Moderator: Andrew
Arkansas wrote:"You just heard what of his voice Kevin Elson wanted you to hear."
So if...
1. NS and the band didn't know about it, then they should equally blame Kevin Elson for collusion.
2. NS and the band did know about it, but not to what extent, then they should equally blame Kevin Elson for collusion.
3. NS and the band were fully aware of it, then they're all in the $hitter for collusion, and SA can't be a lone scape goat.
4. Nobody knew anything but Augeri, and he held a loaded weapon to KE's head, forcing him to do it...night after night.
5. Anything about this were true, and the band blames Augeri for whatever amount. And, Augeri has lawyers wrangling for more cash (hush money), and is disgusted with the band. Then how did Augeri get any access to them at a show and why did JSS speak so highly of him? Is JSS being 'duped' by <whoever> also?
How many times is the band's mgt going to miserably handle their singer situation? Seems to reason the band's mgt should be first to get sacked and the entire organization overhauled.
Something smells in Stinkville...
later~
Citygirl wrote:And just for the record, a good friend of mine was at Manchester and never mentioned any problem with Faithfully either.
TVL wrote:I was not an Augeri fan and only saw him sing once with Journey in the very beginning, but I thought he had a good voice. It is disappointing to see how bad the man has been condemned on this board. Come on people, he's only human, not a singing robot! He started having trouble with his voice....so what??!! I'm sure all singer's have had their rough time's, especially when touring over a long period of time. Should they have kept going with taped assistance? Maybe not, but many have done it. Maybe the reason's were not all selfish, maybe the band was just giving it time to try to work through the problem. Maybe they were trying to keep going not just for themselve's but for their staff's and crew and familie's who rely on them. Are you all perfect people? Don't think so! Augeri is fallible just like the rest of us. The guy gave you what, 8 year's? No respect for that? Don't know the politic's of the band or who is going to sing in the future or if they will even continue after this tour. All I know is I would like to thank all member's of the band, past and present, for creating and sharing the music I've enjoyed for so long.![]()
TVL wrote:I was not an Augeri fan and only saw him sing once with Journey in the very beginning, but I thought he had a good voice. It is disappointing to see how bad the man has been condemned on this board. Come on people, he's only human, not a singing robot! He started having trouble with his voice....so what??!! I'm sure all singer's have had their rough time's, especially when touring over a long period of time. Should they have kept going with taped assistance? Maybe not, but many have done it. Maybe the reason's were not all selfish, maybe the band was just giving it time to try to work through the problem. Maybe they were trying to keep going not just for themselve's but for their staff's and crew and familie's who rely on them. Are you all perfect people? Don't think so! Augeri is fallible just like the rest of us. The guy gave you what, 8 year's? No respect for that? Don't know the politic's of the band or who is going to sing in the future or if they will even continue after this tour. All I know is I would like to thank all member's of the band, past and present, for creating and sharing the music I've enjoyed for so long.![]()
Abitaman wrote:TVL wrote:I was not an Augeri fan and only saw him sing once with Journey in the very beginning, but I thought he had a good voice. It is disappointing to see how bad the man has been condemned on this board. Come on people, he's only human, not a singing robot! He started having trouble with his voice....so what??!! I'm sure all singer's have had their rough time's, especially when touring over a long period of time. Should they have kept going with taped assistance? Maybe not, but many have done it. Maybe the reason's were not all selfish, maybe the band was just giving it time to try to work through the problem. Maybe they were trying to keep going not just for themselve's but for their staff's and crew and familie's who rely on them. Are you all perfect people? Don't think so! Augeri is fallible just like the rest of us. The guy gave you what, 8 year's? No respect for that? Don't know the politic's of the band or who is going to sing in the future or if they will even continue after this tour. All I know is I would like to thank all member's of the band, past and present, for creating and sharing the music I've enjoyed for so long.![]()
I fell the same way, maybe more so. I believe something was a foot, but not as bad as it is made out to be. I would go see him perform with Journey or solo. Most people do forget, he is human, and having to sing in the inhuman parts of the perrygod. If we was a politician, no one would think twice of this. But he is a musician, and can only do so much.
