Moderator: Andrew
Lora wrote:Jeremey wrote:in the end it will always be about the music. If they go with a guy who knows the songs inside and out, and has conditioned his voice by singing the material every weekend for 5 years for 3 hours at a time, to most I would think would be a good thing, but then again, there'll always be a fickle minority in any population.
For me, it is not just about the music. It is about whether or not the singer/musician reaches me. Moves me. Makes me feel. When I listen to Steve Perry's voice, it literally alters my brain chemestry and takes me to that place. I can listen to someone else sing the very same song, the very same notes and.....nothing. Journey seems to want to play to people who don't know or care who is singing as long as they get close to the original sound. They will probably do just fine. But don't catagorize those who aren't going along for the ride as "fickle." I know my own heart and will follow it as you must follow yours.
ohsherrie wrote:Lora wrote:Jeremey wrote:in the end it will always be about the music. If they go with a guy who knows the songs inside and out, and has conditioned his voice by singing the material every weekend for 5 years for 3 hours at a time, to most I would think would be a good thing, but then again, there'll always be a fickle minority in any population.
For me, it is not just about the music. It is about whether or not the singer/musician reaches me. Moves me. Makes me feel. When I listen to Steve Perry's voice, it literally alters my brain chemestry and takes me to that place. I can listen to someone else sing the very same song, the very same notes and.....nothing. Journey seems to want to play to people who don't know or care who is singing as long as they get close to the original sound. They will probably do just fine. But don't catagorize those who aren't going along for the ride as "fickle." I know my own heart and will follow it as you must follow yours.
I understand exactly what you're saying Lora. Some of us have been labeled as Perryheads and then later Perryloons for trying to make people understand why just hitting the notes or singing in the same range wasn't enough.
The band obviously intends to continue though with someone singing those songs. I took what Jeremey said to mean that whoever sings for them shouldn't be labelled and judged according to where they came from or what they were doing when they were chosen, but according to how well they do with the band. I thought he as saying the "fickle" ones were the ones that were using his gig as a tribute singer as an excuse to not like him or an insult to him the way some used Augeri's job at Gap.
I threw the job at the turkey farm in there because some of us 'heads or 'loons used to get that thrown in our face as an insult to Perry the way some of those very people are now using the tribute band label as an insult to Jeremey.
froy wrote:
The wrong tempo and the backing vocals stink
Slow the damm song down
No way this guy sings for JRNY
The survivor dude kicks his ass,
Tyra-J wrote:I'm with froy here. The Survivor guy is totally amazing... WOW! Thanks to treetopovskaya for pointing it out.
I'm not too crazy about Jeremey's voice. First listen to this...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fgVQQnImaQ
and then to Jeremey...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pX0HvUndENQ
And everyone with ears must hear what Jeremey lacks! Backings suck too!
Tyra-J wrote:I'm with froy here. The Survivor guy is totally amazing... WOW! Thanks to treetopovskaya for pointing it out.
I'm not too crazy about Jeremey's voice. First listen to this...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fgVQQnImaQ
and then to Jeremey...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pX0HvUndENQ
And everyone with ears must hear what Jeremey lacks! Backings suck too!
MCC620 wrote:Yes you do have a huge hand in deciding your fate. And you better use your head as much, if not more than, your heart.
Stay and post Jeremey, but just like Lora and I pointed out comments you made, so will others.
Red13JoePa wrote:MCC620 wrote:Yes you do have a huge hand in deciding your fate. And you better use your head as much, if not more than, your heart.
Stay and post Jeremey, but just like Lora and I pointed out comments you made, so will others.
Aw GodPLEASE don't do this SAME petty thing with Jeremey that you did with JSS.
It's becoming a pattern and Hunsicker has been PLENTY complimentary of Augeri and JSS and obviously we know how he feels about pery.
NealIsGod wrote:Tyra-J wrote:I'm with froy here. The Survivor guy is totally amazing... WOW! Thanks to treetopovskaya for pointing it out.
I'm not too crazy about Jeremey's voice. First listen to this...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fgVQQnImaQ
and then to Jeremey...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pX0HvUndENQ
And everyone with ears must hear what Jeremey lacks! Backings suck too!
I would kill to be able to sing like either one.
