MR

Hey, its anti-appreciation thread day so what the hell.

Anyone got that clip of JSS doing "Only The Young" where he does some kind of squeal? I remember Deano said Ross must've goosed him.

StoneCold wrote:Hey, its anti-appreciation thread day so what the hell.

Anyone got that clip of JSS doing "Only The Young" where he does some kind of squeal? I remember Deano said Ross must've goosed him.

Dude, you're really askin for it!

I really can't name one song Soto butchered. He was just mdeiocre to me on a lot of them and good on some. The dude is too talented to really fuck up any song.

Since 78 wrote:

StoneCold wrote:Hey, its anti-appreciation thread day so what the hell.

Anyone got that clip of JSS doing "Only The Young" where he does some kind of squeal? I remember Deano said Ross must've goosed him.

Dude, you're really askin for it!

Rolie and Fleischman are next but I'll let somebody else post those.

Somebody like you! See how many Worst threads we can create before Andrew lays the hammer down.

Saint John wrote:I really can't name one song Soto butchered. He was just mdeiocre to me on a lot of them and good on some. The dude is too talented to really fuck up any song.

He raped "Stone In Love" pretty good when I saw them in Indy.

I know that when Jeff first joined Journey, someone posted a performance of him singing "Separate Ways" on here as proof he was the man. It was not a good performance, at all, and I said so at the time here, not endearing myself to Soto fans. When he went to hit the high notes, they simply weren't there. That said, he was brand new to Journey then, and he did get better. His absolute best song was always "I'll Be Alright Without You". He nailed that song EVERY time!


John from Boston

RedWingFan wrote:He raped "Stone In Love" pretty good when I saw them in Indy.

Dude, he raped all of Journey songs, that's the reason why he was canned...

RedWingFan wrote:He raped "Stone In Love" pretty good when I saw them in Indy.

Only Arnel on the re-record did it justice. I really liked the newer guitar parts.

Saint John wrote:

RedWingFan wrote:He raped "Stone In Love" pretty good when I saw them in Indy.

Only Arnel on the re-record did it justice. I really liked the newer guitar parts.

I wouldn't know. Still haven't listened to that blasphemous cd.

RedWingFan wrote:

Saint John wrote:

RedWingFan wrote:He raped "Stone In Love" pretty good when I saw them in Indy.

Only Arnel on the re-record did it justice. I really liked the newer guitar parts.

I wouldn't know. Still haven't listened to that blasphemous cd.

That's a colse-minded view. Fuckin' feminist.

tanga wrote:Dude, he raped all of Journey songs, that's the reason why he was canned...

Timing being what it was. I truly believe Schon & co. saw Tragchick's first Arnel thread here and set about the ouster of JSS.

StoneCold wrote:

tanga wrote:Dude, he raped all of Journey songs, that's the reason why he was canned...

Timing being what it was. I truly believe Schon & co. saw Tragchick's first Arnel thread here and set about the ouster of JSS.

Jeff was being let go before the Youtube samples were posted. That's actually why they were being posted on here.

Saint John wrote: Only Arnel on the re-record did it justice.

Here is Arnel completely murdering "Stone In Love". What a fucking train wreck this was!!!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=weJ75cT-SZc


John from Boston

Enigma869 wrote:

Saint John wrote: Only Arnel on the re-record did it justice.

Here is Arnel completely murdering "Stone In Love". What a fucking train wreck this was!!!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=weJ75cT-SZc


John from Boston

I said re-record, as in the album version (Revelation disc 2), dick lips.

Saint John wrote:I said re-record, as in the album version (Revelation disc 2), dick lips.

Yeah...I know what you said, fuckwad I simply wanted to point out that your new best friend Arnel has had some shaky moments, as well!


John from Boston

Enigma869 wrote:

Saint John wrote: Only Arnel on the re-record did it justice.

Here is Arnel completely murdering "Stone In Love". What a fucking train wreck this was!!!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=weJ75cT-SZc


John from Boston

For his first live performance with the band, I'd say that was pretty damn good. But I judge people differently than most others do. If they can do it better than I can, then I'm impressed. I'm a horrible singer.

Rick wrote:For his first live performance with the band, I'd say that was pretty damn good. But I judge people differently than most others do. If they can do it better than I can, then I'm impressed. I'm a horrible singer.

We'll agree to disagree. It was a horrendous peformance, in my opinion. You have to understand that I believe Arnel is a very talented singer, so I expect FAR more out of him, than I ever did out of Augeri. Because of that, I don't think it was a good performance. I'm not a good singer, either, but that really isn't the point. I'm not the dude up there trying to sing Journey's catalog. Arnel has obviously gotten better, but he was ALL over the place (vocally) on that performance!


John from Boston

Enigma869 wrote:

Saint John wrote:I said re-record, as in the album version (Revelation disc 2), dick lips.

Yeah...I know what you said, fuckwad I simply wanted to point out that your new best friend Arnel has had some shaky moments, as well!


John from Boston

And I've denied said "shaky moments" where, cum guzzler?

StoneCold wrote:
Somebody like you! See how many Worst threads we can create before Andrew lays the hammer down.

How about... No?

jss is purrrrfect. always. }:C))

"only the young"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLWMLGR9yuk

I liked JSS doing Only the Young. I thought it suited his voice more than some of the other Journey songs.

StoneCold wrote:Hey, its anti-appreciation thread day so what the hell.

Anyone got that clip of JSS doing "Only The Young" where he does some kind of squeal? I remember Deano said Ross must've goosed him.

Not sure if I've heard that one. But I do get a chuckle out of Ross' bigass smile on this clip around the 1:15 mark or so.......likes watching our boy too.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-UR2hw6AsAI

IMO, JSS is the only one to nail the sexy soulful bluesy swagger that song calls for vocally......since Perry.

Rick wrote:

StoneCold wrote:

tanga wrote:Dude, he raped all of Journey songs, that's the reason why he was canned...

Timing being what it was. I truly believe Schon & co. saw Tragchick's first Arnel thread here and set about the ouster of JSS.

Jeff was being let go before the Youtube samples were posted. That's actually why they were being posted on here.

I think Trag's AP thread was April of 07 and Jeff was still there until after he Virginia show in May. I'll see if I can find the AP thread.

Yep, April 17, 2007. Here 'tis

http://forums.melodicrock.com/phpBB/vie ... hp?t=24598

In June, LocknLoad threw this one up

http://forums.melodicrock.com/phpBB/vie ... highlight=