Rockindeano wrote: SA re recorded this DVd in studio.
I'm not looking to square off on this, but I'm not sure I buy this in its entirety. There's some moments that SA had during that DVD that a half-drunk producer wouldn't let get past him without an overdub. Ask The Lonely is filled with them. I suspect it's more the case that things were overdubbed and fixed in the studio.....to what extent is probably where the question lies. I couldn't weigh in on that with any level of knowledge. I just feel that there are certain points on that DVD that, if given the opportunity to fix (in the entirety) in the studio....would not have been presented on the dvd as it currently stands.
Having said there, there isn't a live album recorded these days that doesn't receive some level of studio magic. Case in point was the Right Here Right Now live DVD/CD that Van Halen did in 1994. According to lore, Alex's drum set did not translate to tape very well during the 2 nights they recorded..and despite Andy Johns' best efforts, he simply couldn't get the drums to sound right when they went back to mix it.
So, IIRC, their solution was to use literally re-record the snare drum, as it blasted through PA speakers in EVH's racketball court....stick a mic at the other end of the court, and pipe that signal back to the mixing console. That, and of course the various vocal overdubs and redos....
It seems to me that your intention is to make the Arrival DVD out to be a sort of "Kiss: Alive" record....which *were* "live" records that were simply recorded in the studio and given the benefit of an "audience cheer track." I'm not so sure that was the case with the arrival dvd. It does appear that the music and a percentage of the vocals were indeed recorded in that building that night, but they brought the tracks back to San Francisco to fix the really bad spots.
Granted, I could be fooled here...but I've spent enough time in both the live music and recording worlds to feel that it's more along the lines of overdubbed errors instead of an outright studio recording....
BTW, Congrats on kicking the bottle. You're a better man than I. I can't last 6 days!