by fred_journeyman » Sun Jul 16, 2006 3:28 am
This is a funny thread. I for one, would not be interested in seeing Journey with Perry as frontman. THAT would be pathetic. I mean, Steve WAS one of rock's premiere singers in his day. Now? He's in his fifties, hasn't sung a note professionally for years (the humming he did on a few releases over the years doesn't count) and he has shown absolutely no interest in singing publically. To go to a concert where songs would be sung two full steps below their original key by a lead vocalist whose chops are nowhere near what they used to be is not exciting at all. THAT would be embarrassing and pathetic. It's obvious that Steve Perry has a good deal more sense than that, to even want to attempt it.
I remember shortly before Elvis died, he came to the town I lived in, in New York state. I talked with one of the women I worked with who saw him and asked if the concert was good. Her comment? Elvis was better than ever! Right. This is the guy who would lay down on stage, forget the words to songs, had pretty much lost his high range and sounded more like a warbler than the Elvis that we all once knew. I'm glad she enjoyed the concert though, but "better than ever"? Not even close.
If Perry came back to Journey, which I cannot imagine at all, that would signal the end of Journey for me. If it DID happen, it would seem as though they WERE only doing it for the money. Now, it simply seems as though they prefer to keep Journey's music alive.
I have to absolutely disagree that the current state of Journey is "pathetic." Far from it. They are consumate professionals and I think Soto's inclusion in the band gives it that much more of a musical edge.
Embarrassed by Journey? If they're are embarrassing, then stop listening to them and just put on the music when Steve Perry fronted. I mean, it's not as if you hold stock in Journey's corporation and the risk is that your stock is going to bottom out.
I'm not interested in a Journey with Perry and it would seem that neither is Steve Perry.
By the way, there used to be a Steve Perry forum on Andrew's space here. What happened to it?
- Fred