Was it wrong, yes, even if a little was used. But everyone does it now a days, it is common place. Does anyone else get their balls busted over it? NO. Why did Augeri get his balls busted on it? I hold Augeri as much to blame as anyone else in the band. I hold the band to blame as much as Augeri. But I will see Journey again, and see Augeri again.
I have made mistakes, glad my wife, family, friends, job, I'm Glad they all forgave me, or I would be one lonely person. If for some reason this is not true and did not happen, then we all have blamed an person who is not to blame. He may not be to blame if it did happen. We are just wanting to take someone down, and Say "look at what I did", and I want no part of that.-ERIC
TVL wrote:Come on people, he's only human, not a singing robot!
Augeri is fallible just like the rest of us. The guy gave you what, 8 year's? No respect for that?
EightyRock wrote:
I predict Perry will tour before you get the skinny on tapegate in Andrew's (or anyone elses) interview.
Abitaman wrote:But everyone does it now a days, it is common place.
Abitaman wrote:Does anyone else get their balls busted over it? NO. Why did Augeri get his balls busted on it?
JourneyRox wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:Journey isn't the one gunking up the works.
It's a soon-to-be ex-member that is strangulating the boys coffers and nickel and diming them to death!
Steve Augeri- u are a crookedy nosed guido punk.
Get over urself and give Jeff the same chance the boys generously gave u back in 1998.
Oh come on. It's not him. It's the lawyers. Once they get involved everything takes forever. Try getting divorced w/lawyers involved. Yuck.
rap_still_sucks wrote:Jesus, when will Journey get over their paranoid communist mentality about communication??? No news about a sick lead singer in four months, now Andrew can't release interviews this week as promised (surprise)! I love the hell out of Journey music, but I have to say on a personal level they begin to disgust the hell out of me. Get over yourselves Journey! Quit being a bunch of paronoid control freaks, and quit hiding so much! Do you think it will even matter? Just be honest!
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Why do u think?
Because, unlike other classic rock bands, Steve was using it for WHOLE tours.
It stopped being enhancement and crossed into outright fraud.
What he truly sang was absolutely negligible.
A minute or so here, a minute or so there.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Abitaman wrote:But everyone does it now a days, it is common place.
If I was JSS I'd take offense to this comment.Abitaman wrote:Does anyone else get their balls busted over it? NO. Why did Augeri get his balls busted on it?
Why do u think?
Because, unlike other classic rock bands, Steve was using it for WHOLE tours.
It stopped being enhancement and crossed into outright fraud.
What he truly sang was absolutely negligible.
A minute or so here, a minute or so there.
Abitaman wrote:I still don't think it was quite that bad as some here say.
But I think the reason Augeri got his balls busted had less to do with the lipping, than with the fact he wasn't Perry, IMO-ERIC
Abitaman wrote:
I still don't think it was quite that bad as some here say. ....
But I think the reason Augeri got his balls busted had less to do with the lipping, than with the fact he wasn't Perry, IMO-ERIC
pdsidd wrote:Point me to a video that has no crowd noise where there should be crowd noise or whatever and I'm a believer but when push comes to shove you believe your own eyes and ears and I was in Edinburgh and if Steve was miming he was absolute perfection at it because I couldn't tell he was doing it.
"Didn't shell out to see a fellow human"???? That is absolutely the most idiotic statement I have ever read on this board! Congratulation's!....... I wasn't following the band in 05' so I'm not going to argue with you point by point.....see Monker for that! ha! Wasn't a fan of Augeri. I was just saying that it's not fair to put a guy on trial without knowing all the fact's. He IS human after all! I guess your perfect, right?? You take this whole thing WAY too seriously!The_Noble_Cause wrote:TVL wrote:Come on people, he's only human, not a singing robot!
Thing is, people didn't shell out big bucks to go see a fellow human.
We can all look at each other in the crowd to see that.
We paid to hear him sing and he did practically none of that.
The only song sang 100% live in '05 was Loving;Touching; Squeezing.Augeri is fallible just like the rest of us. The guy gave you what, 8 year's? No respect for that?
Why should there be?
