Instrumental off the new album

Which do you prefer?
https://forums.melodicrock.com/phpBB/
https://forums.melodicrock.com/phpBB/viewtopic.php?f=69&t=34069
ProgRocker53 wrote:In all seriousness, "The Journey Revelation" sounds like something FyreDynger would entitle something.
Saint John wrote:"Captain Friga's Tea Party" is fuckin' brilliant. I bet even Jon laughs at that one.
Saint John wrote:ProgRocker53 wrote:In all seriousness, "The Journey Revelation" sounds like something FyreDynger would entitle something.
Sounds to me like something a bible thumping southern inbred would come up with.
Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
I was thinking more likely Cain myself.
It was at the encouragement of Shirley that the instrumental even made the cut. That tells me he *gets it*, and like many fans here, holds affection for the titular instrumentals of albums past.
The band has never released an instrumental since Cain joined.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:That tells me he *gets it*, and like many fans here, holds affection for the TITULAR instrumentals of albums past.
Have you heard the demo of "With A Tear" where Perry did mess around with it and they were trying to put lyrics to it? They must have decided it was better left without....here it is if you haven't heard it...fun to hear how he just improvised to the music..ProgRocker53 wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
I was thinking more likely Cain myself.
It was at the encouragement of Shirley that the instrumental even made the cut. That tells me he *gets it*, and like many fans here, holds affection for the titular instrumentals of albums past.
The band has never released an instrumental since Cain joined.
SHOULD'VE released at least two of them.
"With A Tear" and "Into Your Arms" are two of the best songs Journey have ever done. I'm sorry, I don't think a soaring melody and emoting Perry could add to those two songs anymore. Instrumental masterpieces. They sound more "Journey" than more than half of RoR, closer to what I would've expected a Freedom record to be like.
Who played bass and drums on those anyway? Jackson and Londin?
Blueskies wrote:Have you heard the demo of "With A Tear" where Perry did mess around with it and they were trying to put lyrics to it? They must have decided it was better left without....here it is if you haven't heard it...ProgRocker53 wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
I was thinking more likely Cain myself.
It was at the encouragement of Shirley that the instrumental even made the cut. That tells me he *gets it*, and like many fans here, holds affection for the titular instrumentals of albums past.
The band has never released an instrumental since Cain joined.
SHOULD'VE released at least two of them.
"With A Tear" and "Into Your Arms" are two of the best songs Journey have ever done. I'm sorry, I don't think a soaring melody and emoting Perry could add to those two songs anymore. Instrumental masterpieces. They sound more "Journey" than more than half of RoR, closer to what I would've expected a Freedom record to be like.
Who played bass and drums on those anyway? Jackson and Londin?
http://download.yousendit.com/A53E88535DE48539
ProgRocker53 wrote:Blueskies wrote:Have you heard the demo of "With A Tear" where Perry did mess around with it and they were trying to put lyrics to it? They must have decided it was better left without....here it is if you haven't heard it...ProgRocker53 wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
I was thinking more likely Cain myself.
It was at the encouragement of Shirley that the instrumental even made the cut. That tells me he *gets it*, and like many fans here, holds affection for the titular instrumentals of albums past.
The band has never released an instrumental since Cain joined.
SHOULD'VE released at least two of them.
"With A Tear" and "Into Your Arms" are two of the best songs Journey have ever done. I'm sorry, I don't think a soaring melody and emoting Perry could add to those two songs anymore. Instrumental masterpieces. They sound more "Journey" than more than half of RoR, closer to what I would've expected a Freedom record to be like.
Who played bass and drums on those anyway? Jackson and Londin?
http://download.yousendit.com/A53E88535DE48539
Yeah, I've heard it.. I mean, it still would've been a good song with vocals, but for once I feel it is indeed better without. Shame it wasn't included on ROR.
Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
NoMoreTails wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
Yes, but if the instrumental is two pieces of music with "The Journey" portion being a progressive rocker and "Revelation" being a Neal singing through the guitar soulful piece it could work--Conversations/In My Lonely Feeling.....
The Journey/Revelation doesn't feel weird to me the way "The Journey Revelation" would.
Saint John wrote:NoMoreTails wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
Yes, but if the instrumental is two pieces of music with "The Journey" portion being a progressive rocker and "Revelation" being a Neal singing through the guitar soulful piece it could work--Conversations/In My Lonely Feeling.....
The Journey/Revelation doesn't feel weird to me the way "The Journey Revelation" would.
Excellent point(s). Your scenario (The Journey/Revelation) is the only one that would be acceptable as far as incorpoarting all 3 words.
Saint John wrote:NoMoreTails wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
Yes, but if the instrumental is two pieces of music with "The Journey" portion being a progressive rocker and "Revelation" being a Neal singing through the guitar soulful piece it could work--Conversations/In My Lonely Feeling.....
The Journey/Revelation doesn't feel weird to me the way "The Journey Revelation" would.
Excellent point(s). Your scenario (The Journey/Revelation) is the only one that would be acceptable as far as incorpoarting all 3 words.
ProgRocker53 wrote:Although "Captain Friga's Tea Party" is pretty snazzy.
The_Noble_Cause wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
I was thinking more likely Cain myself.
Red13JoePa wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
I was thinking more likely Cain myself.
I've never seen Cain come up w/ a title that daft have you?
Red13JoePa wrote:The_Noble_Cause wrote:Red13JoePa wrote:I don't think it's that bad in and of itse1f it's just weird to use the band name EVER in song.
Reeks of Shir1ey, BTW.
I was thinking more likely Cain myself.
I've never seen Cain come up w/ a title that daft have you?
cyndy! wrote:the bio has it listed as, "The Journey Revelation)," which is grammatically incorrect. maybe it's supposed to be "The Journey (Revelation)."