Moderator: Andrew
roycap wrote:Journey has the better song catalog, but Foreigner and Styx will blow them away live. Pineda is still raw and is not a polished lead singer. Styx and Foreigner
will get the better reviews.
roycap wrote:Journey has the better song catalog, but Foreigner and Styx will blow them away live. Pineda is still raw and is not a polished lead singer. Styx and Foreigner
will get the better reviews.
Archetype wrote:I saw Styx last week in Erie. They're really, really, really good as of late, and they've always been good. They're going to upstage Journey and Foreigner. No doubt about it. It'll be really anti-climactic since it seems that Styx will be playing first. I saw United in Rock this summer and Styx blew Foreigner away. I'm so glad that they played last or Foreigner would have seemed even more dull. Styx was better than REO and Journey in 2003 on the Main Event tour.
Ehwmatt wrote:If I'm going to a show with my buddies to drink, rock, and have a great time, Foreigner and Styx will 100% guaranteed blow Journey away due to Journey's truncated setlist and the clunkers they have to play because of it. Foreigner and Styx just rock more during these shortened sets and their stage presence crushes Journey's, even if Perry were there.
If I'm going to a show with my girlfriend, we'll enjoy Journey more.
Given the choice of 3 hour shows from each with good setlists, I'd probably enjoy Journey the most unless Arnel had a bad night.
steveo777 wrote:roycap wrote:Journey has the better song catalog, but Foreigner and Styx will blow them away live. Pineda is still raw and is not a polished lead singer. Styx and Foreigner
will get the better reviews.
You're on crack. Pineda is not a newbie.
parfait wrote:steveo777 wrote:roycap wrote:Journey has the better song catalog, but Foreigner and Styx will blow them away live. Pineda is still raw and is not a polished lead singer. Styx and Foreigner
will get the better reviews.
You're on crack. Pineda is not a newbie.
That still doesn't change the fact that Pineda looks like a drugged up Duracell bunny on stage. He got no presence what so ever. Good voice, but that's about it.
SF-Dano wrote:Ehwmatt wrote:If I'm going to a show with my buddies to drink, rock, and have a great time, Foreigner and Styx will 100% guaranteed blow Journey away due to Journey's truncated setlist and the clunkers they have to play because of it. Foreigner and Styx just rock more during these shortened sets and their stage presence crushes Journey's, even if Perry were there.
If I'm going to a show with my girlfriend, we'll enjoy Journey more.
Given the choice of 3 hour shows from each with good setlists, I'd probably enjoy Journey the most unless Arnel had a bad night.
Not to be harsh, and you are entitled to your opinion, but Foreigner will most likely play "I"ve Been Waiting for A Girl Like You", "I Wanna Know What Love Is", "Urgent', "That Was Yesterday", "Girl on The Moon", "Say You Will". They have some nice rockers as does Journey, but when you include the above in there set, I still don't see how they blow Journey away.
I saw Foreigner open for Journey back in 99 (i believe it was), and it was not even close. Journey by a mile. And for the record, I do like Foreigner.
I saw Foreigner open for Journey back in 99 (i believe it was), and it was not even close. Journey by a mile. And for the record, I do like Foreigner.
roycap wrote:I saw Foreigner open for Journey back in 99 (i believe it was), and it was not even close. Journey by a mile. And for the record, I do like Foreigner.
This is a different band with Kelly Hansen as lead singer than with a less than 100% Lou Gramm in '99. I saw Styx 2 weeks ago and they sound great. In fact, every time I have seen them over the years, their live show is tight. I love Journey, but Pineda is all over the stage like a Hyperactive child. It becomes distracting.
But, there's just something different about going from "I've Been Waiting For a Girl Like You" to a song like "Hot blooded" or "Juke Box Hero." They just rock harder. Don't get me wrong, I like Journey music better, but in a live setting, even the Foreigner ballads have a lot more balls than the Joureny ones - they're moodier; Journey's are sugary.
SF-Dano wrote: I don't even know if I can even make that concession with "Open Arms".
roycap wrote:Journey has the better song catalog, but Foreigner and Styx will blow them away live. Pineda is still raw and is not a polished lead singer. Styx and Foreigner
will get the better reviews.
froy wrote:roycap wrote:Journey has the better song catalog, but Foreigner and Styx will blow them away live. Pineda is still raw and is not a polished lead singer. Styx and Foreigner
will get the better reviews.
All 3 are cover bands so who cares
steveo777 wrote:froy wrote:roycap wrote:Journey has the better song catalog, but Foreigner and Styx will blow them away live. Pineda is still raw and is not a polished lead singer. Styx and Foreigner
will get the better reviews.
All 3 are cover bands so who cares
Last time I checked Perry didn't own the Journey name.
If you wanna go there we can say Journey became a cover band when Rolie or Fleschman left.
Michigan Girl wrote:it doesn't show you in your best light, which is already
after sunset
hoagiepete wrote:Sorry to repeat myself, but Journey had better bring their "A" game every night. If they do, they can hang, if not, aka Styx, Reo, Journey tour, they'll appear bored and boring.
Saw Foreigner a couple of months ago and their set rocked. If I recall they played I Want to Know what Love is and maybe one other ballad, but it did not slow the pace down at all. Crowd was rocking from the start and were on their feet after the encore wanting more. Kelly Hansen is by far, without a doubt, the best replacement singer, all things considered, of any I have heard. The real deal.
I've never left a Styx show disappointed. I've left wishing DDY was still there, but not disappointed as they are always high energy and entertaining.
I'm looking forward to it.
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 21 guests