MR

Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

Oh Come on! I mean Geez!! Perry is definitely a bigger quitter than Prince!

Since 78 wrote:

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

Oh Come on! I mean Geez!! Perry is definitely a bigger quitter than Prince!

Prince is still making albums (crap ones since after Chaos and Disorder) and playing live and touring- um, what's Perry doing?

brywool wrote:

Since 78 wrote:

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

Oh Come on! I mean Geez!! Perry is definitely a bigger quitter than Prince!

Prince is still making albums (crap ones since after Chaos and Disorder) and playing live and touring- um, what's Perry doing?

Listening to Prince albums

brywool wrote: um, what's Perry doing?

Giving everyone a reason to ask this question 10 times daily!!
Where's SJ?!?! If I had time I would quote him
word for word~the rant that will surely be here soon......

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

Looks like I'm gonna have to educate another moron.

Same site, different list: "No Singer? No Problem! 20 Replacement Singers" and yup, Journey's there too http://www.spinner.com/2008/04/02/no-singer-no-problem-journey/

There's alot of big heartbreakers on that list.

steveo777 wrote:

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

Looks like I'm gonna have to educate another moron.

About what looks good to me!!!!

The worst kind of quitter - quit on his band, fans, and himself. Doesn't care and doesn't try.

Onestepper wrote:

brywool wrote:

Since 78 wrote:

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

Oh Come on! I mean Geez!! Perry is definitely a bigger quitter than Prince!

Prince is still making albums (crap ones since after Chaos and Disorder) and playing live and touring- um, what's Perry doing?

Listening to Prince albums

Good one!

Arianddu wrote:Same site, different list: "No Singer? No Problem! 20 Replacement Singers" and yup, Journey's there too http://www.spinner.com/2008/04/02/no-singer-no-problem-journey/

So cool, SP and JSS Pictured...look out, here comes Deb!!!

Terrible choice of photography. The person who deserves to be pictured with Perry in that pic is Steve Augeri. 8 long years that kept the touring machine going is something that must not go unnoticed, and it is. Shameshame.

steveo777 wrote:

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

Looks like I'm gonna have to educate another moron.

I dunno what you're gonna teach that karaoke star , but don't call him a moron, please ?!

Behshad wrote:

steveo777 wrote:

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

Looks like I'm gonna have to educate another moron.

I dunno what you're gonna teach that karaoke star , but don't call him a moron, please ?!

Now, well....you know!!!

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

To me that article is really bias, I understand who they are intending to put down there. Serously if I were a member of Journey and SP wanted to come back, I'd audition him, have him sing some tunes, then after he's been humiliated enough since he can't sing anymore, I'd say thanks but no thanks, we got someone who sings great and won't flake out on us when we want to do music.

However, if Journey did bring SP back and things went "south" again like they did before with SP and Journey, I'd be one of the members here LMAO. To replace AP with SP now, that's beyond stupidity and they would be just begging for something to go wrong doing it.

The Sushi Hunter wrote:

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

To me that article is really bias, I understand who they are intending to put down there. Serously if I were a member of Journey and SP wanted to come back, I'd audition him, have him sing some tunes, then after he's been humiliated enough since he can't sing anymore, I'd say thanks but no thanks, we got someone who sings great and won't flake out on us when we want to do music.

However, if Journey did bring SP back and things went "south" again like they did before with SP and Journey, I'd be one of the members here LMAO. To replace AP with SP now, that's beyond stupidity and they would be just begging for something to go wrong doing it.

Everyone would like things to be the way they used to be, myself included. Unfortunately, what you have posted is probably closer to what the reality would be. Because I already know this, it makes it easier to move on with the band and love the music that Mr. Perry has left us with, while also enjoying what we have now. There is a lot of light ahead.

brywool wrote:

Since 78 wrote:

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

Oh Come on! I mean Geez!! Perry is definitely a bigger quitter than Prince!

Prince is still making albums (crap ones since after Chaos and Disorder) and playing live and touring- um, what's Perry doing?

