annie89509 wrote:Gideon wrote:It's one of my favorites and actually one of the true vocal gems on Escape. I know I might get stringed up by my penis for suggesting this, but Perry's tone on Escape was (in my opinion) the least pleasant of all the albums. It was in that transition period when his high tenor was starting to get wear and tear; whiney rather than piercing.
I much prefer either his supremely high pitched days (Infinity thru Departure) or when he adapted a harder tone from Frontiers on out. From '83 - '94, he had the best vocal tone I've ever heard.
Blasphemy!

In retrospect, I guess we can say Steve's voice in ESCAPE was in the transitional phase from tenor to baritone, lol. However, I always thought his early years, while technically perfect, sounded "girly." The critics sure made fun of it. I, too, love the harder edge to his singing in the later albums. In the concert boots, though, SP was noticeably straining by the later dates of the Frontiers tour, where he started losing his range (and ducking notes, as some have called it). So, to me, the Escape period was the perfect blend of his singing abilities when he was simply unmatched as a singer and performer (as so many have stated in regards to SP).
See, I don't see that. At all. Comparing his performances pre-Escape, Escape, and post-Escape, it seemed as though Perry's voice was in a state of flux from '80-'82; Perry
never went baritone, the notes in songs like "Faithfully" and "Why Can't This Night Go On Forever" still require a high pitch, it just wasn't his countertenor days.
He sounded angelic with his pristine, glass-breaking vocals from Infinity through Departure. Escape, he came off as a little raspy and more than a little whiney as his tenor voice took some wear and tear. I can't quite describe it, but there were times he sounded like a fucking banshee. Technically impressive, as always, but his tone and quality were sub-par (relative to what he once was and what he would be). And his phrasing began to flux, as well.
But from '83-'94, almost perfect.