JR (Susie) wrote:NealIsGod wrote:Tyra-J wrote:I'm with froy here. The Survivor guy is totally amazing... WOW! Thanks to treetopovskaya for pointing it out.
I'm not too crazy about Jeremey's voice. First listen to this...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fgVQQnImaQ
and then to Jeremey...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pX0HvUndENQ
And everyone with ears must hear what Jeremey lacks! Backings suck too!
I would kill to be able to sing like either one.
That makes 2 of us.
NealIsGod wrote:JR (Susie) wrote:[I agree w/Joe AGAIN today (OMG what happened).]
You better be careful or we may vote you Homecoming King & Queen.
MCC620 wrote:
I'll say the same thing to you I said to JSS last year...........let your abilities speak for you. Posting on here is just going to push those who aren't behind having you as lead singer further away.
JR (Susie) wrote:Please dont drive this good man off this forum. I dont think he'll yell back at u like Jeff did. He's got too much personal crap going on so he'll just stay away. Maybe that will make u happy. If so, that is really not cool. So please, just as u ask him to stop & think about what he posts & its impact, stop & think about what ur posting.
ohsherrie wrote:JR (Susie) wrote:Please dont drive this good man off this forum. I dont think he'll yell back at u like Jeff did. He's got too much personal crap going on so he'll just stay away. Maybe that will make u happy. If so, that is really not cool. So please, just as u ask him to stop & think about what he posts & its impact, stop & think about what ur posting.
She's actually hoping to push Jeremey into losing his cool so she can get on her soap box about how her sweet, humble Augeri would never have done so.
NealIsGod wrote:Yeah, but you would kill JoePa.
JR (Susie) wrote:NealIsGod wrote:Yeah, but you would kill JoePa.
Nah. I might need him for some trollslaying. He's pretty good at that u know
ohsherrie wrote:She's actually hoping to push Jeremey into losing his cool so she can get on her soap box about how her sweet, humble Augeri would never have done so.
Socratic Methodist wrote:JR (Susie) wrote:NealIsGod wrote:Yeah, but you would kill JoePa.
Nah. I might need him for some trollslaying. He's pretty good at that u know
That's debatable......
Socratic Methodist wrote:JR (Susie) wrote:NealIsGod wrote:Yeah, but you would kill JoePa.
Nah. I might need him for some trollslaying. He's pretty good at that u know
That's debatable......
ohsherrie wrote:JR (Susie) wrote:Please dont drive this good man off this forum. I dont think he'll yell back at u like Jeff did. He's got too much personal crap going on so he'll just stay away. Maybe that will make u happy. If so, that is really not cool. So please, just as u ask him to stop & think about what he posts & its impact, stop & think about what ur posting.
She's actually hoping to push Jeremey into losing his cool so she can get on her soap box about how her sweet, humble Augeri would never have done so.
JR (Susie) wrote:Socratic Methodist wrote:JR (Susie) wrote:NealIsGod wrote:Yeah, but you would kill JoePa.
Nah. I might need him for some trollslaying. He's pretty good at that u know
That's debatable......
Aw fuck. I thought he slayed u
Socratic Methodist wrote:I'm looking back at last night's debacle thinking, 'what the fuck happened?'....
JR (Susie) wrote:Socratic Methodist wrote:I'm looking back at last night's debacle thinking, 'what the fuck happened?'....
Hopefully u were drinking & didnt realize what u were posting. Don't drink & post
MCC620 wrote:Umm no ohsherrie, no Bonnie and no Susie...........
just tired of how often the Gap comments have to be continued, yup defending Augeri. Just like every time someone says something about Perry ohsherrie is all over them, or when someone touches precious Neal, Bonnie is jumping in to defend.
And Susie I am so glad I could help you and Joe make up.
MCC620 wrote:just tired of how often the Gap comments have to be continued, yup defending Augeri.
Liam wrote:MCC620 wrote:Umm no ohsherrie, no Bonnie and no Susie...........
just tired of how often the Gap comments have to be continued, yup defending Augeri. Just like every time someone says something about Perry ohsherrie is all over them, or when someone touches precious Neal, Bonnie is jumping in to defend.
And Susie I am so glad I could help you and Joe make up.
HE WORKED AT THE FUCKIN' GAP...It's GONNA COME UP.
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 29 guests