I got into Prince's music in the late 80's. The last great album he put out though I'm sure was Purple Rain. Since that album, I have absolutely zero use for any of Prince's music now.

steveo777 wrote:

The Sushi Hunter wrote:

Onestepper wrote:Not sure if this has been posted yet. Perry is listed with this blurb about half way down the list. Don't know if they are necessarily ranked, but thought it was interesting who else made the list:

Steve Perry

Steve Perry Quits Journey:

Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

http://www.spinner.com/2009/09/17/rocks-biggest-quitters-20-musicians-who-walked-away-from-fame/

To me that article is really bias, I understand who they are intending to put down there. Serously if I were a member of Journey and SP wanted to come back, I'd audition him, have him sing some tunes, then after he's been humiliated enough since he can't sing anymore, I'd say thanks but no thanks, we got someone who sings great and won't flake out on us when we want to do music.

However, if Journey did bring SP back and things went "south" again like they did before with SP and Journey, I'd be one of the members here LMAO. To replace AP with SP now, that's beyond stupidity and they would be just begging for something to go wrong doing it.

Everyone would like things to be the way they used to be, myself included. Unfortunately, what you have posted is probably closer to what the reality would be. Because I already know this, it makes it easier to move on with the band and love the music that Mr. Perry has left us with, while also enjoying what we have now. There is a lot of light ahead.

That's right......head for the bright light Steveo777.......

YoungJRNY wrote:Terrible choice of photography. The person who deserves to be pictured with Perry in that pic is Steve Augeri. 8 long years that kept the touring machine going is something that must not go unnoticed, and it is. Shameshame.

I agree.

YoungJRNY wrote:Terrible choice of photography. The person who deserves to be pictured with Perry in that pic is Steve Augeri. 8 long years that kept the touring machine going is something that must not go unnoticed, and it is. Shameshame.

Sometimes 8 years of hard work doesn't get full recognition as a result of 8 weeks of lippin.
If they were to choose any other picture than Soto's pic , it should be this pic

Spinner wrote:Cat Stevens, born Steven Georgiou, sold millions of copies of his touchy-feely folk rock. But after nearly drowning in 1976, Stevens began searching for higher meaning. He converted to Islam, changed his name (again) to Yusuf Islam and auctioned off his guitars for charity. Though praised for his philanthropy, Yusuf's support of Islamic charities landed him on an FBI watch list in 2004. Fortunately, his name was cleared in time to promote his 2006 return album.

If he "quit".....then what the HELL IS THIS....??

"...If ya wanna sell-out, SELL-OUT...."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=im9RGjuDbu0

Gibby wrote:The worst kind of quitter - quit on his band, fans, and himself. Doesn't care and doesn't try.

who are you talking about, cuz i know it isn't steve perry.

Gibby wrote:The worst kind of quitter - quit on his band, fans, and himself. Doesn't care and doesn't try.

No way. Show me what you have contributed to the rock world, and then we will compare it against what Steve Perry has contributed. I can assure you that you will be the one looking like a quitter... you probably never even got started.

If I was Steve Perry, I would be extremely proud of what I gave to my fans, and I wouldn't feel the least bit indebted to anyone to give them anything more. Perry gave willingly... how can you fault him because he won't give any more? He hasn't betrayed his fans, and he hasn't betrayed himself. He did what he did, and he did it better than any singer I have ever heard. He should be walking around patting himself on the back all day long. I am very happy with what he gave, and he doesn't owe me or anyone else anything more. Even if he wanted to give more... maybe he doesn't have the voice? Should he be ashamed of that?

Quitter? That's not one of the words that come to my mind when I think of Steve Perry. He's still living his life... not the one we want him to live.



[/loonrant]

Voyager wrote:

Gibby wrote:The worst kind of quitter - quit on his band, fans, and himself. Doesn't care and doesn't try.

No way. Show me what you have contributed to the rock world, and then we will compare it against what Steve Perry has contributed. I can assure you that you will be the one looking like a quitter... you probably never even got started.

If I was Steve Perry, I would be extremely proud of what I gave to my fans, and I wouldn't feel the least bit indebted to anyone to give them anything more. Perry gave willingly... how dare we ridicule him because he won't give any more? He hasn't betrayed his fans, and he hasn't betrayed himself. He did what he did, and he did it better than any singer I have ever heard. I am very happy with what he gave, and he doesn't owe me or anyone else anything more. Even if he wanted to give more... maybe he doesn't have the voice? Should he be ashamed of that?

