Moderator: Andrew
George_g888 wrote:When I think of iconic signers, Steve Augeri definitely comes to mind.
George_g888 wrote:Yes sarcasm.
I love augeri, and realize he needs to make a buck somehow. But come on....
tj wrote:I don't mind Augeri any more than I do Payne. If they had Hansen instead of Gramm, I would be fine with that as well. All 3 of those guys didn't originate the hits, but certainly paid their dues over the years keeping the bands going. They also contributed to new music with the groups, so it isn't like they just are karaoke. Maybe not the hits that we know the bands for, but should Journey stop playing all Rolie era songs because Cain replaced him 35 years ago?
STORY_TELLER wrote:tj wrote:I don't mind Augeri any more than I do Payne. If they had Hansen instead of Gramm, I would be fine with that as well. All 3 of those guys didn't originate the hits, but certainly paid their dues over the years keeping the bands going. They also contributed to new music with the groups, so it isn't like they just are karaoke. Maybe not the hits that we know the bands for, but should Journey stop playing all Rolie era songs because Cain replaced him 35 years ago?
Yeah, I don't know dude. Not feeling your reasoning here. Perry, Neal, Ross and Smitty were also involved in the creation of the songs that were created with Rollie in the mix so, sorry, but the math doesn't work in your favor on this. Especially when Perry was the driving writing force in the band before Cain took over for Rollie. Not saying that in a mean way, just scratching my head.
See I'm a firm believer in maintaining truth and accuracy in history, so what I take issue with is the way the show is being promoted. Augeri is not an Icon on any level (neither is Hansen for that matter). Augeri did not create material that has stood the test of time. He's touring other people's songs that have stood the test of time. It's one thing if you've been hired to sing those songs by the very band that created them. It's quite another to go out there with a backing band to tour them as if they were yours all along. Chalfant is out there doing the same thing now and Hugo's been doing it for years. All 3 of these guys had musical careers of their own. Now they're out there singing tunes they had nothing to do with? They should all be sending Neal, Jon and Perry a royalty check.
Again, if Augeri was out there singing songs off Arrival and Generations, I would have no problem with it. But to be out there singing Perry's songs? It smacks of history revision for the people who don't know any better, and I don't respect it.
tj wrote:I see your point, just don't agree totally, which is OK. That's what makes these boards fun. I agree that Augeri and Hansen (who I know isn't participating in this) aren't icons. Some would argue that Rolie isn't either - though I would disagree with that. I had never heard of John Payne until a few years ago, so he isn't either in my book. So you really get Zander and Gramm (Rolie if anyone outside of hardcore Journey and Santana fans know who he is). Maybe it should be "3 Rock Icons and Some Guys Who Replaced Icons".
I am pretty sure that Neal, Jon and Perry do get royalty checks as songwriters for whomever is singing. Perry sang Journey songs during his FTLOSM tour. He partially wrote some of them (or maybe all), but didn't make them famous as Steve Perry. He sang Wheel in the Sky for years, but it he didn't write it (Fleischman was partially credited). Short of the same members in a band from beginning through the money years to today, it's pretty murky to me, so that's why I am OK with it. Outside of U2, I can't think of any bands who are still together from beginning album to today. There probably are some, I just can't think of them.
I guess I think that if you were hired by the band and a member at one point, particularly if you were the lead singer, you can have at it. I would much rather hear Augeri (on a good night) singing Open Arms than Mariah Carey.
Another take, which is interesting to me is Don Felder of the Eagles. He wrote the music to Hotel California and has been playing it and other Eagles songs - which he was never the lead singer on - during his tours for several years.
tj wrote:I don't mind Augeri any more than I do Payne. If they had Hansen instead of Gramm, I would be fine with that as well. All 3 of those guys didn't originate the hits, but certainly paid their dues over the years keeping the bands going. They also contributed to new music with the groups, so it isn't like they just are karaoke. Maybe not the hits that we know the bands for, but should Journey stop playing all Rolie era songs because Cain replaced him 35 years ago?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 28 guests