Art Vandelay wrote:I was young when they were in their heyday, so I don't really remember the vibe of the band back then. I was probably more of a casual fan until Greatest Hits. Were they always looked at and identified as Neal's Band? Was he ever considered the driving factor/selling point of the band? Or did this identity really come to the foreground after Perry left?
Every video, interview and article that I have seen, heard or read from back then paints the picture of a collaborative band with Herbie at the wheel. Perry and Schon are always mentioned as the driving forces, but I don't remember ever seeing anything from this time that really paints it as Neal's band. Was that something that was understood back then?
No, I would say your assessment is spot on. Herbie was THE business leader, even hiring and firing members. If any one band member was considered the "leader" of Journey, it would be Steve Perry...especially after ROR. For ROR, the band had to agree to let him produce the album...Perry's story is that his mom asked him to do another Journey album rather than do another solo album and that is how he decided. Regardless, Perry had control of the band at that point.
What Neal is doing is rebranding Journey to be 'his' band. it NEVER WAS. If you remember interviews, Herbie wanted Journey to be a "family" sorta band. He compared the Grateful Dead to his vision for Journey. That is what existed until around 1983 and Perry starting to demand more influence and control. Neal AND Jonathan were always in the background...the way Jonathan still is today.
Until the last year or so, the story was that Gregg approached Herbie about hiring Jonathan...it was not Neal's decision. I don't know if Neal claimed he hired Steve Smith but the story was that Herbie was tired of Aynsley's teenage girlfriends and treating the band like a second hand job because he could make more money as a session drummer...so he fired him and hired Steve Smith. And, if you remember, Herbie basically forced Steve Perry on the band with a "he's the new lead singer...get used to it!" attitude. Neal had no power back then, especially over Herbie. He has always wanted Journey to be like Van Halen...the problem is that the band's name is not "Schon" and Journey was never viewed as "Neal's band."
So, now he is trying to reverse that with his lines about him founding the band, being at every concert, etc. He is demanding control over the band...something he legally can't have...but, publicly he wants the fans to see it that way.