Moderator: Andrew
Majestic wrote:I hope you all followed the link to the article and then listened to the interview, because it is even a better listen than read.
Arkansas wrote:Like I've suggested before - he needs to let Schon & Cain finish his work. I mean, he talks about "the magic of the band", yet he says his latest work isn't as good as the previous work. Duh! He needs Journey to make it like they used to. He can't do it on his own. I think it's apparent that none of them can.
G.I.Jim wrote:That was a pretty good read, but just like every other interview... he's fighting his own demons and will never release anything.I honestly don't think we're ever going to hear another Perry album while he's alive, and the thought of that really sucks. I know his vocals aren't what they used to be, but I would love his new album regardless. I know it would still be good, and I would be happy just to be hearing something new. I think he sounds much better than most people think, but I don't think we'll ever get that conformation. Sad...
Arkansas wrote:Like I've suggested before - he needs to let Schon & Cain finish his work. I mean, he talks about "the magic of the band", yet he says his latest work isn't as good as the previous work. Duh! He needs Journey to make it like they used to. He can't do it on his own. I think it's apparent that none of them can.
later~
swataz wrote:Arkansas wrote:Like I've suggested before - he needs to let Schon & Cain finish his work. I mean, he talks about "the magic of the band", yet he says his latest work isn't as good as the previous work. Duh! He needs Journey to make it like they used to. He can't do it on his own. I think it's apparent that none of them can.
Quote of the day, to me.
Pacfanweb wrote:I get that Perry is obviously very sensitive about what his voice can do these days, but damn dude.....NOBODY with a hint of reasoning ability would expect a 60 year old to have the same voice he did when he was younger. If you did, you'd be the first person in history to have it.
I suggest he take a listen to some of the older singers that still perform today, and see how his current voice stacks up against theirs......you don't need to be listening to people like Adam Lambert or that dude from Train....you would have been hard pressed to keep up with those dudes when you were 40.
Listen to Roger Daltrey. His voice is terrible, long gone, yet people still flock to see him. Just like they'd come to see you.
Robert Plant...he's had no high register since the early 80's. Still sells out whenever he tours.
Why? Because Daltrey is still Daltrey, and Plant is still Plant. They still sound like who they are, even if they can't hit all the notes.
I'm going to go out on a limb, with little evidence either way, and say that I think Perry's voice is in better shape than either of these two guys.
Can he still sing Open Arms and not miss a note? Hell no, he didn't even do that back in the day. So what? I bet nobody who went to those shows even remembers he ducked the high notes in that song.
My suggestion for Perry (and I've made this one before) is to do what Garth Brooks did. Go to Vegas, and just play on the weekends. Maybe Friday and Sunday. Get a taste for it, smaller crowds, it'll sell out instantly, and then you'll be able to show what you still have. Then people will know, and neither you nor they will be expecting too much if you decide to do a real tour sometime.
Just DO it.
It doesn't matter what critics will say....even if you somehow showed up with your voice from the early days, critics would still find something to complain about. Screw 'em. Just sing, from the vibe I get from your interviews, I believe it would make you (and us) happy. Might be the only thing that would make you happy now.
swataz wrote:Pacfanweb wrote:I get that Perry is obviously very sensitive about what his voice can do these days, but damn dude.....NOBODY with a hint of reasoning ability would expect a 60 year old to have the same voice he did when he was younger. If you did, you'd be the first person in history to have it.
I suggest he take a listen to some of the older singers that still perform today, and see how his current voice stacks up against theirs......you don't need to be listening to people like Adam Lambert or that dude from Train....you would have been hard pressed to keep up with those dudes when you were 40.
Listen to Roger Daltrey. His voice is terrible, long gone, yet people still flock to see him. Just like they'd come to see you.
Robert Plant...he's had no high register since the early 80's. Still sells out whenever he tours.
Why? Because Daltrey is still Daltrey, and Plant is still Plant. They still sound like who they are, even if they can't hit all the notes.
I'm going to go out on a limb, with little evidence either way, and say that I think Perry's voice is in better shape than either of these two guys.
Can he still sing Open Arms and not miss a note? Hell no, he didn't even do that back in the day. So what? I bet nobody who went to those shows even remembers he ducked the high notes in that song.
My suggestion for Perry (and I've made this one before) is to do what Garth Brooks did. Go to Vegas, and just play on the weekends. Maybe Friday and Sunday. Get a taste for it, smaller crowds, it'll sell out instantly, and then you'll be able to show what you still have. Then people will know, and neither you nor they will be expecting too much if you decide to do a real tour sometime.
Just DO it.
It doesn't matter what critics will say....even if you somehow showed up with your voice from the early days, critics would still find something to complain about. Screw 'em. Just sing, from the vibe I get from your interviews, I believe it would make you (and us) happy. Might be the only thing that would make you happy now.
My NEW quote of the day! VEry well said, and spot on, IMO.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest