Ranking and (Rating out of 10) for Generation so far

[Eric]

(1)It's Never Too Late (9)
(2)The Place In Your Heart (9)
(3)Out Of Harms Way (8)
(4)Faith In The Heartland (7)
(5)Butterfly (6)
(6)A Better Life (6)
(7)Beyond the Clouds (6)
(8)Better Together (5)
(9)Believe (5)
(10)Knowing That You Love Me (5)
(11)Self-Defense (4)
(12)Every Generation (2)
(13) Gone Crazy (2)

[jrnyman28]

That makes an average of 5.7 for "Generations"
Are you sure about those ratings?

[Red13JoePa]

Yea, his panning of EG, and GC drag the aggregate way down.
I'd give EG at least like a 7.5, I really like that #. Could've still used an Augeri touch on the high bridge at then end but a real good tune all in all.

Still really digging In Self Defense, too.

[jrnyman28]

(1)It's Never Too Late (9)
(2)The Place In Your Heart (9)
(3)Out Of Harms Way (9)
(4)Faith In The Heartland (
(5)Butterfly (7)
(6)A Better Life (
(7)Beyond the Clouds (
(8)Better Together (7)
(9)Believe (6)
(10)Knowing That You Love Me (
(11)Self-Defense (7)
(12)Every Generation (
(13) Gone Crazy (7)

That makes my average: 7.8

Funny how, when I rank the CD as a whole I gave it a much higher grade than 78%....

[Guest]

I wish I could hear the entire CD instead of those clips. I guess that means I *have* to go to the show, regardless of whether I don't have the moolah. I want this CD.

My first impressions based on the two clips I heard was that the guitars were fabulous, as usual, and the drumming was tight. I wasn't too keen on the vocals. But I am going to give them a chance. I just wish he didn't sound like the ghost of Perry for me! I am sure he is a great singer in his own right, but the Perry similarities are too eerie for me. I can't get past them.

The best song on Arrival, I thought, was Higher Place. I wasn't keen on the ballads at all. There are a couple of good bluesy rock songs too. Can't remember their names right now, and don't have the CD handy.

[jrnyman28]

I wish I could hear the entire CD instead of those clips. I guess that means I *have* to go to the show, regardless of whether I don't have the moolah. I want this CD.

You could buy it through www.frontiers.it and NEH Records. it is the European release with a bonus track.

I wasn't too keen on the vocals. But I am going to give them a chance. I just wish he didn't sound like the ghost of Perry for me! I am sure he is a great singer in his own right, but the Perry similarities are too eerie for me. I can't get past them.

Have you ever listened to Hugo or Kevin Chalfant of The Storm and Two Fires? There are several people with similar voices to Perry's.

The best song on Arrival, I thought, was Higher Place.

And the vocals did not interfere on that one? Hopefully they won't on the new stuff either then.

I wasn't keen on the ballads at all. There are a couple of good bluesy rock songs too. Can't remember their names right now, and don't have the CD handy.

I agree completely!!

[Eric]

Yeah - I'm sure about those ratings - so far - based on CLIPS. Deano did send me a copy of the CD, but the Post Office keeps your mail for 10 days after you move and provide a forwarding date, so all my mail is backed-up somewhere....

The 5.7 is just an average of those songs, I would probably give the album a 7 so far based on everything. And on a 1-100 scale like Andrew does, where I'd give 96's, 97's, etc. instead of 9's - it would be in the high 70's or low 80's...based on the clips. Gone Crazy, Every Generation and the re-tread Self Defense just aren't good tunes for me and it hurts the overall average.

To compare, I'll do Arrival (which have changed over time):

1) Higher Place - 10
2) I Got a Reason - 9
3) Living To Do - 9
4) Nothin Comes Close - 8
5) Signs of Life - 8
6) Kiss me Softly - 8
7) We'll meet Again - 7
World Gone Wild - 7
9) To Be Alive Again - 7
10) I'm Not that Way - 6
11) Live and Breathe - 6
12) With Your Love - 5
13) Lifetime of Dreams - 5
14) All the Things - 5
15) Loved by You - 2
16) All the Way - 2