MR

http://youtube.com/watch?v=XEKhzHrSXiE

Augeri, Perry, and Pineda all on one track, mixed perfectly!

That was really cool.

Great video, thanks for sharing.

ALMOST mixed perfectly. A few beats off (eeww! )

Very cool.

brywool wrote:ALMOST mixed perfectly. A few beats off (eeww! )

Very cool.

I thought they did a really good job mixing it too. I would of took the backing track from the Chile festival, and just lifted the three vocals off the other performances and overdubbed it... but then the videos would not sync.... AHHH see there is a reason I have yet to attempt to do this...

Didn't watch it all, but where's JSS?

These are my thoughts and do not reflect the thoughts of anyone else on this board.

That was cool. Made me realize how long it has been since I listened to anything Augeri did......kinda miss the dude. Gotta go break out some boots!

tammy wrote:Didn't watch it all, but where's JSS?

Well I would say there wasn't any "good footage" of DVD quality of Open arms, and also I would say a lot people either forgotten or didn't release he was touring with Journey for a short period of time, and they never recorded anything of decent quality to advertise, or did they?.

tammy wrote:Didn't watch it all, but where's JSS?

They must only use Journey singers who have released material with the group..

Vladan wrote:

tammy wrote:Didn't watch it all, but where's JSS?

Well I would say there wasn't any "good footage" of DVD quality of Open arms, and also I would say a lot people either forgotten or didn't release he was touring with Journey for a short period of time, and they never recorded anything of decent quality to advertise, or did they?.

one other point to remember is that JSS only did Open Arms with Journey very few times. Deen did the song 95% of the tour.

Rick wrote:These are my thoughts and do not reflect the thoughts of anyone else on this board.

Switch AP and SA for me and that's my feeling on the matter. I didnt bring my pie chart though.

Rick wrote:These are my thoughts and do not reflect the thoughts of anyone else on this board.

Agreed, although I'd put Perry's bar a little bit higher.

Barb wrote:

Rick wrote:These are my thoughts and do not reflect the thoughts of anyone else on this board.

Agreed, although I'd put Perry's bar a little bit higher.

Not based on those clips. In my opinion Perry sounds 'off' on Open Arms live compared to the studio. Something about the way he sings the words 'Open Arms' it just doesn't seem to soar. Seems weird to say it as I think Perry in his active years was by far the best vocalist I ever heard but on that clip alone he comes off worse. Love Augeri's tone but Arnel owns it!

Cool Mix!

I really liked all three of these guys for different reasons when at their best. Perry stopped impressing me after Escape. Augeri was a very good replacement and gave us Journey back, and Arnel makes me excited for the present and future. The mix does a good job of showing how each of them brings something similar, yet different to the songs. I'm a big fan of JSS, but after hearing him twice live fronting Journey I was completely turned off at the thought of him being the permanent replacement. Arnel was and is the right move. His voice is the best suited to the Journey catalog. We'll see how he holds up. IMO Journey has had three excellent singers...SP, SA and now Arnel.

musicfan17 wrote:Cool Mix!

I really liked all three of these guys for different reasons when at their best. Perry stopped impressing me after Escape. Augeri was a very good replacement and gave us Journey back, and Arnel makes me excited for the present and future. The mix does a good job of showing how each of them brings something similar, yet different to the songs. I'm a big fan of JSS, but after hearing him twice live fronting Journey I was completely turned off at the thought of him being the permanent replacement. Arnel was and is the right move. His voice is the best suited to the Journey catalog. We'll see how he holds up. IMO Journey has had three excellent singers...SP, SA and now Arnel.

Whooaaa what?!

Just because he couldnt sing like his balls were twisted??

What a silly .. silly .. comment.

Faithfully, WCTNGOF, Seperate Way.. the list is endless of great Perry moments after Escape

Rick wrote:These are my thoughts and do not reflect the thoughts of anyone else on this board.

I like your chart Rick, my thoughts on these Frontmen are pretty much the same as yours.

Very cool. Thanks for posting it.

youkeepmewaiting wrote:

musicfan17 wrote:Cool Mix!

I really liked all three of these guys for different reasons when at their best. Perry stopped impressing me after Escape. Augeri was a very good replacement and gave us Journey back, and Arnel makes me excited for the present and future. The mix does a good job of showing how each of them brings something similar, yet different to the songs. I'm a big fan of JSS, but after hearing him twice live fronting Journey I was completely turned off at the thought of him being the permanent replacement. Arnel was and is the right move. His voice is the best suited to the Journey catalog. We'll see how he holds up. IMO Journey has had three excellent singers...SP, SA and now Arnel.

Whooaaa what?!

Just because he couldnt sing like his balls were twisted??

What a silly .. silly .. comment.

Faithfully, WCTNGOF, Seperate Way.. the list is endless of great Perry moments after Escape

I said he stopped impressing me after Escape...I didn't say I didn't think he was still a great singer. Thanks for call me silly btw... But I'm sure that's not the worst thing I'll be called around here. Anyway...I liked all three of our Journey singers. The you tube mix was kinda cool. Let's not turn this into yet another thread were you must defend SP.

Rick wrote:These are my thoughts and do not reflect the thoughts of anyone else on this board.

I cant see the apparent pie chart is it??

Ha ha I posted the reply and now I can...

Good stuff! Respect to these 3 gentlemen. JSS well...he actually saved the band, so respect to him too.

Bar charts comparing Journey singers?
My, my... here, quite frankly, is what I think:

Very cool video...makes me miss Perry though.

wednesday's child wrote:Bar charts comparing Journey singers?
My, my... here, quite frankly, is what I think:

That chart resembles a hand making some sort of gesture. I think your chart is more accurate than mine is.

wednesday's child wrote:Bar charts comparing Journey singers?
My, my... here, quite frankly, is what I think:

This is good for me too!!!

I'd say nobody can beat the original coz he MADE the song. No matter how good the predecessors are, they will just be as good as how they could sing the way the original did. Please note that i'm a new journey fan. Cool video, i don't see it as comparing them, but something for us to realize how good the song is no matter who's the frontman. Also, it means that their (band) choices are right all the time. Love it!

Nobody will ever be better than Steve Perry. He was/is to musical vocals as what Michael Jordan was to the NBA. It's really foolish to compare anybody to his talents. The argument then basically becomes a game of horse shoes amongst the other lead singers in the band. I think from there, it really just comes down to personal tastes. I think Arnel has a great voice, but I actually prefer Augeri or Soto since their voices were much different from Perry's.

that was great, great breaks in the song to cut in
whoever did it , can they go get the audio for
dont turn around by
neil diamond
eyes-jeff scott soto
ans ace of base
always wondered what a medley of those 3 would sound like