JourneyRox wrote: Cain channel Rolie? Not in a million lifetimes. But frigging Augeri sounds like crapola. Cain sounds much much much better than him? WTF was Augeri doing? I used to have an ounce of pity for him. Now I wanna crucify the fucker for ruining this song & hurting my ears. He shoulda stepped his ass down right there, right then. Fucker is croaky, straining the hell out of his always thin lousy-assed voice, flatter than a pancake, unable to hit any note & sounding like a squeakie toy for cats. This is disgraceful. I'm hopping mad. Oh fuck it gets worse. Anytime. Shuddupayaface Augeri. What the fuck is that caterwauling of "Anytime"? Damn I'm glad he did shut up. How how how could this band not have fired him for sounding this way? They had the BEST. Ok I gotta get off this soapbox. Holy shit Butterfly. A shitty song to begin w/& he croaks the fuck out of it. He SUXXXXXXX. Is it any wonder the crowd boos them? Fuck I'm booing sitting here at home. I think I'll turn off this crap boot. Unless it's Deen. He's the ONLY saving grace.
Deano, we owe u more than we realize. Way more. Thank u for breaking this & making this band get rid of this lousy wailing flat voiced screeching fool.
I think Cain's voice is pretty friggin' close to Rolie's on those songs actually.
As for what Augeri was doing, well "the show must go on" and he did the best he could. I'd rather hear this boot than the first ones with JSS any day of the week. Thank GOD he got rest and sounds pretty good now. Augeri was definitely having problems, Duh. Tell us something that hasn't been talked about every day for the last year. Doesn't mean he sucks and is shit and is a fool. Means he was having voice issues. Singers have had them forever. Perry had them and he dropped out -seemingly forever. Augeri had them and he dropped out. Steven Tyler had them. Elton John had them. Friggin' Dolly Parton had them. Julie Friggin' Poppins Andrews had them and now has no voice. It's not that rare as far as singers go. Shit happens. And he's gone. You're happy now. Gees. Let it go.
You can't bring up anything here because somebody's gonna get all shitty on yer ass.
"Listen to Open Arms" from the same show-Flawless by the way. I have yet to hear the current singer do that at all. "Lights" also was great. Granted, those songs were the best that day and the rest are pretty damned bad (I agree with that), but you seem to take it like it hurts you personally.
In the immortal words of John Lennon "It's only a rock band."
The crowd booed because they said they were playing new stuff. Not because of his performance or Butterfly.
By the way, the first time they booed was when Augeri said that they were gonna play some new stuff. This was after "Stone in Love" and they quit booing as soon as he said it was for the troops. They went into "Harms Way" . When Neal said "new stuff" before "Self Defense", they booed again. "Butterfly" was still a few songs off. When he said "new stuff" again before "Butterfly", people booed again. After they played "Butterfly", I didn't hear booing. When he was introduced, I didn't hear booing. It was ONLY when the band talked about playing "new" songs. Neal mentioned the same thing in interviews (and on stage) that nobody wanted to hear new stuff. They hadn't even HEARD the songs yet, but they weren't even willing to in the least. Maybe it was because they spent the first hour listening to the obscure stuff from the pre-Perry albums with dopey lyrics about volcanoes, etc...?
I remember when I saw Lou Gramm with Journey. He was definitely having vocal problems. The crowd was brutal. It was after the show I heard that he was recovering from some brain tumor or something. I felt bad for the guy. I feel bad for Augeri too.
Regarding the post about if someone sucks, say so.
First of all, it's not necessary, but just because a singer is having problems doesn't mean that they once weren't great and that the suckiness blows their previous contributions away. When I first heard JSS with Journey. I thought he sucked with a capital S. But I'm still giving him a chance because I hear improvement every time I hear him. I think he'll be fine. With Augeri, I heard him for years where he was great. Now, he's not. Doesn't mean he's shit. Same goes for Perry.
I was just flabbergasted that the band's audience could be so rude to them at a show. Checking out some of the posters on this board, I can see that it's pretty common.