
http://www.cliquerecords.com/sounds/stoneinlove.mp3
http://www.cliquerecords.com/sounds/faithfully.mp3
Nothing against Journey's choice back then,but hearing this made me think that Kevin would have been much better for the band after Perry left.
Moderator: Andrew
Shania wrote:
Nothing against Journey's choice back then,but hearing this made me think that Kevin would have been much better for the band after Perry left.
bladezuk wrote:Shania wrote:
Nothing against Journey's choice back then,but hearing this made me think that Kevin would have been much better for the band after Perry left.
I was always led to believe Chalfant got the job, but as soon as he got it, Perry said he wanted back in the band so they went with him instead, so this has nothing to do with the Augeri recruitment, as it would have taken place just before the TBF album. I could be wrong but have seen this topic discussed a few times here.
Matthew wrote:They could have hired him again after TBF though. I doubt Chalfant would have said no.
ohsherrie wrote:I don't see why he did this anymore than I could understand why Journey wanted to rerecord them. Why would anyone want to buy a CD of someone else doing these songs when they can still get the originals? Makes no sense to me.
Shania wrote:Thanks to Wavid for sending me these.![]()
http://www.cliquerecords.com/sounds/stoneinlove.mp3
http://www.cliquerecords.com/sounds/faithfully.mp3
Nothing against Journey's choice back then,but hearing this made me think that Kevin would have been much better for the band after Perry left.
ohsherrie wrote:I don't see why he did this anymore than I could understand why Journey wanted to rerecord them. Why would anyone want to buy a CD of someone else doing these songs when they can still get the originals? Makes no sense to me.
AR wrote:ohsherrie wrote:I don't see why he did this anymore than I could understand why Journey wanted to rerecord them. Why would anyone want to buy a CD of someone else doing these songs when they can still get the originals? Makes no sense to me.
Why not?
Haven't you ever gone to see a local cover band play other people's songs?
Maybe he just enjoys singing these and knew that others would like to hear him do them?
As a career move, I bet it gets more notice than Two Fires or Shooting Star.
Why did Friga re-record Faithfully?
ohsherrie wrote:AR wrote:ohsherrie wrote:I don't see why he did this anymore than I could understand why Journey wanted to rerecord them. Why would anyone want to buy a CD of someone else doing these songs when they can still get the originals? Makes no sense to me.
Why not?
Haven't you ever gone to see a local cover band play other people's songs?
Maybe he just enjoys singing these and knew that others would like to hear him do them?
As a career move, I bet it gets more notice than Two Fires or Shooting Star.
Why did Friga re-record Faithfully?
Sure, I'll go see Jeremey every chance I get and I love listening to his live CDs, but Frontiers is a Journey tribute band. If I were to buy a CD to hear Journey music though, and had a choice between the original and another singer trying his best to sound like the original I'd sure take the original.
I didn't like Jon redoing Faithfully either.
AR wrote:Why did Friga re-record Faithfully?
AR wrote:ohsherrie wrote:AR wrote:ohsherrie wrote:I don't see why he did this anymore than I could understand why Journey wanted to rerecord them. Why would anyone want to buy a CD of someone else doing these songs when they can still get the originals? Makes no sense to me.
Why not?
Haven't you ever gone to see a local cover band play other people's songs?
Maybe he just enjoys singing these and knew that others would like to hear him do them?
As a career move, I bet it gets more notice than Two Fires or Shooting Star.
Why did Friga re-record Faithfully?
Sure, I'll go see Jeremey every chance I get and I love listening to his live CDs, but Frontiers is a Journey tribute band. If I were to buy a CD to hear Journey music though, and had a choice between the original and another singer trying his best to sound like the original I'd sure take the original.
I didn't like Jon redoing Faithfully either.
And how would you feel if Perry went in and re-recorded the originals? Original artists sometimes re-record the originals.
I don't see anyone complaining when Jeff records stuff like Ozzy's Shot in the Dark or some Queen covers or whatever.
Face it, it is ok for people to go in and do their take on old Journey songs, just as it is ok for anyone who wants to record anyone else's stuff. Sometimes it is just cook to here something different. Of course nothing is ever better than the original, but the original tracks aren't going away just because someone else makes a new recording of a particular song.
AR wrote:And how would you feel if Perry went in and re-recorded the originals? Original artists sometimes re-record the originals.
ohsherrie wrote:What I don't like is someone(who doesn't appear to be doing it as a tribute) trying to out Perry Perry on songs that were written specifically for his voice and vocal style. It seems like a waste of time on one hand, and an "in your face" on the other. It just doesn't sit right with me, but that's just me, to each his own.
Shania wrote:Matthew wrote:They could have hired him again after TBF though. I doubt Chalfant would have said no.
That's exactly the moment I was referring to when I said Kevin would have been a better choice.
Thanks,Matthew.
NoMoreTails wrote:Shania wrote:Matthew wrote:They could have hired him again after TBF though. I doubt Chalfant would have said no.
That's exactly the moment I was referring to when I said Kevin would have been a better choice.
Thanks,Matthew.
They should have kept him in the band instead of bringing Perry back for TBF.
ohsherrie wrote:I don't see why he did this anymore than I could understand why Journey wanted to rerecord them. Why would anyone want to buy a CD of someone else doing these songs when they can still get the originals? Makes no sense to me.
ohsherrie wrote:cyndy! wrote:hard to tell with just 2 short clips, but i'm not really feeling this. sounds like he's being so careful with each word & each note, as if they matter more than the emotions behind them.
Like an impersonator?
AR wrote:Sounds to me like a bunch of loons are just offended that someone would DARE sing these songs and actually be good at it.
Fine, lets here Perry sing them NOW then. Thought so.
Fucking babies. If you don't like that Kevin is putting out the CD - don't buy it. How dare he!!!!
The original CD's are still there and remastered for you to listen to till the end of time. How this CD coming out could bother anyone is silly.
NealIsGod wrote:ohsherrie wrote:cyndy! wrote:hard to tell with just 2 short clips, but i'm not really feeling this. sounds like he's being so careful with each word & each note, as if they matter more than the emotions behind them.
Like an impersonator?
Did HOTS take over your screen name, Sher?
Matthew wrote:AR wrote:Sounds to me like a bunch of loons are just offended that someone would DARE sing these songs and actually be good at it.
Fine, lets here Perry sing them NOW then. Thought so.
Fucking babies. If you don't like that Kevin is putting out the CD - don't buy it. How dare he!!!!
The original CD's are still there and remastered for you to listen to till the end of time. How this CD coming out could bother anyone is silly.
Actually..I think most of us Loons don't really give a shit, AR.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 48 guests