by Pacfanweb » Fri Jul 08, 2011 1:03 pm
I'm starting to think the dude probably can still sing a bit, but he's just simply a huge procrastinator. He doesn't HAVE to sing for a living. He doesn't HAVE to record.....no contract to require an album by a particular date. He'd LIKE to make one, but I think he just gets up in the morning and thinks "eh, maybe tomorrow, I'm going to the baseball game/Disneyland/U2 concert/etc."
I mean, can he sing Stone in Love in the original key anymore? Probably not. But I don't think in any way that he can't sing at all....come one, can he raise his voice? That's part of what singing is. Yelling in tune. You telling me he can't yell at someone now? I seriously doubt it.
I've mentioned this before, but Elton John was originally a tenor, and is now a baritone. People still love him and go to his shows. He sings his same old songs in his newer voice, and people still sing along and love it.
Perry could do the same thing, IMO. Just make it clear up front we won't be hearing the old stuff "like he used to do it". Do it in whatever key you can manage. You'll still sound like Steve Perry. And people will still love it. Just DO it. Don't keep teasing people with "I'm going to rent some studio time and record this stuff", etc, or hint at how you still might tour one day.
Normally, I'd say you don't owe us anything, but if you keep promising that you'll do something, then I think you at least owe us a "when" or a "no, I never will or and "I simply cannot".