Page 1 of 1
OT-Celine Dion Special This past Friday night---a question
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 12:45 pmby BobbyinTN
Did anyone else watch her special. I know she's awesome and all, but if you saw it, did you notice that some of the songs were lipsynced?
She did an awesome cover of the George Harrison song, "Something In The Way" with Joe Walsh on guitar, but it bothers me that some of the songs were lipped, or looked as though they were.
Anyone else?
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:09 pmby scarygirl
No sorry, I missed it.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:15 pmby 7 Wishes
It came down to a coin toss between the Dion special and the frontal lobotomy that night, and to quote the lyrical genius Brett Michaels of Poison...
"It's like sometimes you can't choose
It's like heads they win
Tails you gonna lose"
So the lobotomy won. C'est la vie.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:18 pmby Rockindeano
She's phenomenal. I could listen to her sing every day.
You sure she lipped?
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:19 pmby scarygirl
I would be shocked if she lipped.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:23 pmby Triple S
I'm positive she lipped to 'Taking Chances' but I thought everything else looked live. I've always admired her singing but never really liked many of her songs and couldn't stand to watch her. This time around I have to admit I'm kind of enjoying some of her stuff (even my husband says that and he's always said he can't stand her). Don't know what it is, she just doesn't seem quite so annoying anymore.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:29 pmby BobbyinTN
Rockindeano wrote:She's phenomenal. I could listen to her sing every day.
You sure she lipped?
No, I'm not sure and I agree, I don't think I've ever heard her sing badly live, but there was just too much polish on some of the vocals and they didn't really vary from the studio versions.
So I was hopin' for some back up.
Here's someYouTube footage.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=n3RwNg3EaV4&feature=related
I'm pretty sure "River Deep, Mountain High" was sung live, but listen to the next song, the title track from the new CD. I'm almost certain it's lipped.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:30 pmby BobbyinTN
Triple S wrote:I'm positive she lipped to 'Taking Chances' but I thought everything else looked live. I've always admired her singing but never really liked many of her songs and couldn't stand to watch her. This time around I have to admit I'm kind of enjoying some of her stuff (even my husband says that and he's always said he can't stand her). Don't know what it is, she just doesn't seem quite so annoying anymore.
I've always loved her voice, but this new stuff is just a little bit grittier and I'm lovin' that.
I think "The Power Of Love" was lipped too. The songs that were definitely live was "Something In The Way", "The Prayer" and I think "River Deep, Mountain High" was live.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:39 pmby scarygirl
BobbyinTN wrote:Triple S wrote:I'm positive she lipped to 'Taking Chances' but I thought everything else looked live. I've always admired her singing but never really liked many of her songs and couldn't stand to watch her. This time around I have to admit I'm kind of enjoying some of her stuff (even my husband says that and he's always said he can't stand her). Don't know what it is, she just doesn't seem quite so annoying anymore.
I've always loved her voice, but this new stuff is just a little bit grittier and I'm lovin' that.
I think "The Power Of Love" was lipped too. The songs that were definitely live was "Something In The Way", "The Prayer" and I think "River Deep, Mountain High" was live.
Maybe she's saving her voice. Something I wish someone else had done.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:52 pmby Rockindeano
scarygirl wrote:Maybe she's saving her voice. Something I wish someone else had done.
Augeri?
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:53 pmby scarygirl
Rockindeano wrote:scarygirl wrote:Maybe she's saving her voice. Something I wish someone else had done.
Augeri?
LOL. I don't see anything wrong with lipping in certain situations. Television specials being one of them.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:55 pmby Rockindeano
No, I am serious. I thought at first, Augeri, then I thought maybe Perry.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:57 pmby Perrydise
I dont care who lips, just as long as it isnt done at a concert that I am attending that I paid to get into.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 1:57 pmby scarygirl
Rockindeano wrote:No, I am serious. I thought at first, Augeri, then I thought maybe Perry.
I did have Perry in mind when I said that. He sang the shit out of his voice. If only he had been able to slow down. The same goes for Augeri.
Sounds like Celine only lipped a couple, and sang the majority. Since it wasn't, at least as far as I know presented as a live concert, then I have no problem with that.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 2:21 pmby nikki
Something In The Way---Celine Dion w/ Joe Walsh
http://youtube.com/watch?v=C98e79GXf3s
Judge for yourselves. I like it. One of my favorites of all time. Nice version of it, too.
Posted:
Tue Feb 19, 2008 3:16 pmby johnroxx
"Something" is a song that carries special memories of a great time in life for me...fact is, the Abbey Road album, as a whole, is a pure masterpiece.