Quitter? That's not one of the words that come to my mind when I think of Steve Perry. He's still living his life... not the one we want him to live.

Hoooo~raaaayyy!!

Nice!!!

but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."

fat chance

The Sushi Hunter wrote:
I got into Prince's music in the late 80's. The last great album he put out though I'm sure was Purple Rain. Since that album, I have absolutely zero use for any of Prince's music now.

He's actually got some very cool stuff. However, his albums are THE MOST inconsistent of any artist ever. Check out his Batman soundtrack, and do a youtube search for the song "Peach". Both are great.

TRAGChick wrote:

Spinner wrote:Cat Stevens, born Steven Georgiou, sold millions of copies of his touchy-feely folk rock. But after nearly drowning in 1976, Stevens began searching for higher meaning. He converted to Islam, changed his name (again) to Yusuf Islam and auctioned off his guitars for charity. Though praised for his philanthropy, Yusuf's support of Islamic charities landed him on an FBI watch list in 2004. Fortunately, his name was cleared in time to promote his 2006 return album.

If he "quit".....then what the HELL IS THIS....??

"...If ya wanna sell-out, SELL-OUT...."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=im9RGjuDbu0

Are you saying that if Trag gotta chance at a commercial jingle, you wouldn't give them one of your tunes? I definitely would!
Ca Ching!

Michigan Girl wrote:

Voyager wrote:

Gibby wrote:The worst kind of quitter - quit on his band, fans, and himself. Doesn't care and doesn't try.

No way. Show me what you have contributed to the rock world, and then we will compare it against what Steve Perry has contributed. I can assure you that you will be the one looking like a quitter... you probably never even got started.

If I was Steve Perry, I would be extremely proud of what I gave to my fans, and I wouldn't feel the least bit indebted to anyone to give them anything more. Perry gave willingly... how dare we ridicule him because he won't give any more? He hasn't betrayed his fans, and he hasn't betrayed himself. He did what he did, and he did it better than any singer I have ever heard. I am very happy with what he gave, and he doesn't owe me or anyone else anything more. Even if he wanted to give more... maybe he doesn't have the voice? Should he be ashamed of that?

Quitter? That's not one of the words that come to my mind when I think of Steve Perry. He's still living his life... not the one we want him to live.

Hoooo~raaaayyy!!

Nice!!!

Great post Voyager! There is a huge difference between "quitting" and deciding that you've given as much as you are able to give and would like a chance to have a different life. SP missed out on spending more time with his dying mother to write and produce a Journey album - how many of you would sacrifice time with a dying loved one to go to work when you don't have to? He could have kept living the life of a rock star, but left the road and took care of his dying grandfather instead. That's not quitting in my book.


I certainly respect his right to choose what he wants to do with his life and if not spending it with two guys most of the people on MR call names I'd rather not repeat is one of them, then so be it! I miss him in Journey too, but I appreciate what he gave of himself and while he was with Journey he gave his all.

Voyager wrote:

Gibby wrote:The worst kind of quitter - quit on his band, fans, and himself. Doesn't care and doesn't try.

No way. Show me what you have contributed to the rock world, and then we will compare it against what Steve Perry has contributed. I can assure you that you will be the one looking like a quitter... you probably never even got started.

If I was Steve Perry, I would be extremely proud of what I gave to my fans, and I wouldn't feel the least bit indebted to anyone to give them anything more. Perry gave willingly... how can you fault him because he won't give any more? He hasn't betrayed his fans, and he hasn't betrayed himself. He did what he did, and he did it better than any singer I have ever heard. He should be walking around patting himself on the back all day long. I am very happy with what he gave, and he doesn't owe me or anyone else anything more. Even if he wanted to give more... maybe he doesn't have the voice? Should he be ashamed of that?

Quitter? That's not one of the words that come to my mind when I think of Steve Perry. He's still living his life... not the one we want him to live.




[/loonrant]

Ditto!