MR

Perry is NOT in the top 10 on this list finalized today!

Classic Vinyl’s Top 10 Greatest Classic Rock Singers
Wed 1/2 - Fri 1/11 10 am ET
Whose voices best define rock and roll? Find out as Classic Vinyl reveals the Ten Greatest... one per day starting January 2nd at 10 am ET. Check back each day after 10 am ET when this list will be updated.
1. Janis Joplin
2. Jim Morrison
3. Mick Jagger
4. Roger Daltrey
5. Paul McCartney
6. Robert Plant
7. David Bowie
8. Paul Rodgers
9. Elton John
10. Freddie Mercury

http://www.sirius.com/classicvinyl

Janis Joplin was not a classic rock singer!!!

Oh she was an excellent blues and r&b singer -

and Elton John is not that good of a singer at all - he is a great performer, and he and Bernie Taupin wrote some great songs - but Elty is not a great vocalist.

That is like saying that Burt Bacharach is a great singer.

The man sounds like a dying frog - even singing his own songs, which are some of the best ever written.



Cat

ph that is a fuycking ridiculous list"!! the onhly person i would ever put near Perry would be Mercyury and he is bloody 10tyh!! fukin stupid if u asdk me!!!! im sick of the bloody stupid polls spouting bullshit. we like what we like. . no, we LOVE what we love, fuck stupid polls.

praise the lord!

Uno_up wrote:Perry is NOT in the top 10 on this list finalized today!

Classic Vinyl’s Top 10 Greatest Classic Rock Singers
Wed 1/2 - Fri 1/11 10 am ET
Whose voices best define rock and roll? Find out as Classic Vinyl reveals the Ten Greatest... one per day starting January 2nd at 10 am ET. Check back each day after 10 am ET when this list will be updated.
1. Janis Joplin
2. Jim Morrison
3. Mick Jagger
4. Roger Daltrey
5. Paul McCartney
6. Robert Plant
7. David Bowie
8. Paul Rodgers
9. Elton John
10. Freddie Mercury

http://www.sirius.com/classicvinyl

There are no words to describe just how badly that list SUCKS! For starters, Janis Joplin was horrible and simply couldn't sing! How the hell they rank her first boggles the mind! I wouldn't have her ranked in the top 500! As for Mick Jagger...He can't sing either! Kudos to the Rolling Stones for being around as long as they've been around. I simply don't believe there is anything even remotely interesting about Jagger's voice! He is a below average singer, to my ears! I'd rank Mercury ahead of everyone on that list!


John from Boston

Enigma869 wrote:

Uno_up wrote:Perry is NOT in the top 10 on this list finalized today!

Classic Vinyl’s Top 10 Greatest Classic Rock Singers
Wed 1/2 - Fri 1/11 10 am ET
Whose voices best define rock and roll? Find out as Classic Vinyl reveals the Ten Greatest... one per day starting January 2nd at 10 am ET. Check back each day after 10 am ET when this list will be updated.
1. Janis Joplin
2. Jim Morrison
3. Mick Jagger
4. Roger Daltrey
5. Paul McCartney
6. Robert Plant
7. David Bowie
8. Paul Rodgers
9. Elton John
10. Freddie Mercury

http://www.sirius.com/classicvinyl

There are no words to describe just how badly that list SUCKS! For starters, Janis Joplin was horrible and simply couldn't sing! How the hell the rank her first boggles the mind! I wouldn't have her ranked in the top 500! As for Mick Jagger...He can't sing either! Kudos to the Rolling Stones for being around as long as they've been around. I simply don't believe there is anything even remotely interesting about Jagger's voice! He is a below average singer, to my ears! I'd rank Mercury ahead of everyone on that list!


John from Boston

Paul Rogers has a great voice tho - and Elton isnt bad either............- i like Janis - very emotional - altho in typical singing terms - yeah - i see where you are coming from. Daltrey had great power - he was quite good back in the day.

Perry & Lennon should have made this list.
Call this the "tone deaf" channel.

This is why I have XM radio.

People, read the header. It is suggesting the voices that defined rock n roll, NOT who has the best voice.

This is why I have XM radio.

XM sucks compared to Sirius. Perhaps that's why Sirius and XM are merging.