Bravo to Celine and Joe for a job well done on this classic...and thanks for posting the youtube.com link.
;^)
Posted:
Wed Feb 20, 2008 12:31 amby Michigan Girl
Perrydise wrote:I dont care who lips, just as long as it isnt done at a concert that I am attending that I paid to get into.
I CONCUR!!!!
Posted:
Wed Feb 20, 2008 1:23 amby sniper16
since this was for tv they might have went in and overdubed it for the broadcast.
kind of like kiss did for thier live lps
Posted:
Wed Feb 20, 2008 1:24 amby conversationpc
7 Wishes wrote:It came down to a coin toss between the Dion special and the frontal lobotomy that night, and to quote the lyrical genius Brett Michaels of Poison...
"It's like sometimes you can't choose
It's like heads they win
Tails you gonna lose"
So the lobotomy won. C'est la vie.
This reminds me of the scene in "Wayne's World 2" where Garth has visions of dental surgery as compared to having to listen to Kenny G.
Posted:
Wed Feb 20, 2008 7:01 amby brywool
BLECH. I thought this was terrible. I saw it when it was on. It was like "Hello, I'm Celine Dion and these are my famous friends!". I think Walsh (whom I usually like) butchered the guitar parts and the show was just like some 1970s Carpenter's special. Yuck. The guitar in the original is so subtle and just has the best tone... Walsh made a mess of it in my opinion.
She's a great singer though, I just have a hard time watching her. Same with Aguilera. AMAZING singer, but to watch her is annoying as hell.
Posted:
Wed Feb 20, 2008 7:21 amby texafana
Yes, she lips. Has for a quite a while. Her Vegas show has several songs lipped. She's not a spring chicken anymore.
Posted:
Wed Feb 20, 2008 7:26 amby Tomulator
johnroxx wrote:"Something" is a song that carries special memories of a great time in life for me...fact is, the Abbey Road album, as a whole, is a pure masterpiece.
Bravo to Celine and Joe for a job well done on this classic...and thanks for posting the youtube.com link.
;^)
It doesn't get ANY BETTER than the second side of Abbey Road.
Perfection. Gets to me every time I listen to it.
Posted:
Wed Feb 20, 2008 7:29 amby SusieP
Her voice is not my cup of tea. Too 'reedy' and 'shrill' for my taste. But I think she's a really nice woman. Eccentric and just a little bit nuts.
She did a TV special on UK television recently, and she lipped on that, definitely. But her pieces to the audience and tv interviews she gave at the time it was filmed were hilarious.
Nutty as a fruitcake.
Posted:
Wed Feb 20, 2008 7:33 amby maverick218
Celine wasn't lipping, but Joe was!
She's a phenominal singer, one of my guilty pleasures.
Posted:
Wed Feb 20, 2008 7:35 amby maverick218
brywool wrote:BLECH. I thought this was terrible. I saw it when it was on. It was like "Hello, I'm Celine Dion and these are my famous friends!". I think Walsh (whom I usually like) butchered the guitar parts and the show was just like some 1970s Carpenter's special. Yuck. The guitar in the original is so subtle and just has the best tone... Walsh made a mess of it in my opinion.
She's a great singer though, I just have a hard time watching her. Same with Aguilera. AMAZING singer, but to watch her is annoying as hell.
In Joe's defense, Celine did say that they just quickly threw it together...
Posted:
Wed Feb 20, 2008 8:28 amby X factor
7 Wishes wrote:It came down to a coin toss between the Dion special and the frontal lobotomy that night, and to quote the lyrical genius Brett Michaels of Poison...
"It's like sometimes you can't choose
It's like heads they win
Tails you gonna lose"
So the lobotomy won. C'est la vie.
Yep- if I want overwroght melodrama in my music , I'll fire up some MEatloaf. At least he rocks...
Posted:
Wed Feb 20, 2008 2:09 pmby nikki
brywool wrote:BLECH. I thought this was terrible. I saw it when it was on. It was like "Hello, I'm Celine Dion and these are my famous friends!". I think Walsh (whom I usually like) butchered the guitar parts and the show was just like some 1970s Carpenter's special. Yuck. The guitar in the original is so subtle and just has the best tone... Walsh made a mess of it in my opinion.
She's a great singer though, I just have a hard time watching her. Same with Aguilera. AMAZING singer, but to watch her is annoying as hell.
I thought it was pretty good for being done spur of the moment. Of course, nothing compares to George's version, which to me is perfect in every way.