. I remember when it was announced that the re-records were going to be on there, and how everyone here said that the Journey fan base would completely alienate this idea, and that this would make the band the laughing stock of music. Then, when that didn't work, it was "OMG ... the Pinoys are all buying 75 copies each!!!" Listen, these guys were on Oprah, Ellen, in GQ, on the Sunday Morning show, and the story was told over and over how the disc "contained 12 new tracks and 12 re-recorded hits," so I'm going to believe that that, coupled with it saying that RIGHT ON THE PACKAGE was enough to give the consumer a clue exactly who was singing those songs.
Greg wrote:Even more casual fans may not know the difference between re-recorded, re-mastered, or remixed. And sometimes, there isn't really THAT much of a difference. So, if I'm a casual fan of Journey, and I know the dirty dozen but outside of that, I don't know anything else, I'm going to casually look at new music in Walmart and see that Journey has this big package of two discs and one DVD for $10. I see that it has songs on it that I am familiar with, so I purchase it. What the heck? I might give this disc of new stuff a spin, but I bought it mainly to hear the hits. I guarantee you that was the marketing strategy for Revelation. Couple it with the story of Pineda and the use of DSB, and bam...success!
I might go along with this if Journey was a rap group and catered to a demographic that's generally about as smart as a fucking carburetor, but their fans and the like are able to read, and virtually nobody doles out $11.88 without checking out the fine print.
Greg wrote:Also, consider this: I bet part of the reason, even probably a small part of the reason why the true Greatest Hits album is selling so well, is the fact that those who bought Revelation for that hits CD, went back to buy the true GH, because they wanted the originals and were disappointed that the new "package" didn't have exactly what they had hoped for.
Journey's GH has been selling like gangbusters for over 20 years. Prior to Revelation, if you combine the sales of GH, GH Live and The Essential Journey, you get sales in the area of 15 million. I'm guessing that most people that wanted GH already had it. New sales are coming in from the Glee crowd and the like. Not disenfranchised Revelation owners.