Saint John wrote:that without him and Herbie guiding the band that it would only be a matter of time before the wheels came off the cart. I really think that's what he meant when he said "Don't crack the stone." He realized that they had a chemistry that could never be equalled. I wish Neal would've realized that too. The stone has been cracked and may not be repairable. They would've accomplished just as much WITHOUT Augeri as they would've WITHOUT Perry over the last 8 years. Nothing. They've actually taken a couple of steps backwards into the domain of of "another band who should've hung it up long ago." Perry realized that, without him, they were doomed. Azoff saw $$$$$ and didn't give two shits about their legacy. He figured keep touring, rake in $$$ and watch the catalog sales continue to flourish. That dude needs to be fired ASAP.
Well, to some degree it's also what Dennis DeYoung has been saying about Styx - don't run the name into the ground. I don't think Perry necessarily thought without him and Herbie the wheels would come off the cart, because he got rid of Herbie and the rest of the guys were happy to jump on board since their cash cow said "let's go make an album". It's not about chemistry. As Suite said, rock bands are a business. Do you truly and deeply believe that these guys are the bestest buddies ever? Come on. Now, unlike Styx, the credits for songwriting are not just slanted towards one or two writers. So they all get money from radio play, CD sales, mechanical licenses, etc. Now, Ross, for example, would be the person (arguably) of the original Journey lineup who would benefit the most from touring since he didn't write much of the material.
Azoff has a history of being, shall we say, not the nicest guy. Shrewd business guy, and he is also part of the Styx story, too. Bands don't hire him for his looks.
Whatever the outcome, most of the bands we like - Journey and Styx - will never, ever get to where they were in the late 70s through the mid-80s. If more people realized this, life would be that much easier. Until then, you'll have camps of this side vs. that side, and people delusional thinking that <insert name of band here> can still chart a #1 hit.
Get over it. It's 2006.