Liquid_Drummer wrote:Yep, it is killing his voice. He is singing from the back of his throat almost through out this video. He is walking a tightrope and lets not forget this is 1/2 step lower key than the original. Most males can NOT sing this stuff in their 40's. He has the best coaches and doctors money can buy. None of that matters as aging and genetics play out their hand. He has had a good run and most bands never get a 2nd wind like Journey. I like Arnel but I never understood why they didnt find a tenor in their late to mid 20's. They had him and Jeremey to choose from . Both great sings and both too old. Jeremey paid the price singing that material and he wasnt playing near as much as the real band...
They need to call it day and stop using singers like disposable lighters.
I don't agree at all. It's not "killing his voice". Man, so many here jump to conclusions like this each day. It's crazy. There's no rasp like with Perry in 83 (and after) or Augeri in his last year. Arnel's voice and chords sound fine. There's no gravel in it at all. It's smooth.
What IS WEIRD is that he's changed his whole approach to vowels. If you watch the Chile thing (his first gig), there was a much more "natural" approach to the vowels. They sounded more like speaking. In this clip, he's really darkened his vowels and closed them off in a big way. I noticed it a lot with the Rascal Flatts deal too. He sang the Rascal Flatts stuff SO WELL. When the Journey stuff happened in that show, he sang with these really REALLY darkened vowels. COMPLETELY different than the approach to the RF songs. There's gotta be a reason he's doing that. This Budokan video is one of the first times I've heard him have pitch issues (he also had them in Stone in Love in Chile), but usually, his pitch is great. Another thing, notice how in AWYWI, the mic is off partway through? Makes me wonder if Journey's sound guy is screwing him. We keep hearing reports of how bad the sound is, etc. Jeez, if it sucks in the FOH, gotta wonder what the monitor mixes are.
Also, check out some of the other videos like of Arnel and Neal at the radio station in Japan. Arnel sings AWYWI with no effort at all. Granted, it's not the big high notes, but if his voice was fu**ed, he'd be cracking all over the place.
He's fine, he's just altering his approach for some reason.
One thing about Arnel, he really does have a lot of health issues. I would imagine that if you're flying all over the world, not getting great sleep, etc., that you'll be much more susceptible to virus' and stuff. I'm not worried about him at all. Think back to the horrendous Augeri clips that you heard years ago. Arnel is nowhere near that.