MR

..that Brain May stated that SP "couldn't sing with Journey" anymore (or something to that affect).

Do you think he knows something we don't...like Perry's voice is really "shot"?

Interesting...

Journey...time to "call it a day".

Don't cheapen your legacy any more than you already have. If you don't regroup with SP then close down the shop boys!

some people may think it's because he can't sing anymore, and some may think that it just means that SP doesnt' want anything to do with the boys anymore (like me)

Brian was right on, with all of what he said btw.

Don't think he meant it that way.

I think Brian knows about as much as we do about the state of Perry's voice. The only one who really honestly knows is Perry....well maybe those he is supposedly writing music with.

cracked_stone wrote:I think Brian knows about as much as we do about the state of Perry's voice. The only one who really honestly knows is Perry....well maybe those he is supposedly writing music with.

Seriously, I think Brian may have heard things from people in the biz...

FormerJrnyFan wrote:

cracked_stone wrote:I think Brian knows about as much as we do about the state of Perry's voice. The only one who really honestly knows is Perry....well maybe those he is supposedly writing music with.

Seriously, I think Brian may have heard things from people in the biz...

That's what I was thinking as well...

I am not buying into it at all i bet you can still has it.It may not be like when he was younger but he still can rock with the best of them.

Tomulator wrote:..that Brain May stated that SP "couldn't sing with Journey" anymore (or something to that affect).

Do you think he knows something we don't...like Perry's voice is really "shot"?

That's not how I took that comment when I read it. As cracked stone stated, I'm sure Brian May has as much of a clue about Perry and his singing as anyone else. I interpreted it literally. He "can't sing with them" not meaning "he can't sing" but literally he can not because he is legally not part of the band, nevermind that he also doesn't want to. It can't and won't happen, that whole thing is over, thus, he can't sing with them.

Just my interpretation.