MR

OK...I'll probably get crucified for this but I actually like Arnel's version of this song better than any I've heard from Perry. I've never cared for the way that Perry sang that song live. There's something about the way he sang the chorus in the versions I've heard that I really don't like at all.

conversationpc wrote:OK...I'll probably get crucified for this but I actually like Arnel's version of this song better than any I've heard from Perry. I've never cared for the way that Perry sang that song live. There's something about the way he sang the chorus in the versions I've heard that I really don't like at all.

You feeling okay?

conversationpc wrote:OK...I'll probably get crucified for this but I actually like Arnel's version of this song better than any I've heard from Perry. I've never cared for the way that Perry sang that song live. There's something about the way he sang the chorus in the versions I've heard that I really don't like at all.

Wow, Dave. You better run for cover, here comes the Loons!

It kicks ass!!!! And I love Jon's keys leading in....

Sorry guys...I don't like the way Perry sang the chorus on that tune, especially the two words from the title. It's the only song I feel that way about.

I wont go "on a limb' and say its better, but it is really good,much better then I expected.I am impressed,If he can make it through the tour and with no trickey from the band, Ill go see them again

conversationpc wrote:OK...I'll probably get crucified for this but I actually like Arnel's version of this song better than any I've heard from Perry. I've never cared for the way that Perry sang that song live. There's something about the way he sang the chorus in the versions I've heard that I really don't like at all.

Crucified may be a little strong! I'm thinking; buried in an Ant Hill is the best option

Since 78 wrote:

conversationpc wrote:OK...I'll probably get crucified for this but I actually like Arnel's version of this song better than any I've heard from Perry. I've never cared for the way that Perry sang that song live. There's something about the way he sang the chorus in the versions I've heard that I really don't like at all.

Crucified may be a little strong! I'm thinking; buried in an Ant Hill is the best option

Do they practice Sharia law where you live?

Does anyone know what the hell Arnel says toward the end of SW? "And if he ever hurts you, true love won't ???????? you"

WTH? It sounds more like "destructmeyou".

conversationpc wrote:

Since 78 wrote:

conversationpc wrote:OK...I'll probably get crucified for this but I actually like Arnel's version of this song better than any I've heard from Perry. I've never cared for the way that Perry sang that song live. There's something about the way he sang the chorus in the versions I've heard that I really don't like at all.

Crucified may be a little strong! I'm thinking; buried in an Ant Hill is the best option

Do they practice Sharia law where you live?

Before I pass final judgment I guess I should watch the DVD. although, even if I agree I'm not gonna say it. You are a brave guy!

On the Houston DVD, Perry sings that song from the bottom of his soul - he puts his all into that song. I don't think anyone could ever sing it better than that. Not to say that Arnel isn't freaking amazing himself!

I get what you are saying about the chorus. On the studio version he brings emphasist to the end of the words ( oopen arrmms ), in the live version he sort of runs it out (ooopen aaarms ) in the front so it is sounds different when he finishes. He is more of an alto on the studio version but becomes a tenor when singing it live. At least that is how I hear it.

Barb wrote:On the Houston DVD, Perry sings that song from the bottom of his soul - he puts his all into that song. I don't think anyone could ever sing it better than that.

Agreed but the way he sings the chorus still bugs me.

Barb wrote:On the Houston DVD, Perry sings that song from the bottom of his soul - he puts his all into that song. I don't think anyone could ever sing it better than that. Not to say that Arnel isn't freaking amazing himself!

Perry does sing from the soul, but Arnel puts soul in the song....

Gunbot wrote:I get what you are saying about the chorus. On the studio version he brings emphasist to the end of the words ( oopen arrmms ), in the live version he sort of runs it out (ooopen aaarms ) in the front so it is sounds different when he finishes.

That's a good description of what I'm talking about.

conversationpc wrote:

Barb wrote:On the Houston DVD, Perry sings that song from the bottom of his soul - he puts his all into that song. I don't think anyone could ever sing it better than that.

Agreed but the way he sings the chorus still bugs me.

You're cuckoo!

I hear you. I feel the same way except I prefer Augeri's version. I would have have liked Perry's version a lot more if he had stayed true to the studio version (I feel that way about a lot of live Perry performances) as opposed to, for instance, the Houston '81 version.

Studio version: "So now I COOOOME to youuuu with OOOOOpen arms"

Houston '81 "So now I COME TO YOU WITH OPEN ARMS"

The phrase "Open Arms" is sung with the same note...and I think it loses its' intensity.

I liked the way Steve A. stuck to the studio versions, which were, in my opinion, the definitive versions in most cases.

Barb wrote:

conversationpc wrote:

Barb wrote:On the Houston DVD, Perry sings that song from the bottom of his soul - he puts his all into that song. I don't think anyone could ever sing it better than that.

Agreed but the way he sings the chorus still bugs me.

You're cuckoo!

JeremyP wrote:I hear you. I feel the same way except I prefer Augeri's version. I would have have liked Perry's version a lot more if he had stayed true to the studio version (I feel that way about a lot of live Perry performances) as opposed to, for instance, the Houston '81 version.

