Rhiannon wrote:WalrusOct9 wrote:See? That sounded great. So why do they need all the tapes when they play live?
It's not tapes... they just have sounds from their originals that you can't recreate with a five guy band. Such as with the medleys. It's not like anyone's out there lipping. They're true to their sound and I don't see any problem at all with the way they put on a live show.
I dunno...Queen never used tapes and they kicked ass live. It didn't sound exactly like the studio version, but that was the point. I remember Def Leppard on their VH1 Storytellers in '99 singing an a capella chorus of "Armageddon It" and it blew me away. You can recreate anything if you put your mind to it, get a little creative, and have a band full of guys with decent voices.
Sorry....I really like those guys' songs and the lead singer has got some fuckin' pipes, but both times I saw them (in 2005 opening for Europe and in 2007) the tapes weren't for 'enhancement', they were almost drowning out the band (the drummer, in fact was almost completely overwhelmed by his own drum loops, making it feel even more like memorex).
It mildly annoys me when Journey and Toto do this too, given the level of voices onstage (particularly with Toto), but it's never been as loud in the mix as it was on the 7th Heaven stuff. There's great songs, a killer lead singer, and presumably a solid band behind all of it...don't cover that up with a laptop. In a live show, balls and energy go farther than computerized 100% precision.