The last two practically negated all the good merits of the first 6.
If it wasn't for the valiant efforts of a fan and his blog, Augeri would've kept on faking it.
He transmogrified the band into what Neal Schon despises the most; "a pro-tools band".
TVL wrote:Didn't shell out to see a fellow human"???? That is absolutely the most idiotic statement I have ever read on this board! Congratulation's!.......
I wasn't following the band in 05' so I'm not going to argue with you point by point
I was just saying that it's not fair to put a guy on trial without knowing all the fact's.
He IS human after all! I guess your perfect, right??
You take this whole thing WAY too seriously!
Uh dude, just like with Augeri you don't know all your fact's. You make assumption's. I did pay to see the band when Augeri was singing, just not in 05'! Try gathering all the fact's when you put someone on trial. Now go find Monker to argue with. I don't have any more time for this and it lead's no where. You are to rigid and set in your opinion's and will not change them no matter what someone else has to say. We dis-agree, but it doesn't make my opinion's any less valid than your's. Have a great night!The_Noble_Cause wrote:TVL wrote:Didn't shell out to see a fellow human"???? That is absolutely the most idiotic statement I have ever read on this board! Congratulation's!.......
Maybe I bumbled the phrasing, but the point remains the same.
We pay to go see talent put on display.
Any of us lowley shmoes can fake it.I wasn't following the band in 05' so I'm not going to argue with you point by point
So in other words, u didn't personally drop any bread to go see Augeri.
No wonder u are so nonchalant about it.I was just saying that it's not fair to put a guy on trial without knowing all the fact's.
What possibly could justify such an act?
Try to think up a possible scenario.
I'll wait.He IS human after all! I guess your perfect, right??
Last I checked I'm not stealing anyone's money under false pretenses.You take this whole thing WAY too seriously!
And years after his death, u prove P.T. Barnum's most infamous maxim to be true.
pdsidd wrote:It's garbage to suggest that Steve Augeri was miming for a year - three rows back during the UK tour I can say categorically he was not miming. Bulls**t.
The guy deserve whatever he gets if they're hanging him out to dry - he's twice the singer JSS is and Journey will be the worse for him not being there.
I'm not an Augeri fan per se, I liked Perry as well but JSS is not good enough and from what I've heard cannot hit the notes like Augeri or Perry did. JRNY need to raise the bar.
As great a frontman that JSS is, he's not enough of a singer in my opinion.
TVL wrote:Uh dude, just like with Augeri you don't know all your fact's. You make assumption's. I did pay to see the band when Augeri was singing, just not in 05'! Try gathering all the fact's when you put someone on trial.
You are to rigid and set in your opinion's and will not change them no matter what someone else has to say.
We dis-agree, but it doesn't make my opinion's any less valid than your's.
Mark H wrote:I saw 4 of the Euro shows, all from within the first 5 rows and agree, no way was Steve miming, although maybe things went 'ze shape of ze pair' at the start of the US tour. Don't know.... wasn't there.
I did see the so called incriminating boots of the Manchester show and the boot simply does not show what happened on the night, at least from my 5th row position. Maybe it was doctored, maybe it was just a function of the equipment it was recorded on..don't know..it just wasn't the sight or sound from my position in the hall.
You seem hungry and want to be fed.......so here you go....Steve Perry was the best rock singer ever!!...........argument?The_Noble_Cause wrote:TVL wrote:Uh dude, just like with Augeri you don't know all your fact's. You make assumption's. I did pay to see the band when Augeri was singing, just not in 05'! Try gathering all the fact's when you put someone on trial.
Augeri lip-synched.
This has been confirmed by various industry insiders, sources close to the band, and people within the band themselves.
There is no room for anymore debate.
If you defend paying to go see a Journey show in 2005, then u are nothing more than a willful sucker who likes being raped.You are to rigid and set in your opinion's and will not change them no matter what someone else has to say.
You've said nothing except "Augeri is human".
How is that a justification for fraud?We dis-agree, but it doesn't make my opinion's any less valid than your's.
Sure it does.
My opinion is based on knowledge, urs is based on feelings.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 47 guests