Studio version: "So now I COOOOME to youuuu with OOOOOpen arms"

Houston '81 "So now I COME TO YOU WITH OPEN ARMS"

The phrase "Open Arms" is sung with the same note...and I think it loses its' intensity.

I liked the way Steve A. stuck to the studio versions, which were, in my opinion, the definitive versions in most cases.

I love Augeri...

ScarabGator wrote:

JeremyP wrote:I hear you. I feel the same way except I prefer Augeri's version. I would have have liked Perry's version a lot more if he had stayed true to the studio version (I feel that way about a lot of live Perry performances) as opposed to, for instance, the Houston '81 version.

Studio version: "So now I COOOOME to youuuu with OOOOOpen arms"

Houston '81 "So now I COME TO YOU WITH OPEN ARMS"

The phrase "Open Arms" is sung with the same note...and I think it loses its' intensity.

I liked the way Steve A. stuck to the studio versions, which were, in my opinion, the definitive versions in most cases.

I love Augeri...

Me too. I still miss him.

stevew2 wrote:I wont go "on a limb' and say its better, but it is really good,much better then I expected.I am impressed,If he can make it through the tour and with no trickey from the band, Ill go see them again

Stevew, is that really you? This was the first positive comment I've heard from you since I joined MR.

Barb wrote:

ScarabGator wrote:

JeremyP wrote:I hear you. I feel the same way except I prefer Augeri's version. I would have have liked Perry's version a lot more if he had stayed true to the studio version (I feel that way about a lot of live Perry performances) as opposed to, for instance, the Houston '81 version.

Studio version: "So now I COOOOME to youuuu with OOOOOpen arms"

Houston '81 "So now I COME TO YOU WITH OPEN ARMS"

The phrase "Open Arms" is sung with the same note...and I think it loses its' intensity.

I liked the way Steve A. stuck to the studio versions, which were, in my opinion, the definitive versions in most cases.

I love Augeri...

Me too. I still miss him.

Me too. No offense to Arnel because he is awesome but I wish things could have turned out different with him. I dont know if he reads this board but if he does I hope he knows a bunch of us really appreciated him.

Barb wrote:

ScarabGator wrote:

JeremyP wrote:I hear you. I feel the same way except I prefer Augeri's version. I would have have liked Perry's version a lot more if he had stayed true to the studio version (I feel that way about a lot of live Perry performances) as opposed to, for instance, the Houston '81 version.

Studio version: "So now I COOOOME to youuuu with OOOOOpen arms"

Houston '81 "So now I COME TO YOU WITH OPEN ARMS"

The phrase "Open Arms" is sung with the same note...and I think it loses its' intensity.

I liked the way Steve A. stuck to the studio versions, which were, in my opinion, the definitive versions in most cases.

I love Augeri...

Me too. I still miss him.

Same here. That lineup will always be MY Journey.

O.k. After listening, First and Last question WHAT ARE YOU SMOKIN!!!! SOMEBODY BRING ME A SHOVEL!!!!!

Since 78 wrote:O.k. After listening, First and Last question WHAT ARE YOU SMOKIN!!!! SOMEBODY BRING ME A SHOVEL!!!!!

Where's JoePa when you really need him.

RebornJrny wrote:

stevew2 wrote:I wont go "on a limb' and say its better, but it is really good,much better then I expected.I am impressed,If he can make it through the tour and with no trickey from the band, Ill go see them again

Stevew, is that really you? This was the first positive comment I've heard from you since I joined MR.

Its me, and I do miss Steve A,and I wish Journey would have took a break, and maybe we woud be talking about him. As you know Journey is greedy, and we know the rest of the story. That aside. I love the music that Journey made. Personally they are retarded. I am separating myself from them personally{which i should have done in 2002}I love the music they have made, and I like most of Revelations. I would have rather had Jeremey sing for Journey, that didnt happen.I am enjoying all the new stuff,and Arnel is one hell of a singer, and a nice guy{like Augeri is} I hear accents, but I can understand every word he is singing. When I heard "Only The Young" thats what changed my mind about everything

Steve, you're talking about the Chile gig, right?

Patriotism aside, I wanted to be blown away, but found myself uneasy from the start of their set,
and not because of accent, pitch or timing problems on Arnel's part. Those things were bad enough,
but each song felt too much like Arnel was "trying" to sing it.

Then they played Only The Young... and it was like, just there.
Like he stopped trying, and just sang it.
That's when I knew there really was something there to build on.

wech

wednesday's child wrote:Steve, you're talking about the Chile gig, right?

Patriotism aside, I wanted to be blown away, but found myself uneasy from the start of their set,
and not because of accent, pitch or timing problems on Arnel's part. Those things were bad enough,
but each song felt too much like Arnel was "trying" to sing it.

Then they played Only The Young... and it was like, just there.
Like he stopped trying, and just sang it.
That's when I knew there really was something there to build on.

wech

No I am talkin abbout the stuidio version of Only The Young, {flawless} and the las veg, video. Chile sucked

Hah! Serves me right.
Chile deffo had problems, lke I said...
bright spot for me was Only the Young, which at least showed me some real potential.

wech